What's new

Sewer cleaner in Umerkot dies after doctor refuses to touch his ‘filthy body'

Trisonics

BANNED
Joined
Mar 6, 2009
Messages
1,997
Reaction score
-13
UMERKOT: The main accused in the case in which a sewer cleaner Irfan Maseeh died due to alleged negligence of the doctors of Civil Hospital Umerkot has been arrested by the police.

Umerkot police told Geo.tv that the accused Dr Jaam Kunbhar has been arrested while raids were being conducted to arrest the other two doctors —Dr Yousuf and Dr Allah Dad Rathore— involved in the incident.

The case was registered under section 319, 34 PPC against six suspects including three doctors on behalf of the father of the Irfan Maseeh.

Speaking to Geo.tv, SSP Umerkot Usman Bajwa said that the Municipal Committee did not give them safety equipment which caused the death of Maseeh.

“The doctors refused to treat as they are covered with filth”, he added.

Lying in a corner of Civil Hospital Umerkot, sewer cleaner Irfan Maseeh kept gasping for breath, his family members claim that they pleaded with the hospital staff to treat him, but the senior doctor at the facility refused to touch his sludge-covered body.

"Dr Yousuf said he would not touch Irfan's dirty body until it was cleaned," the deceased's brother Pervaiz Maseeh told Geo.tv. "I cleaned his body, after which an oxygen pump was sent for Irfan, but that was empty."

Irfan Maseeh's family alleges that the doctor's negligent response to the emergency situation and lack of facilities at the hospital left him to succumb to death.

Meanwhile, Dr Kunbhar claimed that Irfan Maseeh had already passed away before arriving at the hospital.

Irfan had dived down to clean a manhole Thursday morning when he fell unconscious after inhaling poisonous gases trapped inside, Pervaiz said.

He added, one after another two more men jumped inside to save those trapped, but all fell unconscious due to the same reason.

Pervaiz had reached the site after people in the area informed him of the incident.

"When they were eventually taken out, I put Irfan on my back and rushed him to the hospital," the bereaved brother said. "A rickshaw driver stopped us on the way and gave us his vehicle to carry Irfan to the hospital as quickly as possible."

But he could not be saved despite all the efforts people around him made to resuscitate him.

The death of Irfan due to the alleged negligence of doctor enraged the family members who started protesting with his body.

144301_8536938_updates.jpg

Umerkot SSP Usman Bajwa speaks to one of Irfan's family members.

"No one had come to share our loss or express solidarity with us," Pervaiz said. "But Umerkot SSP Usman Bajwa visited us a while back, promising that the responsible doctor would be taken to task and complete investigation would be carried out in the case."

This was not the first death caused by the negligence of staff at Civil Hospital Umerkot, said Pervaiz. "A similar incident took place in 2014 when a sewage cleaner, struggling for life, was referred to Hyderabad for treatment as the facility in Umerkot was not equipped to treat him."

Home Minister Sindh Suhail Anwar Sial has taken notice of the incident.

https://www.geo.tv/latest/144301-se...kot-hospital-refused-to-touch-his-filthy-body
 
This economic class system is ingrained within the rural areas of Sindh. Ive seen horrible treatment of poor people there which no animal deserves much less human
 
That's why I am in favour of whipping and beheading to be introduced in Pakistan... in forgivable from a doctor
 
Frw days back ,a video was going viral showing a man begging a doctor to treat his relative in Larkana?sindh.

The doctor didnt even care, barking at security to throw out the man.
 
this is a remnant of the great indian caste system.

hope it gets wiped away soon
 
Interior Sindh still has Hindu era cast system and people behave as such. They even touch elder's feet as greetings same way as Hindus do.
 
This economic class system is ingrained within the rural areas of Sindh. Ive seen horrible treatment of poor people there which no animal deserves much less human

Is it a question of class or hygiene?

Interior Sindh still has Hindu era cast system and people behave as such. They even touch elder's feet as greetings same way as Hindus do.

You are mixing up feudalism with Hindu varna system.

A doctor should be the last person on earth to complain about filth.

Actually Doctors maintain and required to maintain high quality of hygiene.

Rather than blaming the doctors and the caste system, people should first ponder why people have to get into the filth and do such jobs when world is moving towards automation of every aspect if life.

1) A device to check for the existence of the poisonous gases could have been used

2) A full suit with oxygen masks could have been provided

3) A remote camera driven de-clogging system could have been used

People would not talk about these as it would reflect the failure of the authorities and ministries responsible for these. The easiest way would be to blame the religion and doctors.
 
They even touch elder's feet as greetings same way as Hindus do.

I don't think that's something inherently evil to be noted like this. Its a harmless gesture of respect towards elders and if their culture continues to abide by it, I don't think that should be noted as a fault.
 
I don't think that's something inherently evil to be noted like this. Its a harmless gesture of respect towards elders and if their culture continues to abide by it, I don't think that should be noted as a fault.
yes, but it originates from hinduism
 
A Doctor's job is to save lives irrespective of what condition they are in. This is just wrong on many levels.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom