Training Afghan Forces - Hilarious!

[Ahmad Shah Abdali]

History proves that Afghans are real tough fighters...true.

History proves that Tajiks, Uzbeks, and Hazaras (the people who make most of ANA) are real tough fighters? Dont be so sure about it.

Afghan Taliban are mostly Pashtun. History proves that Pashtuns are real tough fighters not the Tajiks, Uzbeks, Hazaras.

Do you really believe the BS which you write? Pashtuns constitute the majority of Afghan National Army unlike the PA which is domnated by Punjabis and Pashtuns are only 15%. Based on which metrics are you measuring who is a "tough" fighter? History proves that Tajiks have been part of the Armies of Afghans like Abdali. Hazaras are one of the best martial arts fighters Afghanistan has produced and are famous for their excellent performance in elite ANA units. So get your facts straight before labelling traitors as the representatives of Pashtuns.

 

[Ahmad Shah Abdali]

Just realized the thread is 18 months old WHO OPENED THIS?!?!?

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Do you really believe the BS which you write? Pashtuns constitute the majority of Afghan National Army unlike the PA which is domnated by Punjabis and Pashtuns are only 15%. Based on which metrics are you measuring who is a "tough" fighter? History proves that Tajiks have been part of the Armies of Afghans like Abdali. Hazaras are one of the best martial arts fighters Afghanistan has produced and are famous for their excellent performance in elite ANA units. So get your facts straight before labelling traitors as the representatives of Pashtuns.

Pashtun make 35-40% of PA... the PA doesnt discriminate against our own ppl... thts why we had many pashtun COAS(probably majority of COAS were pashto speakers) n even a Hazara army chief...Gen Musa...

Abt ANA....sorry to say but majority of ANA is made up of tajik n hazaras and is infected by ethnic discrimination..... here read it:
AFP: Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army, soldiers say

http://www.google.com.au/url?sa=t&s...0_yrDg&usg=AFQjCNFy4f1dLkA_JszH2lY96lvQ3QIHbw

Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army, soldiers say

 

[RazPaK]

Yes, "Northern Pakistan has this type of terrain........." and may be some other parts of Pakistan as well BUT not whole of Pakistan.
Likewise, Gurkhas from the Himalayan region of India and Nepal are tough as well due to their natural environment and terrain BUT whole of India doesn't have such terrain.
Whereas, almost all of Afghanistan is mountainous and desertous which make its inhabitants naturally more enduring.
It is scientifically proven that people living in desert areas, live longer and people living in hilly areas need less oxygen to survive than people living in plains.

This is why I said that an Afghan is more tough than an average Pakistani or Indian NOT all Pakistanis and Indians.

In Pakistan we have more hills and mountains than plains, yet even our plains are mostly desert regions.

 

[Emmie]

Very hard training indeed..

 

[Omar1984]

Do you really believe the BS which you write? Pashtuns constitute the majority of Afghan National Army unlike the PA which is domnated by Punjabis and Pashtuns are only 15%. Based on which metrics are you measuring who is a "tough" fighter? History proves that Tajiks have been part of the Armies of Afghans like Abdali. Hazaras are one of the best martial arts fighters Afghanistan has produced and are famous for their excellent performance in elite ANA units. So get your facts straight before labelling traitors as the representatives of Pashtuns.

Yes Pakistan Army is 100% Punjabi and also ISI is 100% Punjabi. Keep thinking that, it will help our ISI agents hide their work when they operate in your country

As for your Afghan Taliban they are 99% Pashtuns and they are defeating another superpower while your ANA licks the boots of Russia, India, and Amreeka.

 

[Ahmad Shah Abdali]

Pashtun make 35-40% of PA... the PA doesnt discriminate against our own ppl... thts why we had many pashtun COAS(probably majority of COAS were pashto speakers) n even a Hazara army chief...Gen Musa...

Kayani Launches Reforms in Pakistan Army, Hamid Mir's Report | Hamid Mir Columns

Looking at the percentage of Baloch in the PA it's not surprising they have rebelled.

Abt ANA....sorry to say but majority of ANA is made up of tajik n hazaras and is infected by ethnic discrimination..... here read it:
AFP: Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army, soldiers say

Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army, soldiers say - Worldnews.com

Ethnic discrimination infests Afghan army, soldiers say

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/07/world/asia/07afghanistan.html?pagewanted=all

Those were old days, 42% of Afghan National Army are pashtuns. The defence minister, chief of the army staff, most of the senior generals are pashtun as well. The only concern is that there isn't enough recruits from southern provinces like Kandahar, Ghazni etc. Recruitment is low in areas where the terrorists are active regardless of the area.

