Why has India traditionally adopted a defensive policy on Pakistan?

[Water Car Engineer]

• In 1965, when Pakistani forces infiltrated J&K during Operation Gibraltar, India chickened out again. Instead of retaliating at Pakistani weak points such as East Pakistan, it opened another war front in Punjab which pakistanis defended vigorously.

It wasnt about chickening out, but drawing you away from Kashmir, which worked perfectly. Kashmir wasnt armed well than, there were only light French tanks there for example.

 

[third eye]

It is gratifying to see Pakistanis thinking that India's policy towards them is defensive.

I wish the Pak Govt & ISI too would feel the same.

 

[GURU DUTT]

Hi,

You have opened up a great thread----. Time and weapons procurement is on Pakistan's side----. The only thing that they are left with is smart talk and sharp rhetoric---.

In due time----they are also going to lose that as well. Their terrorists labelling policy against Pakistan has failed----their maligning the world against Pakistan has failed----.

With the exposure of their terrorist affiliations with MQM---they are not in position to convince the world of their innocence anymore----.

slaam mastan saheb even if we beleve that what you are saying is true even then pakistan will be shown no symoathy by the westerners and india will not be treated like pakistan nor indians point of view will be brushed aside as they need us more than they need you now
as they say samrath ko dosh nahi goaseen ..... or in jatt bhashaa jinke ghar danne unke kamle bhi sayaane .... aage aap khud samjhdaar ho

 

[MastanKhan]

slaam mastan saheb even if we beleve that what you are saying is true even then pakistan will be shown no symoathy by the westerners and india will not be treated like pakistan nor indians point of view will be brushed aside as they need us more than they need you now
as they say samrath ko dosh nahi goaseen ..... or in jatt bhashaa jinke ghar danne unke kamle bhi sayaane .... aage aap khud samjhdaar ho

Hi,

That is incorrect----. Actually---Pakistan has the western countries by the ballz at this time----due to the western countries creation of isis. They don't have anywhere to run.

Turkey does not want to fight them----Saudi Arabia is a lame military----. Iran will only do so much to keep its position strong----.

India had a great act for the last 8 years----but now the steam has run out of it----.

All the indian economy is teetering on a very sharp edge----. 10-20 blasts in major I T hubs and all the foreigners would be running out of the country.

Guru---Chalakian tou aap bahut martay hein Kamloan or Sianoon ki----but have you ever heard " make peace while you are ahead---beware of bad things to come "----.

The terrorists only have to succeed one time.

After getting its arse thrashed for 14 years----even the U S---with its tail between its legs---had to come to the peace table with the Taliban in Murree this month.

The American verdict now is----God bless the Taliban----the isis are a monster---please stop them from spreading in Afghanistan.

The only problem with you guys right now is---that most of you have not been thru that moment where you say---" Oh Lord----I wish I had done it different if I knew that things would get that bad "---.

 

[JonAsad]

for once i agree had the positions swapped we would have eaten the tiny indians alive by 71-

 

[manojb]

Hi,

That is incorrect----. Actually---Pakistan has the western countries by the ballz at this time----due to the western countries creation of isis. They don't have anywhere to run.

Turkey does not want to fight them----Saudi Arabia is a lame military----. Iran will only do so much to keep its position strong----.

India had a great act for the last 8 years----but now the steam has run out of it----.

All the indian economy is teetering on a very sharp edge----. 10-20 blasts in major I T hubs and all the foreigners would be running out of the country.

Guru---Chalakian tou aap bahut martay hein Kamloan or Sianoon ki----but have you ever heard " make peace while you are ahead---beware of bad things to come "----.

The terrorists only have to succeed one time.

After getting its arse thrashed for 14 years----even the U S---with its tail between its legs---had to come to the peace table with the Taliban in Murree this month.

The American verdict now is----God bless the Taliban----the isis are a monster---please stop them from spreading in Afghanistan.

The only problem with you guys right now is---that most of you have not been thru that moment where you say---" Oh Lord----I wish I had done it different if I knew that things would get that bad "---.

Wow... man you serious ly need mental assessment. . Word is schizophrenia. Get well soon mastan mian.

 

[MastanKhan]

Wow... man you serious ly need mental assessment. . Word is schizophrenia. Get well soon mastan mian.

