The India Pakistan geographical divide is at least 1600 years old

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Stupid thread ,

The original divide between India an Pakistan was religious , people of Pakistan have earned their own identity.

I have no shame to say that yes our ancestors were hindu indeed , and we are proud that they accepted Islam as true religion.

Sindh Punjab share more ethnic relation with some of Indian races , KP shares same ethnicity with afghans.
Islam makes us brother and a nation.

The scientific and anthropological evidence says otherwise. It completely refutes what you say:

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/the-...cal-divide-is-at-least-1600-years-old.513143/

Please read the eveidence or provide evidence for your POV otherwise it is irrelevant what you say.

 

[StandForInsaf]

The scientific and anthropological evidence says otherwise. It completely refutes what you say:

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/the-...cal-divide-is-at-least-1600-years-old.513143/

Please read the eveidence or provide evidence for your POV otherwise it is irrelevant what you say.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Pakistan

read here.
The major ethnic groups of Pakistan in numerical size include: Punjabis, Pashtuns, Sindhis, Siddis, Saraikis, Muhajirs, Balochis, Hindkowans, Chitralis, Gujarati and other smaller groups. Smaller ethnic groups, such as Kashmiris, Kalash, Burusho, Brahui, Khowar, Hazara, Shina, Kalyu and Balti are mainly found in the northern parts of the country.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Pakistan

read here.
The major ethnic groups of Pakistan in numerical size include: Punjabis, Pashtuns, Sindhis, Siddis, Saraikis, Muhajirs, Balochis, Hindkowans, Chitralis, Gujarati and other smaller groups. Smaller ethnic groups, such as Kashmiris, Kalash, Burusho, Brahui, Khowar, Hazara, Shina, Kalyu and Balti are mainly found in the northern parts of the country.

Wikipedia is not credible. So many manipulate it. Pakistanis don't even look like indians. There is a scientific and anthropological reason to this:

http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/sc...he-aryan-migration-debate/article19090301.ece

 

[StandForInsaf]

Wikipedia is not credible. So many manipulate it. Pakistanis don't even look like indians. There is a scientific and anthropological reason to this:

http://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/sc...he-aryan-migration-debate/article19090301.ece

Thats about aryan migration path.

So in a nutshell: R1a is distributed all over Europe, Central Asia and South Asia; its sub-group Z282 is distributed only in Europe while another subgroup Z93 is distributed only in parts of Central Asia and South Asia; and three major subgroups of Z93 are distributed only in India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and the Himalayas. This clear picture of the distribution of R1a has finally put paid to an earlier hypothesis that this haplogroup perhaps originated in India and then spread outwards. This hypothesis was based on the erroneous assumption that R1a lineages in India had huge diversity compared to other regions, which could be indicative of its origin here. As Prof. Richards puts it, “the idea that R1a is very diverse in India, which was largely based on fuzzy microsatellite data, has been laid to rest” thanks to the arrival of large numbers of genomic Y-chromosome data.

What you want to proof from this? aryan migration path?

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Thats about aryan migration path.

So in a nutshell: R1a is distributed all over Europe, Central Asia and South Asia; its sub-group Z282 is distributed only in Europe while another subgroup Z93 is distributed only in parts of Central Asia and South Asia; and three major subgroups of Z93 are distributed only in India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and the Himalayas. This clear picture of the distribution of R1a has finally put paid to an earlier hypothesis that this haplogroup perhaps originated in India and then spread outwards. This hypothesis was based on the erroneous assumption that R1a lineages in India had huge diversity compared to other regions, which could be indicative of its origin here. As Prof. Richards puts it, “the idea that R1a is very diverse in India, which was largely based on fuzzy microsatellite data, has been laid to rest” thanks to the arrival of large numbers of genomic Y-chromosome data.

What you want to proof from this? aryan migration path?

Sorry but your conjecture does not stand up to the analysis of imminent scientists and experts in this field. If they are not right than why do Pakistanis look so physically different to indians?

 

[StandForInsaf]

Sorry but your conjecture does not stand up to the analysis of imminent scientists and experts in this field. If they are not right than why do Pakistanis look so physically different to indians?

ya well they don't stand up to imminent scientist and experts in this field.


People belonging to z93 will look similar that's what your link tells.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

ya well they don't stand up to imminent scientist and experts in this field.


People belonging to z93 will look similar that's what your link tells.

But then why do Pakistanis look so physically different to indians (bar the few exceptions)?

 

[El Sidd]

Neanderthals still much?

 

[StandForInsaf]

But then why do Pakistanis look so physically different to indians (bar the few exceptions)?

because they are different races (bared exceptions).
Pakistan has less Dravidians populations may you are trying so say this?

https://pics.me.me/the-great-meltin...o-european-populations-dravidian-15383388.png

Neanderthals still much?

Thrown great analysis baba ji.

 

[DESERT FIGHTER]

He is a NOBODY in India

He was just a passing Fad ; the flavour of the month

Out of Sight ; Out of Mind ; We have new stars being created every year

 

[Kabira]

because they are different races (bared exceptions).
Pakistan has less Dravidians populations may you are trying so say this?

https://pics.me.me/the-great-meltin...o-european-populations-dravidian-15383388.png

Thrown great analysis baba ji.

Great expert explain how must of Indian population is genetically similar to Bengalis and look more like them?

 

[El Sidd]

because they are different races (bared exceptions).
Pakistan has less Dravidians populations may you are trying so say this?

https://pics.me.me/the-great-meltin...o-european-populations-dravidian-15383388.png

Thrown great analysis baba ji.

Simple evolution man. The first thing Neanderthals stopped fighting about when they became humans was no racism.

Question of intelligence over primitive instincts.

Loosely translated.

Insaan se ashraful makhlooqat honay tak ka safar.

Missing link.

Missing 30000 years in archeological evolution. The days spent in garden of eden.

What else. I can throw thousand theories man.

Does it matter.

No

 

[StandForInsaf]

Simple evolution man. The first thing Neanderthals stopped fighting about when they became humans was no racism.

Question of intelligence over primitive instincts.

Loosely translated.

Insaan se ashraful makhlooqat honay tak ka safar.

Missing link.

Missing 30000 years in archeological evolution. The days spent in garden of eden.

What else. I can throw thousand theories man.

Does it matter.

No

Neanderthal and homosapien are different species baba ji.

 

[MultaniGuy]

But then why do Pakistanis look so physically different to indians (bar the few exceptions)?

Excellent comment.

We Pakistanis have nothing in common with Indians.

Period.

 

[El Sidd]

Neanderthal and homosapien are different species baba ji.

Lol i know

Homosapiens

Homo sapiens sapiens

Human


I like saying Neanderthals. It's more catchy.

The word homo has some stigma about it. I guess I am still Joey Tribbiani at heart