Why does Kashmir only belong to Muslims?

[Yeti]

Sure.... only brave enough to massacre unarmed civilians... n wet their pants at the sight of tribals with obsolete arms,swords etc and blankets ? a maharajas army shyt their pants n fled at the sight of un equiped tribesmen with axes,swords,daggers,frontier rifles etc and blankets to save them from cold?



The idea ur tryin to sell... as for my old id... yeah i miss it... bad decision..

Well was the alternative solution? another 50 years of bloodshed and wasting resources on the LOC when that money could be better used to serve both our countries its not like we are oil rich like gulf to afford it.

The Musharraf plan was doable why fight over Kashmir when we can just remove borders and make it like free movement of goods and people from yr side and our side that way Kashmir will be free and have peace.

 

[ranjeet]

Sure.... only brave enough to massacre unarmed civilians... n wet their pants at the sight of tribals with obsolete arms,swords etc and blankets ? a maharajas army shyt their pants n fled at the sight of un equiped tribesmen with axes,swords,daggers,frontier rifles etc and blankets to save them from cold?

The army that mattered was there in a flash when the orders came ... n it's still camping down their. So massage your bruised ego with gentle caressing hands because this itch is gonna be there till Armageddon.

 

[waz]

Kashmir belongs to Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs and Buddhists. However the situation is not as idealistic and the state is subtly partitioned on religious lines and with the recent massive sectarian tensions, community cohesion has gone forever.

Let the people decide, but we will only see what I talked about above i.e. Jammu, Ladakh (exempting Kargil) wanting to stay with India and the valley, poonch, rajouri etc joining Pakistan. I took out the independence option as both India and Pakistan have ruled this out.

 

[Solomon2]

But - the rights of the minorities can't be held hostage by the whims and fancies of the majority. Pakistanis of all people should realize - there would have been no Partition then if the idea of Pakistan was put to vote. Neither slavery nor segregation in the USA would have ended either.

Pakistan's philosophy is majoritarian; leaders from Jinnah to Zia held that areas where they declared Muslims were a majority were places they believed should come under Pakistani sovereignty and that under such Muslims should have special rights over non-Muslims. (It differs from superficially-similar Israel in two particular ways: authority and mediation are preferred over law and minorities don't have enforceable rights but only a revocable tolerance.)

As Z.A.B. put it after he learned otherwise in the 1965 war, it is an article of faith among Pakistanis that Muslims in border areas w/India would want to be part of Pakistan; otherwise, they weren't really Muslims. Rather than correct the mis-education of the Pakistani populace, he reinforced and utilized it to achieve power by labeling the people of East Pakistan as Hindus, Ahmadis as non-Muslims, etc. Zia continued the program, making it even more extreme. Pakistan still suffers from the messed-up minds so created.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

No proof...just empty words.

Sure.... only brave enough to massacre unarmed civilians... n wet their pants at the sight of tribals with obsolete arms,swords etc and blankets ? a maharajas army shyt their pants n fled at the sight of un equiped tribesmen with axes,swords,daggers,frontier rifles etc and blankets to save them from cold?



The idea ur tryin to sell... as for my old id... yeah i miss it... bad decision..

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Not so comic for those tourists who came over from your side and are now lying in mass graves.
Whether God would give them Hell or Heaven is for God to decide, but it is our Armed forces' responsibility to make sure the appointment with God is fixed!

Thank you for ur idiotic one-liners.



Comic... haha

It will always suffer from it. The quest for the 'purest Muslim' regime and siasat is infinite. This quest will continue to claim lives. With so much hatred in their hearts, Pakistan does not really require an enemy. As far as killing each other is concerned - they are doing it very well themselves!

Pakistan's philosophy is majoritarian; leaders from Jinnah to Zia held that areas where they declared Muslims were a majority were places they believed should come under Pakistani sovereignty and that under such Muslims should have special rights over non-Muslims. (It differs from superficially-similar Israel in two particular ways: authority and mediation are preferred over law and minorities don't have enforceable rights but only a revocable tolerance.)

As Z.A.B. put it after he learned otherwise in the 1965 war, it is an article of faith among Pakistanis that Muslims in border areas w/India would want to be part of Pakistan; otherwise, they weren't really Muslims. Rather than correct the mis-education of the Pakistani populace, he reinforced and utilized it to achieve power by labeling the people of East Pakistan as Hindus, Ahmadis as non-Muslims, etc. Zia continued the program, making it even more extreme. Pakistan still suffers from the messed-up minds so created.

