What's new

To Defeat India, Understand The Mindset

A1Kaid

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Joined
Oct 20, 2008
Messages
9,667
Reaction score
8
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
I return with this...

To Defeat India, Understand The Mindset


dada25224a6e6439509db558171b27c1.jpg




Pakistani Soldiers


Written by Pakistan News :: Pakistan Daily
Wednesday, 24 December 2008 00:46


India follows the ‘Chankaya’ Ideology.’ that all of India’s neighbors are its enemies. And all of the neighbors of India’s neighbors are India’s friends. This was the first time in Pakistan that the private Pakistani media countered the Indian media warfare. The Indians admit this. Sadly, as always, Pakistan has lost ground at the diplomatic front.

We need to understand that the Indian foreign policy, military and intelligence doctrine work on ‘Chankya’s ideology.’

The synopsis of that ideology is that all of India’s neighbors are its enemies. And all of the neighbors of India’s neighbors are India’s friends. That’s why India has bad relations with Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Nepal, Maldives and even Bhutan. India has always had very good relations with Afghanistan, Iran, and Russia.

Chankya ideology also states clearly that India is the super power of the region (Bharat Mata), and all its neighboring countries are its proxies or satellites. This is from where the rhetoric of regional economic bloc, regional zone and South Asian economic zone originates from.

After the Mumbai attacks India has started exerting tremendous pressure on Pakistani government. Pakistani government on the other hand has shown amazing weakness in dealing with this critical situation. This was the first time in Pakistan that the private Pakistani media countered the Indian media warfare while the state-run media (PTV+APP) were weak. Times of India, The Hindu, and other Indian newspapers had to acknowledge that the Indian media onslaught was ripped apart by Pakistani media. Sadly, as always, Pakistan has lost ground at the diplomatic front. This has been Pakistan’s failure since Tashkent Agreement. This is because of our incompetent and corrupt governments. India has cornered us diplomatically, and is pressurizing us militarily. They enjoy the sympathies of U.S. and the rest of the world.

What are the main objectives of India, Israel, and U.S.?

With regards to Pakistan, these three countries form a nexus. They want to finish off our nuclear program, disband our eyes and ears i.e. the ISI; break Pakistan into three or four smaller parts since it is easier to govern a country with 180 million people if its broken down into smaller pieces, disband our army, make Pakistan a satellite state of India, just like Nepal or Bangladesh.

India is now a strategic ally of U.S. India is moving its troops into Afghanistan, so that it can corner Pakistan from both fronts. U.S. wants Indian troops to support its troops in Afghanistan against Taliban. The intelligence arm of any country is the nation’s first line of defense. It’s the eyes and ears without which any military force can’t function. All western and Indian propaganda against ISI is baseless and ridiculous. All officers of ISI are taken from the armed forces. There can be no political appointee. Whereas the Indian RAW has political appointees. The Hindu fundamentalist government of BJP back in the 1990s inducted political appointees into RAW en masse. If ISI is disbanded Pakistan will become an easy target for Indian military. The important thing to keep in mind for all the Pakistani peaceniks, pacifists, and candle light vigilantes and artists like Sameena Pirzada and others is that the peace process between India and Pakistan only started after Pakistan became a declared nuclear power. That is when India understood that war between two nuclear power countries is no longer an option. That’s when confidence building measures, trade links, cultural exchanges, sports, took place. As long as Pakistan was not a declared nuclear weapon state India maintained a threatening attitude towards Pakistan. Without nuclear weapons I can say confidently that India will leave no chance to annihilate us.

The problem with Western experts on South Asia is that they don’t understand the dynamics of Pakistan-India conflict. The root cause of conflict between Pakistan and India is Kashmir. Without the resolution of this conflict permanent peace between India and Pakistan cannot be achieved. There is peace in Europe today because they have resolved their problems and disputes and all countries treat each other with equal respect. Not to forget that two brutal world wars were fought in Europe that completely devastated Europe. After such devastation Europe got together and realized that mutual peace is must for coexistence. Peace between two countries can only be on equal terms. The U.S and Soviet Union were able to co-exist because both had nuclear weapons. If Pakistan is destabilized then it’s not possible that India will remain intact and enjoy exponential growth rates.

