‘Vishvas’: A word that threatens Pakistan

[Capt.Popeye]

Urdu's an Indian language as well, so what's the fuss?

That it certainly is; hence it has given to and taken from so many Indian languages. Which is a good thing apart from being a simple reality.

 

[Che Guevara]

Urdu's an Indian language as well, so what's the fuss?

That's what I don't understand,Urdu is an Indian language...

Pakistan is a Muslim nation ,that doesn't mean Muslim all around world are Pakistani...what I am trying to say that an Indian language by Indian Muslim doesn't mean its Pakistani language...

 

[JohnyD]

That's what I don't understand,Urdu is an Indian language...

Pakistan is a Muslim nation ,that doesn't mean Muslim all around world are Pakistani...what I am trying to say that an Indian language by Indian Muslim doesn't mean its Pakistani language...

correct.....

 

[illusion8]

That it certainly is; hence it has given to and taken from so many Indian languages. Which is a good thing apart from being a simple reality.

It has influences from Arabic, Persian but the base seems to be Hindi, does Sanskrit plus any more Indian language figure in the mix of Urdu?

 

[INDIC]

That's what I don't understand,Urdu is an Indian language...

Pakistan is a Muslim nation ,that doesn't mean Muslim all around world are Pakistani...what I am trying to say that an Indian language by Indian Muslim doesn't mean its Pakistani language...

True, I agree.

 

[illusion8]

That's what I don't understand,Urdu is an Indian language...

Pakistan is a Muslim nation ,that doesn't mean Muslim all around world are Pakistani...what I am trying to say that an Indian language by Indian Muslim doesn't mean its Pakistani language...

The problem is accepting any Indian-ness in their past history or culture, they want to delink from India culturally, but they don't have a base to fall back on and unfortunately all roads lead to their past Indian roots.

 

[Capt.Popeye]

It has influences from Arabic, Persian but the base seems to be Hindi, does Sanskrit plus any more Indian language figure in the mix of Urdu?

Even Hindi as we know it and speak it now is an amalgam with its roots in Khari-Boli and Braj-Bhasha. Then going back further there is Sanskrit.

 

[karan21]

Both nations speak English that means we are culturally invaded by britain.

When we have no problem in bringing Pakistani talent to India and making them overnight superstars, using Pakistani words, inviting Pakistan students for cultural exchanges then Pakistan should not repent for Indian influence.

Pakistan has separated from India, it has not created its own culture. Its culture is similiar to northern Indians, muslims and pathans of India. Pakistan has inherited a part of Indian culture. So you will definitely see more impact of changing Indian culture on Pakistan than Pakistan on India.

 

[Raja.Pakistani]

abb humhein PM ka balutkar nhi karna chaya iss baat par lol

 

[Che Guevara]

The problem is accepting any Indian-ness in their past history or culture, they want to delink from India culturally, but they don't have a base to fall back on and unfortunately all roads lead to their past Indian roots.

but pakistan want nuke deal because India had granted, they want this and that because world has given it to India...tub inko ya baat yaad nahi aata..

 

[Awesome]

Yeh Anyaye hai!

Mera Dharam brasht hogaya!

 

[tvsram1992]

they watch Bollywood movies but protest against it

 

[harpoon]

they watch Bollywood movies but protest against it

Other than period films which Bollywood movie dialogues are exclusively Hindi. Its usually a mixture of Hindi/Urdu & English.

 

[Rafael]

Urdu / Hindi - what's the difference?

 

[INDIC]

That's what I don't understand,Urdu is an Indian language...

Pakistan is a Muslim nation ,that doesn't mean Muslim all around world are Pakistani...what I am trying to say that an Indian language by Indian Muslim doesn't mean its Pakistani language...

The fact always amazes me when Pakistanis claim Indian don't have any claim over IVC and Gandhara, Pakistan have no common heritage with India but proudly claim Urdu as their heritage which is native to Uttar Pradesh from India when Turks or Mongols don't claim Urdu as their heritage.