 

[doppelganger]

Kashmir is an Indian state. Like all Indian states there are some Muslims also living there.

What's the fuss really about man? Get with the program already!

 

[Sukapha]

Kashmir is India's. Why? Because we are strong, and have won all the wars that have been fought over Kashmir. Simple. We need to be strong for a long time as we are in a rough neighbourhood and there are enough people who are in need.

 

[Jackdaws]

Pakistan's philosophy is majoritarian; leaders from Jinnah to Zia held that areas where they declared Muslims were a majority were places they believed should come under Pakistani sovereignty and that under such Muslims should have special rights over non-Muslims. (It differs from superficially-similar Israel in two particular ways: authority and mediation are preferred over law and minorities don't have enforceable rights but only a revocable tolerance.)

As Z.A.B. put it after he learned otherwise in the 1965 war, it is an article of faith among Pakistanis that Muslims in border areas w/India would want to be part of Pakistan; otherwise, they weren't really Muslims. Rather than correct the mis-education of the Pakistani populace, he reinforced and utilized it to achieve power by labeling the people of East Pakistan as Hindus, Ahmadis as non-Muslims, etc. Zia continued the program, making it even more extreme. Pakistan still suffers from the messed-up minds so created.

Yes, populist moves tend to dilute the thinking of a nation.

With muslim majorities,public support n no military intervension... unlike junagarh,hyderabad,kashmir etc...

Love you too.

And the Chittagong Hill Tracts with its Hindu/Buddhist majority? How did that become a part of erstwhile East Pakistan?

 

[hussain0216]

An amicable resolve may mean the kashmir valley going to Pakistan, and other parts where there are more kaffirs going to India.


Kashmiri's hate india, we hate hindu's, we never wanted to work or live with them.

They are the clingy girlfriend you just cant get rid of..

Year in, year out Kashmiri's display their open hatred for India & still they dont get it

 

[INDIC]

And the Chittagong Hill Tracts with its Hindu/Buddhist majority? How did that become a part of erstwhile East Pakistan?

Jinnah invited Hindu majority Jaisalmer, Bikaner and Jodhpur to accede to Muslim Homeland in the name of using Karachi port but they refused. Then they created hurdles for accession of Junagadh and Hyderabad's integration with India but try to grab them. Even after losing Kashmir, Pakistan refused to compromise on Hyderabad for Kashmir. When they lost of it, them remembered religion based demographies of princely state.

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

An amicable resolve may mean the kashmir valley going to Pakistan, and other parts where there are more kaffirs going to India.


Kashmiri's hate india, we hate hindu's, we never wanted to work or live with them.

They are the clingy girlfriend you just cant get rid of..

Year in, year out Kashmiri's display their open hatred for India & still they dont get it

There you go... a hate filled Muslim Boyfriend ..could not control his Hindu Girlfriend..so he comes out and vents on a defense forum.

IS she too hot to handle

 

[SarthakGanguly]

No. From Kashmir - let me tell you this hatred is limited to Srinagar and some hotspots only. Rest don't care much about this Hindu hatred.

But yes, we know you hate Hindus.
And oh, yes - Kashmir's demographic change is now getting interesting. The Sunni Muslim share of the population is down to 66% and coming down. This news might give you a sleepless night or two.

An amicable resolve may mean the kashmir valley going to Pakistan, and other parts where there are more kaffirs going to India.


Kashmiri's hate india, we hate hindu's, we never wanted to work or live with them.

They are the clingy girlfriend you just cant get rid of..

Year in, year out Kashmiri's display their open hatred for India & still they dont get it

 

[hussain0216]

Give Kashmir the freedom to go to Pakistan and South Asia could be strong & United...

Otherwise the eternal goal of Pakistan will be to get Kashmir and hurt India,,

Indian could possibly be a world power but its enemies will always have a ready made sword in the form of Pakistan at its neck.


Free Kashmir and it could all change

 

[AnnoyingOrange]

Give Kashmir the freedom to go to Pakistan and South Asia could be strong & United...

Otherwise the eternal goal of Pakistan will be to get Kashmir and hurt India,,

Indian could possibly be a world power but its enemies will always have a ready made sword in the form of Pakistan at its neck.


Free Kashmir and it could all change

Come and get it .... sitting in your cozy room 2 continents apart and ranting ... this will not get you anything kido.