When experts come on TV and say that extremists on both sides don’t want peace, this is utter rubbish. Only extremists in India don’t want peace with Pakistan! Why? Because in order for Pakistan and India to have lasting peace, Kashmir dispute must be resolved according to the wishes of the Kashmiri people. Does anyone in Pakistan not want resolution of Kashmir dispute? No. Is there anyone in India who doesn’t want resolution of Kashmir? Yes, their military establishment, their foreign policy establishment, BJP led extremist parties, and a majority of the Indian people. Why do they not want the resolution of Kashmir dispute? Firstly, they call it their internal issue and say it is our ‘Atut Ang’ [integral part]. Secondly, there are so many independence movements going on inside India that they can’t afford setting an example of Kashmiri independence. Recall that India functions on Bharat Mata ideology and they will never give up Kashmir. Everyone in Pakistan is ready to resolve the Kashmir dispute so it’s baseless to say that hawkish elements in Pakistan do not want good relations with India. RSS, Bajrang Dal, Shiv Sena, and even members of BJP have openly said again and again that Pakistan must be destroyed. These are not just small groups; these parties have formed governments in India. - Talha Mujaddidi

Source:To Defeat India, Understand The Mindset | Pakistan Daily
 
.
This is what happens if people who cannot interpret their own books correctly try and interpret others books.
Believe me thats not Chanakya's ideology.
Chanakya was known as Maurya kingdom's minister popular for bringing together the anti-Nanda forces together to forge an empire.
His ideas are known today mainly from his book called 'Arthashaastra' which literally mean 'economic science'. 'artha' is wealth. 'shaastra' is 'science'.
Firstly Chanakya's was not an ideology. His ideas were just a direction for governance and economic management.
It included 'enemy of enemy is friend' kind of obvious stuff. Some other thngs include the use of spies to learn about public opinion on governance.

Many of these are common sense types and are implemented(independently) by all countries in one form or other. For example today in democracies, we do not need spies to know about public opinion, we use polls.

And what kind of crazt guy thinks that 'all neighbours are enemies' and 'their neighbours are friends'? This part is BS. I don't hink Chanakya talked about that.
History is full of crazy guys.But if something crazy is saidthey will not be followed today.

May be Chanakya-haters' inspiration is that he was a Hindu:lol:
 
Last edited:
.
very very intersting one

RSS, Bajrang Dal, Shiv Sena, and even members of BJP have openly said again and again that Pakistan must be destroyed. These are not just small groups; these parties have formed governments in India. - Talha Mujaddidi

BJP was in power during kargil. What happened? Nothing after India got back its place. Infact Indian BJP PM started peace process with pakistan. He started bus service. U can get lot from internet. As a opposition party BJP trying to say that govt is not doing enough. thats all its about. Complete politics. I assure you even with BJP govt India might have not opted to fight.

Today every country is trying to achieve economic growth not with war. Those idea and logic is gone. Srilanka and Nepal are very good frens of India. The relation with china got improved. Ofcourse pakistan remained as convetional.

I really doubt that pakistan can defeat India by political logic. I dont agree with that logic. Only way for pakistan is to fight economically by joining hands of china.
 
.
well chanakya used to live 100s of years back...surely we would have found a more modern approach by now.intresting though...
 
.
There is a major misconception about Chankya in Pakistan.

I bet not one Pakistani has read the book himself. That doesn't prevent them from parroting the lies.

He seems more popular in Pakistan than he is in India. I have never read about him in Indian media, nor by any strategic thinkers of India for a long time.

I believe his book contained general principle of politics and realpolitic. It is not a religious scripture. I think it is difficult for some people to understand even that. I am not surprised though. Some people really are trained to be zombies. By design!
 
.
Couple of points here:
1. Chanakya's arthashastra is not even talked about in India, except in academic circles. I don't know it's details, but it's ridiculous to say it drives India's policy. It's like saying Sun Tzu's Art of War is behind Chinese policy.

2. If all of India's neighbours were supposedly considered enemies, how come there is no hostility between India and Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bhutan and Myanmar? How come the biggest headache for India remains Pakistan? It's you guys who are the aggressors, not us.

3. "Defeat" India? :rofl: Dream on.
 
. . .
That’s why India has bad relations with Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Nepal, Maldives and even Bhutan.

Let me add China and Burma.

Irrespective of what Chanakya means, do Indian friends care to explain why India is surrounded with enemies?
 
.
That is a fallacy.

The only country with which India has challenging relationship is Pakistan.
 
.
Let me add China and Burma.

Irrespective of what Chanakya means, do Indian friends care to explain why India is surrounded with enemies?

Please enlighten us: what problems does India have with Myanmar (NOT Burma anymore)? India is not surrounded by enemies - it has one pain in the neck and a huge bully breathing down her neck. You can figure out who is what.
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom