World War II Indian heroism recalled in Egypt

[scorpionx]

are u proud that your grandpader was a slave to british crown and was serving the crown?

First Its not just being a slave. We were slaves not at our own choice.But what we can do definitely is the choice of our own. That's why some of our ancestors chose a man's way to live.Some "thing" never to be ashamed off.

 

[4 2 0]

our soldiers weren't fighting for any country they fought and died for humanity to save the humankind from the evils of nazism

you retarded man what is evil of nazism?
you were just a slave of crown
the crown gave u a danda and enrolled into british army and then you fought.

there were those who dident took the danda but they gave danda to british crown.

what about indische legion of hitlers and your indian national hero chander bose?

 

[Desert Fox]

......................


I don't know how much Muslim participated in world war ! it must be very few , like Freedom fighter very low were Muslims , Muhammad ali jina never went to jail for any freedom strike in his lifetime.

"Tiger" Niazi fought the Japanese in Burma i believe, he did some heroic act of valor for which he earned the title "Tiger".

Too bad he and other men like him didn't utilize their strength and skills against the bloody brits.

 

[scorpionx]

what about indische legion of hitlers and your indian national hero chander bose?

Thanks for showing your idea about "Chander" Bose.

 

[Desert Fox]

First Its not just being a slave. We were slaves not at our own choice.But what we can do definitely is the choice of our own. That's why some of our ancestors chose a man's way to live.Some "thing" never to be ashamed off.

A "man's way to live" by serving the brits and churchill, the same brits and churchill who're responsible for the many famines in the subcontinent, as a result of which millions of subcontinentals died. Yet we have people spewing nonsense propaganda against Hitler and the Germans, a man and a nation who never enslaved 500 million people.

 

[scorpionx]

A "man's way to live" by serving the brits and churchill, the same brits and churchill who're responsible for the many famines in the subcontinent, as a result of which millions of subcontinentals died. Yet we have people spewing nonsense propaganda against Hitler and the Germans, a man and a nation who never enslaved 500 million people.

I respect your opinion. The British in subcontinent,Russians in Poland were no saint either.But Japan was at our doorsteps and it was an ally of Hitler.So "technically" we were right when we chose to fight against Nazis.

 

[joekrish]

you retarded man what is evil of nazism?
you were just a slave of crown
the crown gave u a danda and enrolled into british army and then you fought.

there were those who dident took the danda but they gave danda to british crown.

what about indische legion of hitlers and your indian national hero chander bose?

A soldier is a soldier they do not become less brave because they faught under someone and that is what we are here to talk about, by the by do you think less of your soldiers because they are fighting for the American cause?

I just fail to understand the logic of a retard calling others a retard.

 

[Azazel]

you retarded man what is evil of nazism?
you were just a slave of crown
the crown gave u a danda and enrolled into british army and then you fought.

there were those who dident took the danda but they gave danda to british crown.

what about indische legion of hitlers and your indian national hero chander bose?

Nice,You are saying while you are living in UK.Look at the irony.Most of these hypocrites don't know that it is because their grandfathers were British subjects(a.k.a slaves) they were able emigrate to UK.British commonwealth citizens had extensive rights to migrate to UK.

 

[Android]

you retarded man what is evil of nazism?
you were just a slave of crown
the crown gave u a danda and enrolled into british army and then you fought.

there were those who dident took the danda but they gave danda to british crown.

what about indische legion of hitlers and your indian national hero chander bose?

idiot if britain would have been defeated and axis powers would have managed conquer entire asia then as per axis plans we would have been under japanese occupation and trust me going through their acts in other regions they would have been far worse than britishers. Joining the war on the side of allies was in our best interest
Axis power negotiations on the division of Asia during World War II - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[niaz]

"Tiger" Niazi fought the Japanese in Burma i believe, he did some heroic act of valor for which he earned the title "Tiger".

Too bad he and other men like him didn't utilize their strength and skills against the bloody brits.

Coward Niazi may have been decorated by the British during Burma campaign when he was only a Lieutenant. However it is easy to follow orders and command a platoon. Fighting a war as leader of nearly one lakh soldiers is a different matter. Anyone who has read Hamoodur Rahman report will understand that Lt Gen Niazi was no tiger. In fact he was an incompetent cowardly general who was, is and will remain a black sheep responsible for the most ignominious defeat of the Pakistan Army.

We need another coward Niazi like we need a hole in the head.

PS.

Justice Hamood ur Rahman (Chief Justice of Supreme Court of Pakistan) Commission was formed by ZAB to investigate reasons of the East Pakistan debacle. Commission included Justice Sh. Anwarul Haq & Justice Tufail Abdur Rahman, with retired Lt Gen Altaf Qadir as military advisor.

The report was result of diligent interviews of 300 witnesses and analysis of hundreds of classified army communications between GHQ and East Pakistan Command. The conclusions are therefore based on facts.

Report was also highly critical of the role played by ZAB and the Peoples Party Thus, even though ordered by ZA Bhutto himself; the final report submitted submitted in October 1974 was kept under wraps for 26 years until declassified by Musharraf in December 2000.

 

[4 2 0]

all the indians gone mad in qadian.

actually the british crown gave a danda to mirza ghulam qadian and they all joined the services of crown.

 

[ajtr]

My grand father was part of the battle, he was recalled very late from the front.

All Muslim soldiers were held back and Sikhs were sent early, which aggravated the massacre of Muslims at time of partition.

This is first hand version from my grandfather.

How similar are these types of stories in india too of muslim soldiers were called back and hindus/sikh remain.but of course stories being stories.

 

[Abingdonboy]

My grand father was part of the battle, he was recalled very late from the front.

All Muslim soldiers were held back and Sikhs were sent early, which aggravated the massacre of Muslims at time of partition.

This is first hand version from my grandfather.

Yep that's right- no Indian Sikh or Hindu soldier died throughout WW1/2, it was only Indian Muslims.

 

[474474]

To the genius who reported this, India didnt exist back then. If it did, it was only on british maps and documents, otherwise it was only h-stan for millenia

 

[Android]

To the genius who reported this, India didnt exist back then. If it did, it was only on british maps and documents, otherwise it was only h-stan for millenia

the word india was used in west to denote subcontinent since ancient times just like the term hindustan used in middle east/central asia and tianzhu was used in east asia while inhabitants of this land used to call it bharat