What's new

Ahmadis in Pakistan

Status
Not open for further replies.
This all Ahmedi Episode started after killing in Lahore. They got killed by same terrorist who killed thousands of Muslims in other and in Lahore area of Pakistan. But making Ahmadi killing an issue is Discrimination with rest of the people of Pakistan.



BTW this thread was started by an Indian. And i can guarantee he didn't care about Ahmadis. He just wanted to create a topic where they can troll.
 

Dont speak if you dont knwo anything about islam. Search a little then come and rant.

The 6 Kalimas

I am not ranting. I am against the rigidity.

If someone goes against the wish of kalimas then by any means is the might of the creator compromised??

The reason for any religion to exists is that it should pave the way for individuals to seek spiritual enlightenment. Technical protocols are just to maintain the periphery of religion. These protocols should not serve as a means of authoritative bindings.

Theres a saying that thre are as many ways to reach god as there are number of people on this earth. Let the ahmedis take whatever way they like to reach allah. Scriptures should not become obstacle to that.

Its a private affair between the creator and the living being. And that is it.

By your diktat even sufis are not worthy to call themselves muslims as they seeks oneness "in" allah (and not oneness "of" allah)!!

"al-hak" and "annalhaq"(correct me if I am wrong)

P.S. I am not a muslim
 
Last edited:
I want a clear debate with Qadiyanis on the forum right here on this issue.
They do not reveal themselves and dont have guts to say that they are qadiyanis even on the internet.

I think there has to be a discussion we must see what they have got to say .

Oh yaar,

Take it easy. Its not personal. What is it that you can resolve here on these threads? Nothing unfortunately.

Do you think you are the first to have such debates? Much more knowledgeable folks have had these in the past. The only solution is to live and let live with mutual respect for each others beliefs.
 
This forum promotes equality and tolerance of all Pakistanis. The causes of Human rights abuses on all Pakistanis have routinely been proudly championed by this forum.

No one is disputing championing human rights neither we are against it.

This forum proudly close down threads whenever we are trying to champion the cause of human rights of Dalits or low cast Hindus.

You can not shut us up by saying that its Pakistani forum so that cant be debated here because Human Rights are Human Rights and you also claim that this forum is International fora.




This thread is not about anyone incident. Its about the treatment meted out to Ahmedis by the state and law.

Then weed out the thread and post only those laws of the state which you think are discriminatory and which we would open heartly debate.


In fact its simply preventing 10-20 threads from opening up over and over, less clutter, more discussion. Sticky is not some award of honor.

This singling out one community if so in future you have to open up sticky threads for shia sunni, deobandis, bralvis too.

The simple soultion should have been that you should have opened a thread with asking if Forum members and Muslims on this forum support any violence against our qadyani countrymen or not .

And Trust me non of us support that.


The Quran can, the constitution should not.


That is also not in discussion here. The state can't pass judgments on matters of faith. You can, to yourself and anybody who will listen to you. Not the state.

The Pakistani Constitution is said to be based on Islamic teachings and in this case The State is only following what Quran said about who is who. Simple as that. There is no difference between Quran and Our constitution over Issue of Muslims and Non-Muslims.




These are all your beliefs, they don't believe they were created by the British. They can believe and proclaim what they believe, you can what you belief.

There is a big difference between belief and an argument sure here they can differ with me that who have created qadyanis. They can post their history and i will post my argument


Sure why not? And they have the right to argue against the Muslims. Whoever has the better argument, wins.


Sure if they can prove the Quran and this akeeda of Khatm-e-Nabowat wrong. They are welcomed to prove it wrong.


I heard you questioning my faith and belief in another thread about that kazzab issue. Here i question your this stance and hypocrisy.



Are they asking anyone's hand in marriage that your acceptance is even a question here? You can call them King Kong for all they care. But they can call themselves whatever they want.

neither we are asking for their hands nor we are stopping them from calling themselves anything. We are just saying if they do so in violation of pure basic Islamic rules then they are kazzabs and liars simple as that.



What if somebody started saying everything Muslims say is a lie? This is all a matter of faith. You can't bring Allah to testify that Muslims are correct and Ahmedis are wrong? What if someone said "Each time Muslims say Allah exists, lets kill them for that is a lie".

And this is not even hypothetical, we had to run from the Quraysh when they did that to us, today you're fighting so hard to emulate the Quraysh.


Many non-Muslims say so and we dont kill them for saying so.

And again why you are twisting the words who is saying kill them ??????????



Again no one is saying accept them, let them say what they want, then you can reject what they say but you can't throw them in jail for saying what they want.


Thats what we are saying dear. Where any of us said that throw them in jail??

What is discriminatory when Islam defines the rules for you so if you are willing to accept these rules you are welcomed to be a Muslim if you do not then Islam defines ok You are on to your faith and we are on to our faith.

Islam gives you clear choice.


Its like when you go to any country they have rules they give you the guidelines if you are willing to follow that guideline you are welcomed if not you are rejected simple as that.
 
They do not reveal themselves and dont have guts to say that they are qadiyanis even on the internet.

:rolleyes:

God Bless Self Righteous Muslims with Guts & Glory, All Hail Pakistani GOv for perfectly orchestrating this division for their use
 
You are right. Unfortunately to understand why these issues crop up for the poor Ahmedis, inevitably you have to understand what the primary punga/gripe is.

Otherwise we will say, this and this should not happen. But in reality it will continue to happen because there will be many who will realize the crux of the issue is unresolved.