 

[Ahmad Shah Abdali]

Very hard training indeed..

Keep laughing, atleast they don't surrender in their hundreds when surrounded by ragtag tribals in Waziristan OR B'desh It is actually good that ANA is underestimated, keep thinking we are weak

 

[Rafi]

Kayani Launches Reforms in Pakistan Army, Hamid Mir's Report | Hamid Mir Columns

Looking at the percentage of Baloch in the PA it's not surprising they have rebelled.



Those were old days, 42% of Afghan National Army are pashtuns. The defence minister, chief of the army staff, most of the senior generals are pashtun as well. The only concern is that there isn't enough recruits from southern provinces like Kandahar, Ghazni etc. Recruitment is low in areas where the terrorists are active regardless of the area.

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/07/world/asia/07afghanistan.html?pagewanted=all

First take your 3 million refugees who refuse to go back to A-Stan, and then talk, if we cut of the wheat supply, you lot would starve so cut the BS.

For your information Baloch are just over 5% of the population, and that is how many are serving.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Kayani Launches Reforms in Pakistan Army, Hamid Mir's Report | Hamid Mir Columns

Looking at the percentage of Baloch in the PA it's not surprising they have rebelled.

True the percentage of baluch and sindhis is not much in the army... they make like 15-20%..... thts why the reforms r being made.... infact PA just inducted 5000 baluch youth in the army... and thousands mor r being recruited..but there is no discrimination.... its th personal choice of people..

Another thing reguarding the point u made .. im a baluch and my father is a Brig in PA and commanding a brigade ...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/07/world/asia/07afghanistan.html?pagewanted=all

Those were old days, 42% of Afghan National Army are pashtuns. The defence minister, chief of the army staff, most of the senior generals are pashtun as well. The only concern is that there isn't enough recruits from southern provinces like Kandahar, Ghazni etc. Recruitment is low in areas where the terrorists are active regardless of the area.

42% vs 58% tajiks,hazaras... thts still makes pashtuns a minority..... anyways discrimination is still there in ANA.

 

[Rafi]

PN - if we cut off the supply of food, we could starve Afghanistan - within weeks, and we need to kick the three million refugees out ASAP - and let Karza sort their food and water out, these Afgoons are taking the Pss.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

Keep laughing, atleast they don't surrender in their hundreds when surrounded by ragtag tribals in Waziristan OR B'desh It is actually good that ANA is underestimated, keep thinking we are weak

Hundreds? nice imagination... they were a few dozen... and at tht time there was a peace accord between govt and the taliban... even than those guys were court marshalled.


Abt ANA soldiers... no they dnt surrender to the taliban... they just sell their weapons to them, and to NATO are known as 50% soldiers who change their loyality for money

 

[Ahmad Shah Abdali]

Yes Pakistan Army is 100% Punjabi and also ISI is 100% Punjabi. Keep thinking that, it will help our ISI agents hide their work when they operate in your country
As for your Afghan Taliban they are 99% Pashtuns and they are defeating another superpower while your ANA licks the boots of Russia, India, and Amreeka.

Thats the best you could answer?!?! well was expected, you don't even deserve a reply, so much for being a "premium member"

 

[Ahmad Shah Abdali]

PN - if we cut off the supply of food, we could starve Afghanistan - within weeks, and we need to kick the three million refugees out ASAP - and let Karza sort their food and water out, these Afgoons are taking the Pss.

looks like I hit a nerve there. We need somebody like Amrullah Saleh, enough of this "brotherhood". Let's pay whoever screws with us in the same coin. As for you, congratulation you just proved that you are nothing but an insecure moron with mental retardation stopping him from discussing in a civilized way

 

[RazPaK]

Keep laughing, atleast they don't surrender in their hundreds when surrounded by ragtag tribals in Waziristan OR B'desh It is actually good that ANA is underestimated, keep thinking we are weak

When have Afghans gone out of the region and had a decisive victory? Answer=Never. If you want to insult Pakistan feel free. We feed and host many Afghans and that is our honour. If you want to insult our people and army, feel free. Indians have been doing it and I guess Afghans will generally now do it too.