Hi,

Thank you very much for your concern----. Thinking and praying about the ailments of others is indeed a SAINTLY consideration.

 

[I M Sikander]

It is gratifying to see Pakistanis thinking that India's policy towards them is defensive.

I wish the Pak Govt & ISI too would feel the same.

How you come to this nonsense conclusion.

 

[vinay]

Hi,

You have opened up a great thread----. Time and weapons procurement is on Pakistan's side----. The only thing that they are left with is smart talk and sharp rhetoric---.

In due time----they are also going to lose that as well. Their terrorists labelling policy against Pakistan has failed----their maligning the world against Pakistan has failed----.

With the exposure of their terrorist affiliations with MQM---they are not in position to convince the world of their innocence anymore----.

As any pakistani would say " where is the proof" ?
if you really think you have all the evidences then take it to court of law and punish mqm

 

[Kaniska]

The answer is simple...

1- Although we,India, shout loudly towards Pakistan posters, but honestly, it is not like we all would like to Pakistan as a nation crumbles and people dies because of war..India and its politician are not affensive in nature not in attitude.
2- My above statement is true except 2 people such as Indira Gandhi and Narendra Modi...
3- To be honest, India even do not like to take up other parts of Kashmir...Other parts of Kashmir is only needed to create connectivity with Cenyral Asia..Otherwise, India and its people are well aware that We are good and happy with whatever we have it right now..
4- The most imporant thing is that, out priority is always different...Our people and mindset is not war prone mindset...No one talks about war and all these things...People put pressure on Gov for develpment of the nation..No one want to stay in anxiety of war..And on top of that except BJP,rest of the political parties feel that if India fight with Pakistan, then they loose the Muslim vote. I am not sure how much this is true, but this is the mindset for which they never get aggressive..That is the same reason why BJP is aggressive to Pakistan because Muslim more or less do not vote for BJP and this BJP does not carry this liability of being good with the Muslims...
5- Although Pakistan feels that India is bleeding in Kashmir, but in the real term, it is not so much money for India so that they will bend back to listen to the terms of Pakistan....So in the quest of funding terrorist to Kashmir and India, now Pakistan branded itself so -vely that everyone can see it..And the same terrorist elements are killing innocent civilian of Pakistan now..

 

[Perpendicular]

Traditionally though not Currently

 

[Norwegian]

@Norwegian kindly requesting you to stop using your brain.

To all gullible Pakistanis like yourself, I kindly request you to start using it!

 

[Beta-Fighter]

Hi,

That is incorrect----. Actually---Pakistan has the western countries by the ballz at this time----due to the western countries creation of isis. They don't have anywhere to run.

Turkey does not want to fight them----Saudi Arabia is a lame military----. Iran will only do so much to keep its position strong----.

India had a great act for the last 8 years----but now the steam has run out of it----.

All the indian economy is teetering on a very sharp edge----. 10-20 blasts in major I T hubs and all the foreigners would be running out of the country.

Guru---Chalakian tou aap bahut martay hein Kamloan or Sianoon ki----but have you ever heard " make peace while you are ahead---beware of bad things to come "----.

The terrorists only have to succeed one time.

After getting its arse thrashed for 14 years----even the U S---with its tail between its legs---had to come to the peace table with the Taliban in Murree this month.

The American verdict now is----God bless the Taliban----the isis are a monster---please stop them from spreading in Afghanistan.

The only problem with you guys right now is---that most of you have not been thru that moment where you say---" Oh Lord----I wish I had done it different if I knew that things would get that bad "---.

Just for your Mis information , IT hubs run by Indians and not Foreigners , attack on Mumbai didn't scared them away. You always think wrong strategy and failed like Kargil.

but did you realise what will happen after that.... Nuke not always safe you. and after that their will be to lot of disturbance on your western border + Terrorists camps destroyed along with army on eastern border.


you army already realised in last year gun fight

 

[third eye]

How you come to this nonsense conclusion.

By reading this thread

Did you not read the title ?

 

[Bossman]

Because the Indians have no balls and haven't had any for the last 1,00 years.They love giving the example of 1971, it was not them but the Bengali Muslims who had the balls and Bangladeshis are regretting it now. In any case 1971 made Pakistan stronger.