I will stop here on my rants because I think I am actually undermining AM's efforts to keep the thread off the theological issues.
;)

It has to happen one day bro , we gotta develop an understanding and if this thread is all about Condemning discrimination against qadiyanis without knowing that why this is happening to them then its my last post on this thread.:coffee:
 
This all Ahmedi Episode started after killing in Lahore. They got killed by same terrorist who killed thousands of Muslims in other and in Lahore area of Pakistan. But making Ahmadi killing an issue is Discrimination with rest of the people of Pakistan.



BTW this thread was started by an Indian. And i can guarantee he didn't care about Ahmadis. He just wanted to create a topic where they can troll.

The admins think otherwise and are not willing to see this incident as terrorism.

qadyanis have been targeted individually by terrorists from Lashkar-e-Jhangvi in the past which also targeted Muslim shias now tell me what is so big about qadyanis??


This attack in Lahore prompted this thread to be made sticky which in my personal view is not justified because that was a terrorist attack and more such attacks have been made on Muslims.
 
@ EMO KID:

Internet should allow them to say that they are qadiyanis there is no GOP involved in PDF its an Independant forum where you can have your say without getting anybody to stop you.

I am inviting them to come and talk , i wana see what they have got to say.
They can discuss their beliefs with us , we will map them with Mainstream islam and we will see who is wrong fair enough?

Maybe if will give you some peace too.
 
Oh yaar,

Take it easy. Its not personal. What is it that you can resolve here on these threads? Nothing unfortunately.

Do you think you are the first to have such debates? Much more knowledgeable folks have had these in the past. The only solution is to live and let live with mutual respect for each others beliefs.

I have NEVER denied it , this is what i want lets develop an understanding and finish this debate once and for all .

This is a forum where we cannot openly share Islamic material or discuss theology but in last few months there have been half a dozen threads on Qadiyanis:D


It has to happen i just want to have their say and to provide them a chance of saying out loud that who they are.
 
I am not ranting. I am against the rigidity.

If someone goes against the wish of kalimas then by any means is the might of the creator compromised??

The reason for any religion to exists is that it should pave the way for individuals to seek spiritual enlightenment. Technical protocols are just to maintain the periphery of religion. These protocols should not serve as a means of authoritative bindings.

Theres a saying that thre are as many ways to reach god as there are number of people on this earth. Let the ahmedis take whatever way they like to reach allah. Scriptures should not become obstacle to that.

Its a private affair between the creator and the living being. And that is it.

By your diktat even sufis are not worthy to call themselves muslims as they seeks oneness "in" allah (and not oneness "of" allah)!!

"al-hak" and "annalhaq"(correct me if I am wrong)
Simple answer. Do what ever you want to do with Budhism, Hinduism. I have no problem. Dont tell us that we should change Islam. Islam IS NOT BUDHISM.

Allah Is one and Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) is last prophet of Allah. There is no Prophet after Muhammad (S.A.W)
 
The discrimination isn't from the constitution of Pakistan, It has followers of MGQ listed as non-Muslims, along with Christians, Hindu's and others. It entails them to all the rights these minorities have enjoyed and will enjoy. The classification of non-Muslims is justified, correct and by the will of the majority of the people. Have a plebiscite if you must.
The discrimination is due to the efforts of the Qadiyani's to have themselves recognized as Muslims. They WILL never be accepted as such by any Muslim who has taken the time to read and understand the Quran alone and with help from various scholars from all schools of thought.
I agree that only god has the right to decide if one was a true Muslim or not but being a Muslim you have to meet the minimum condition of accepting Mohammad as the last prophet.What the Qadiyani's seem to adhere to is akin to saying " I like staring at bare men and engage in sodomy but I'm very straight" .
Now, whether the Muslim community should by large stop treating the Qadiyani's as non-Muslims is an impossible demand since I have outlined earlier. Don't go near anything that concerns the prophet and his status.
To gain any acceptance as Muslims the Qadiyani's must declare publicaly that THEY do not accept any of the teachings of Mirza Ghulam Ahmed Qadiyani.
Nothing less will gain them acceptance from Muslim majority including myself.

However, till then, they can live as non-Muslims in Pakistan and yes the GoP is compelled to give them protection as equal citizens of Pakistan as defined in the constitution regarding non-Muslims.
 
Spirituality is one aspect, however Islam to us is a complete system by which one lives their life. It deals with a lot of very minute, tactical issues as well as the ones in the higher spiritual realm.

As Muslims, we believe the teachings of prophet Jesus were incomplete and with his second coming, he too will bring about a lot of the very detailed, nuanced teachings to his adherents, which is in stark contrast to the higher spiritual level message of "love thy neighbour".

In line with this, for #2, Having faith in Allah and his last prophet as the seal of the prophets is the basic requirement of being a Muslim. On this aspect, there is no room for disagreement. I understand it can come across as very rigid, but this is the case.
Excellent.
A clear explanation. Appreciated.


Re: "love thy neighbour"
The followers of Jesus do understand and follow it but
not in full. They only love the 'Neighbours Wife'
Cheerio.
 
You are right. Unfortunately to understand why these issues crop up for the poor Ahmedis, inevitably you have to understand what the primary punga/gripe is.

Otherwise we will say, this and this should not happen. But in reality it will continue to happen because there will be many who will realize the crux of the issue is unresolved.

I will stop here on my rants because I think I am actually undermining AM's efforts to keep the thread off the theological issues. ;)

Blain i also want to stop posting here but this thread in itself is dealing with theological issues and clearly some people are advocating qadyaniat as truth and branch of Islam which is clearly clashing with Islamic faith.


Tomorrow any Hindu will stand up and claim he is the prophet (nazobillah) do think we should accept it as his right to do so and we should not tell him that its against Islam?
 
Don't speak, don't call yourself Muslim... What is this? Why should we Pakistanis listen to tyrants or become Tyrants?
Any one Not Accepting One Allah and Muhammad As last prophet is not Muslim.

Simple as that
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom