Why Congress wants to forget 1962 Indo-China war

[Tractor]

lets hope all settlements will be done by peaceful means ...

India China should become partners not enemies... i hope china leave its claim on Arunachal... or China will push both india and china in stone age

Mention Arunachal,maybe western frontier should be concern,Kamet peak is really beautiful,it is in India?

 

[Tumba]

Mention Arunachal,maybe western frontier should be concern,Kamet peak is really beautiful,it is in India?

yaa china already occupies Aksai chin .. western frontier is also a concern ...


yes the Kamet Peak is in Utrakhand state of India.. bordering Tibet agained occupied by china ... still PRC wants more... W H Y ???

 

[Tractor]

yaa china already occupies Aksai chin .. western frontier is also a concern ...


yes the Kamet Peak is in Utrakhand state of India.. bordering Tibet agained occupied by china ... still PRC wants more... W H Y ???

For PRG has nothing,nothing to lose in a war.

 

[Outman]

War is not some walk in the park,people in this forum mention it more faster than even breathing,without possible understanding the repercussion's of a war.

They do understand, they are just taking it out on cyber space. Life for most Chinese and Indians is not light as feather.

Indians worry about Chinese being aggressive, Chinese worry about Indians being used as a pawn by the US. We might not like each other per se, but the mutural hatred or fear, which is a key component in a full-scale war, is not there, at least not to my knowledge.

 

[Tumba]

They do understand, they are just taking it out on cyber space. Life for most Chinese and Indians is not light as feather.

Indians worry about Chinese being aggressive, Chinese worry about Indians being used as a pawn by the US. We might not like each other per se, but the mutural hatred or fear, which is a key component in a full-scale war, is not there, at least not to my knowledge.

but you cant trust a Authoritarian Govt like china...

chinese ppl may not be in favor still PRC will do wat it wants,,,, and it will be bad day for India and China both ... after 100s of years our two civilizations has got a chance to rise again to their glory ... and PRC by claiming Arunachal is going towards a dark future..

 

[webber]

call part of xizang 'Arunachal' settles everything, yeah

and a tibetan liar can't face truth

 

[Tractor]

but you cant trust a Authoritarian Govt like china...

chinese ppl may not be in favor still PRC will do wat it wants,,,, and it will be bad day for India and China both ... after 100s of years our two civilizations has got a chance to rise again to their glory ... and PRC by claiming Arunachal is going towards a dark future..

rise again is India's affair.China never rose but always full of brainless people.

 

[Tumba]

call part of xizang 'Arunachal' settles everything, yeah

and a tibetan liar can't face truth

free east Turkmenistan and Tibet ... that will settle the issue...


Republic of China govt is rightful owner of Mainland ...

East Turkmenistan, Tibet, Inner Mongolia.. should be free from the hands of arrogant PRC ...

 

[Tractor]

free east Turkmenistan and Tibet ... that will settle the issue...


Republic of China govt is rightful owner of Mainland ...

East Turkmenistan, Tibet, Inner Mongolia.. should be free from the hands of arrogant PRC ...

Should be but could not be.

 

[chengdusudise]

Indians have Indian Ocean,remember.

sorry, indian ocean is under the control of american navy.

 

[Tumba]

Should be but could not be.

same the case with Arunachal and Kashmir ...

---------- Post added at 08:35 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:34 PM ----------

sorry, indian ocean is under the control of american navy.

also the south china sea ... and pacific

 

[bichuraM]

1962 was a very small conflict ....2014 will be big......india vs pakchina .......

 

[Bigoren]

free east Turkmenistan and Tibet ... that will settle the issue...


Republic of China govt is rightful owner of Mainland ...

East Turkmenistan, Tibet, Inner Mongolia.. should be free from the hands of arrogant PRC ...

 

[Spring Onion]

India stands for peace ... but every aggression from a neighbor should be dealt with all our power..

India is standing ON peace suffocating it to death

 

[Joe Shearer]

This is just to correct some misapprehensions, not to enter the thread in general.

akasi chin is a land grew noting,India really want take it back?

No, indeed, there is no incentive to take back any real estate in Aksai Chin.

It is of value, strategic value, only to PRC.

Indian parliamentary experts have to figure out a way to 'cede' territory to another country in case of a peace treaty that permanently transfers Aksai Chin to PRC.

If India had it then Tibet will be controlled by India,right?

No, there is no way that Tibet can be controlled by India if India regains complete access to Aksai Chin.

Look at the maps.

The population centres in Tibet are mainly concentrated in southern Tibet (not what is known as south Tibet in current diplomatic speak, but the Xigatse Lhasa belt) and eastern Tibet, what used to be known as Kham. Northern and central Tibet are essentially barren.

Aksai Chin gives convenient road access to the populated zone between Xigatse and Manasarovar to the Chinese Military Region of Lanzhou. Strangely, because of the layout of the land, it is relatively easy to get to southern Tibet from Xinjiang, and if the approaches from Qing Hai through Kham are blocked by hostile irregulars, as they were when the PRC wanted to move in, the Xinjiang route may have been a convenient way to get around using comparatively less stiffly contested terrain.

I am saying this without knowledge of the detailed deployment of the PLA in 1959. This is subject to verification.

So Aksai Chin matters to China, it doesn't matter to India.