What's new

Trump reiterates offer to mediate Kashmir dispute; India insists it's a bilateral issue

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Trump reiterates offer to mediate Kashmir dispute; India insists it's a bilateral issue
AP | Dawn.comUpdated August 02, 2019
Facebook Count16
Twitter Share

33
5d43de55e61a6.jpg

US President Donald Trump talks to reporters before departing for a campaign rally in Cincinnati, on the South Lawn of the White House, on Thursday. — AP
United States President Donald Trump has reiterated his offer to mediate the Kashmir dispute between Pakistan and India, telling reporters he is willing to intervene but a decision would be up to the leaders of both the countries.

Last month, Trump, while talking to the mediaalongside Prime Minister Imran Khan at the White House, had said that Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi had recently asked him whether he would like to be a mediator or arbitrator on Kashmir — something New Delhi immediately denied.

Trump, when questioned on Thursday by a reporter regarding India's rejection of third-party mediation, asked: "Have they accepted the offer or not?"

When told no, he said: "It is really up to Prime Minister [Narendra] Modi."

"I met Prime Minister [Imran] Khan, I got along great with [the premier]. I think they are fantastic people — Khan and Modi — I mean, I would imagine they could get along very well," he added.

"But if they wanted somebody to intervene, to help them [...] and I spoke with Pakistan about that and I spoke frankly in India about it [...] that battle has been going on for a long time."

“If I can, if they wanted me to, I would certainly intervene,” Trump said.

India, however, again rejected President Trump’s offer.

5d43d74638312.jpg

India's External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar talks with US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo before the East Asia Summit meeting in Bangkok, Thailand, on Friday. — AP


India’s foreign minister said he told Secretary of State Mike Pompeo that any discussion of the disputed Himalayan region would be between India and Pakistan only. The two men met on Friday on the sidelines of an Asian security forum in Bangkok. India has long refused outside attempts to resolve the conflict while Pakistan has sought international help.

“Have conveyed to American counterpart @SecPompeo this morning in clear terms that any discussion on Kashmir, if at all warranted, will only be with Pakistan and only bilaterally,” Minister for External Affairs S. Jaishankar said in a tweet.



He said he and Pompeo had wide-ranging discussions on regional issues.

In a brief statement about the meeting, the State Department did not mention Kashmir or the mediation offer. It said Pompeo and Jaishankar “discussed our shared commitment to upholding the rule of law, freedom of navigation, and democratic values in the Indo-Pacific region”.

Earlier on Thursday, a senior State Department official said Trump’s offer to help resolve the Kashmir dispute should be seen against the backdrop of the US desire to help improve relations between India and Pakistan.

Briefing the media on Prime Minister Imran's visit to Washington last week, the official reiterated the US offer to help India and Pakistan resolve the 70-year old dispute, if asked by both.

“We recognise that Kashmir has been a bilateral issue but there are opportunities as Pakistan takes steps that build confidence in its own efforts to counter terrorism [and] ultimately towards a constructive dialogue. We stand ready to assist if asked by the parties to do so,” the senior State Department official added.

Furore in India over offer
At a joint news conference with Prime Minister Imran at the White House on July 22, President Trump said he was willing to mediate between India and Pakistan to resolve the Kashmir issue if the two neighbours asked him to do so.

“If I can help, I would love to be a mediator. If I can do anything to help, let me know,” Trump had said while responding to a question from a Pakistani journalist.

“I was with Prime Minister Modi two weeks ago and we talked about this subject [Kashmir]. And he, actually, said, would you like to be a mediator or arbitrator? I said, where? [Modi said] Kashmir,” Trump explained.

The statement caused a political storm in India where opposition parties called Modi’s reported request to the US president an act of treason and asked him to explain why he made such a move.

The Indian government denied ever asking Trump to mediate on Kashmir, adding that India retains its traditional position that it will not accept any third-party mediation on its disputes with Pakistan.

On July 24, President Trump’s Chief Economic Adviser Larry Kudlow rejected the suggestion that his boss had “made up” the claim that the Indian PM had asked him to mediate on Kashmir. “The president does not make anything up. That’s a very rude question in my opinion,” he told a reporter at a White House briefing.

At Wednesday’s State Department briefing, the senior US official backed Trump’s offer but said a follow-up would depend on the steps that Pakistan now takes to eradicate terrorism from the region.

The visit, the official said, was a chance for the prime minister to discuss how his government would bring his vision about and for both sides to confer on how the US could support Pakistan in this endeavour.
 
. . . .
When told no, he said: "It is really up to Prime Minister [Narendra] Modi."

India’s foreign minister said he told Secretary of State Mike Pompeo that any discussion of the disputed Himalayan region would be between India and Pakistan only. The two men met on Friday on the sidelines of an Asian security forum in Bangkok. India has long refused outside attempts to resolve the conflict while Pakistan has sought international help.

India, however, again rejected President Trump’s offer.


So.. whats the fuss about ?
 
. . . .
International disrespect of Trump by India.


The J&K issue is over 70 years old, during this period approx 12- 13 US Presidents have come & gone. The Indian stand has remained the same.

As regards respect, Trump is possibly the least respected US President , he must be used to this . If not, he will.
 
.
The J&K issue is over 70 years old, during this period approx 12- 13 US Presidents have come & gone. The Indian stand has remained the same.

As regards respect, Trump is possibly the least respected US President , he must be used to this . If not, he will.

There is no benefit in prolonging the stalemate in Kashmir
 
. .
If the same Trump had said he [Trump] told Pakistan "there is nothing to mediate about and USA would not want to get involved in what is India's internal matter" this thread would have exploded with orgasmic Indian members shouting "see, see, see". But when Trump says something that underscores Pakistan's wish to internationalize the issue then Indian members start saying all this is irrelevant. And let there be no doubt, when President of USA starts blabbering about Kashmir and how Modi asked him to mediate inside the White house that is internationalizing the issue. India would prefer if the K word is not even mentioned in international fora as it amounts to intrusion in indian internal matters.

Think about this. if you follow the Indian line. That Kashmir is integral part and internal matter of India, then Trump is really being undiplomatic if not taking the piss.

More importantly, given that this is third time that 'K' has been mentioned by Trump/US officials we can now safely assume that Modi did approach Trump on Kashmir. Had it been just slip of the moment by Trump the matter would have been buried particularly after India raised a ruckus. But despite US has maintained it's earlier comment by Trump.
 
. . .
Ahhh..,The art of the deal.....now what could possibly go wrong with having chump...I mean trump decide who gets what,eh?o_O
I think you pakistanis and indians would be literally CRAAAAZZY to turn this offer down;),I mean think of it,you`d each get something and donny "bullsh!t" would get his nobel peace prize into the bargain,it`d be win-win-win,hell you guys will be winning so much you`ll probably get tired of winning just like chump..I mean trump says:enjoy:
Maybe trump can bring the indians and pakistanis together.Truly history in the making.
:azn:
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom