what shall we do with afghanistan?????

[qamar1990]

Because the whole military operation in Pakistan, is due to afghanistan. The more you try to influence them, the more you get influenced by them.

so may we just nee to punish them perhaps?

India is not interested in Afghanistan because that region is harsh and volatile, it will always remain unstable. India is only interested in building schools, hospitals, roads, housing societies for affected all those. How will this be destabalizing Pakistan, I doubt it.

why is india interested in doing all those things for another country while it cannot even support those things in its own country?

 

[FaujHistorian]

They are/were used by indians , they are/were doing the dirty work for india. So if anything needs punishment from pakistan , it is india's presence in afghanistan. We must wipe out the influence and presence of india in afghanistan.

you know the population of Afghanistan. I mean the afghanistanis who are within the border of Afghanistan?

 

[Screambowl]

Pakistan has seen enough of destablization in the last 12 years post US led 2001 invasion of afghanistan. Now it should be time for our enemies to pay for their dirty work during all these years using afghan proxies.

The point is not who used proxies and who didn'T. There are no proxies there but small tribes with their own agenda.

 

[Psycho Pakistani]

well all know what TTP is…
lets stick to topic .. you said we should just leave them alone and let india build the infrastructure? how do we know that india won't be funding anti pakistan elements? or just try turn afghanistan against pakistan?


how much indian presence shall we allow?

Not more than india's official presence in pakistan.

 

[Kompromat]

Integrate them.

 

[Screambowl]

why is india interested in doing all those things for another country while it cannot even support those things in its own country?

We will not build it for free. Any work is done, it's funded by UN, or other countries too. Even if India give funds, whats wrong. You support refugees, why when you cannot handle your own people?

 

[qamar1990]

Integrate them.

so take them over?

 

[Screambowl]

Not more than india's official presence in pakistan.

hahah, I didn't know NS is also PM of Afghanistan. LoL.

 

[qamar1990]

you know the population of Afghanistan. I mean the afghanistanis who are within the border of Afghanistan?

less 30 million I'm pretty sure…
so what does their population have to do with this?

 

[Psycho Pakistani]

you know the population of Afghanistan. I mean the afghanistanis who are within the border of Afghanistan?

It is estimated between 25-30 million. Afghan pashtuns are no more than 40-45 % of the population, the rest 55-60 % are non-pashtun ethnicities among which Tajiks are the biggest and make around 25-30 % of afghanistan's population, 10 % Hazara, 10 % Uzbek and the 5-10% other minorities which include turkmen, pashai, nuristani, baloch etc.

 

[qamar1990]

hahah, I didn't know NS is also PM of Afghanistan. LoL.

well until afghanistan is strong enough to beat pakistan i think they will have no choice but to do as we say or else….

 

[Kompromat]

so take them over?

No, let them feel that they belong to the family. Afghans are hardworking people, if they are given leadership and direction. We don't need to take them over, we just need to support them build a better country like we should.

 

[Screambowl]

well until afghanistan is strong enough to beat pakistan i think they will have no choice but to do as we say or else….

Beat Pakistan? It is the ideology which travels from afg to pak. And the youth of pak gets influenced by it. Already beaten.

 

[qamar1990]

It is estimated between 25-30 million. Afghan pashtuns are no more than 40-45 % of the population, the rest 55-60 % are non-pashtun ethnicities among which Tajiks are the biggest and make around 25-30 % of afghanistan's population, 10 % Hazara, 10 % Uzbek and the 5-10% other minorities which include turkmen, pashai, nuristani, baloch etc.

which of these groups would fit in the "darri" category

No, let them feel that they belong to the family. Afghans are hardworking people, if they are given leadership and direction. We don't need to take them over, we just need to support them build a better country like we should.

thats a good option as well

 

[FaujHistorian]

It is estimated between 25-30 million. Afghan pashtuns are no more than 40-45 % of the population, the rest 55-60 % are non-pashtun ethnicities among which Tajiks are the biggest and make around 25-30 % of afghanistan's population, 10 % Hazara, 10 % Uzbek and the 5-10% other minorities which include turkmen, pashai, nuristani, baloch etc.

Great. Let's pick 20 million for each of use.


Ok, can you imagine any large city of Pakistan with around 20 million population?