Why did France allow the tabloid to provoke Muslims?

[punit]

Making money off mocking religions is no society's norms. If they didn't like why did they let Muslims in? Its like you let someone in your house, poke them in the eye and expect them to stay quiet.

if a cartoon can shake you faith .. its not worth having !

 

[Shot-Caller]

so the result is justified ?

Is the provocation justified?

 

[Jf Thunder]

for Christians whose faith is based on this two things .. its an attack on their faith. just like some one saying prophet Muhammad not being final prophet is attack on yours. Right ?

you saying that will not anger me as you are not Muslim however making a cartoon of our Prophet will make me lash at your throat, and bite out your Jugular vein

 

[Gandhi follower]

India has 180 million muslim population think about that do you want to make your 180 million muslim population un happy?

Liberal secular muslim may be unhappy but he will not for a shooting spree

 

[$@rJen]

Why do west keep this poison in their country... just expell the trouble maker

 

[Tipu7]

Why 1 provoke?

and 1 provoke only
w

so the result is justified ?


for Christians whose faith is based on this two things .. its an attack on their faith. just like some one saying prophet Muhammad not being final prophet is attack on yours. Right ?

wrong

 

[Shot-Caller]

if a cartoon can shake you faith .. its not worth having !

What? It did not make any Muslim convert. Only enraged people. Where were the charlie supporters when peaceful protests were being carried out against it? They kept on disrespecting. You can't do something like this when you know there are some extremists out there and expect to be going on about your life normally.

 

[punit]

and 1 provoke only
w

wrong

about this one incident.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

we dont believe he is son of God yes
but his resurrection, we believe that he never died and will return, so nothing wrong here

By the same token, non-Muslims do not believe that Muhammad was a Prophet of God. Your failure to accept that Jesus was the son of God equals to a non-Muslims failure to accept the commandments pertaining to your Prophet and your religion in your religious books. In effect your refusal as a non-Christian to accept Jesus as the son of God is on the same level of blasphemy as a non-Muslim's refusal to accept the rules of your holy books which included prohibitions against mocking or depicting Muhammad in any way. Should the Christian world now rise up and slaughter the Muslims for their insult to Christianity ?

 

[doppelganger]

No one supports the killings. All Im saying is why do you have to hurt the religious sentiments? Some people may be fine with other's making fun of their religion. Muslims are not. Why is it so hard for you to understand? Its like forcefully feeding a vegetarian meat and expecting him to stay quiet. There are certain lines people must not cross and respect each other's faith.

That is the Indian way of looking at things. Not theirs. I won't say Pakistani way because for you guys there is only really one religion, and no question of making fun of that!

The Indian way is of not overstepping one's bounds and not provoking. So what if every little thing will provoke and we will be up in arms demonstrating, burning, breaking, protesting. The alternative, when someone really goofs up, is killing.

That is not the way of the West. They value their freedom of speech. And one cannot accuse them of being one sided because as most commentators have been at pains to explain, they do it for their own dominant faith, Christianity, as well.

It is their society. It is their laws. It is their lines.

Don't project your own lines on to them. It will not work. In fact it will make things a lot worse. To prove a point. How many more will the nut jobs of yours kill, before European society has enough, their tolerance reaches breaking point, and then your community SERIOUSLY feels the backlash?

Remember, it was Europe that did the Jews. And the way I see it, Muslims are heading in pretty much the same direction. A century does not change the basic DNA of a people.

 

[Red Spinifex]

Why did France allow the tabloid to provoke Muslims?

This such a false premise that it is ludicrous. And the fools actually believe this!

That is the Indian way of looking at things. Not theirs. I won't say Pakistani way because for you guys there is only really one religion, and no question of making fun of that!

The Indian way is of not overstepping one's bounds and not provoking. So what if every little thing will provoke and we will be up in arms demonstrating, burning, breaking, protesting. The alternative, when someone really goofs up, is killing.

That is not the way of the West. They value their freedom of speech. And one cannot accuse them of being one sided because as most commentators have been at pains to explain, they do it for their own dominant faith, Christianity, as well.

It is their society. It is their laws. It is their lines.

Don't project your own lines on to them. It will not work. In fact it will make things a lot worse. To prove a point. How many more will the nut jobs of yours kill, before European society has enough, their tolerance reaches breaking point, and then your community SERIOUSLY feels the backlash?

Remember, it was Europe that did the Jews. And the way I see it, Muslims are heading in pretty much the same direction. A century does not change the basic DNA of a people.

You nailed it, doppelganger!

 

[doppelganger]

Making money off mocking religions is no society's norms. If they didn't like why did they let Muslims in? Its like you let someone in your house, poke them in the eye and expect them to stay quiet.

You will not be grateful they let you in, but will question why they behave as they do (and have always done) after they have let you in?

Don't like things after you have been let in?

Leave!

 

[Jf Thunder]

By the same token, non-Muslims do not believe that Muhammad was a Prophet of God. Your failure to accept that Jesus was the son of God equals to a non-Muslims failure to accept the commandments pertaining to your Prophet and your religion in your religious books. In effect your refusal as a non-Christian to accept Jesus as the son of God is on the same level of blasphemy as a non-Muslim's refusal to accept the rules of your holy books which included prohibitions against mocking or depicting Muhammad in any way. Should the Christian world now rise up and slaughter the Muslims for their insult to Christianity ?

the answer to that long paragraph is, they are free to think the Muhammad (S.A.W.W) was not the final Prophet, but deliberately making fun, that is bad
what if we make fun of Jesus (but we cant because Islam forbids it)
and Crusaders did kill a hell lot of Muslims when they went about their Holy Wars

 

[Red Spinifex]

You will not be grateful they let you in, but will question why they behave as they do (and have always done) after they have let you in?

Don't like things after you have been let in?

Leave!

Exactly! You make good sense, doppelganger.

 

[mujhaidind]

Remember, it was Europe that did the Jews. And the way I see it, Muslims are heading in pretty much the same direction. A century does not change the basic DNA of a people.

First of all Muslims are not jews. There are 2 billions Muslim in the world. If the west could do it then they would have done that already.

You are talking about a religion which has witnessed 1400 years of warfare.The crusaders were curshed. Inshallah they will be crushed again.