What's new

Rafale – The obvious choice for India’s Strategic Forces Command

Why can't we consider SU-35 for this purpose?We have good experience with the MKI and this aircraft has all that the SFC requires including high degree of stealth and setting up of new infrastructure is also not required(i think).

if india fly su 35 it will be obvious its nuclear .
it can only be effective as deterrent but not for delivering the weapons.
also in pre emptive strike enemies can concentrate on bases housing these air craft
 
Not happening until Rafale is chosen for MRCA. We cannot make our entire air wing into a zoo. The objective is to homogenize the entire fighter fleet of India (IAF, ISC and SFC all three). Just for the sake of 40 fighters if we get Rafales, the costs will be needless.

Su-35s are a better choice due to their maximum similarity with MKIs and limited time needed to train the pilots. Or if SFC can wait out a decade, it can even consider special squadrons of FGFAs.
 
I think SU-34 can also be a good choice for SFC as it is a bomb truck. It can deliver huge payloads for long distances.
 
The important thing about rafale is that it has dual engine system ,it can fire air to air and air to ground missiles simultaneously,it can take off from smaller runways which makes it ideal for aircraft carriers ,i dont see a reason why we shoudnt have it.
 
The important thing about rafale is that it has dual engine system ,it can fire air to air and air to ground missiles simultaneously,it can take off from smaller runways which makes it ideal for aircraft carriers ,i dont see a reason why we shoudnt have it.
typhoon also has 2 engines but rafale is also good.hard to tell which is more capable.:mps:
 
we should go for TYPHOON!

---------- Post added at 11:23 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:22 AM ----------

Aerodynamics
The Rafale features a delta wing combined with active integrated (Close-coupled) canard to maximize maneuverability (withstanding +9 g or -3 g) while maintaining stability in flight, a maximum of 11 g can be reached in case of emergency. The canard also reduces landing speed to 115 knots. According to internal sources (Les essais en vol du Rafale) low speed limit is 100 kt but 80 kt is sometimes demonstrated during airshows by pilots willing to underline low speed qualities of the aircraft." "A minimum of 15 kt have been reached during simulated combat vs a Mirage 2000 by an aggressive pilot."[verification needed] The aircraft can operate from 400 meter runways.[15]

[edit]Combat systems


Weapon complement of the Rafale.
The Rafale carries an integrated electronic survival system named SPECTRA which features a software-based virtual stealth technology. The most important sensor is the Thales RBE2 passive electronically scanned multi-mode radar. Thales claims to have achieved unprecedented levels of situational awareness through the earlier detection and tracking of multiple air targets for close combat and long-range interception, as well as real time generation of three-dimensional maps for terrain-following and the real time generation of high resolution ground maps for navigation and targeting.[16]

In circumstances when signature management is required, the Rafale can use several passive sensor systems. The front-sector electro-optical system or Optronique Secteur Frontal (OSF), developed by Thales, is completely integrated within the aircraft and can operate both in the visible and infrared wavelengths.

The SPECTRA electronic warfare system, jointly developed by Thales and EADS France, provides the aircraft with the highest survivability assets against airborne and ground threats.[17] The real-time data link allows communication not only with other aircraft, but also with fixed and mobile command and control centres. For those missions requiring it, the Rafale will also eventually use the Damoclès electro-optical/laser designation pod that brings full day and night LGB capability, though the Armée de l'Air's current plans call for Rafale to use stand off weapons, and for the LGB role to be handled by Dassault Mirage 2000s.

The Rafale core systems employ an Integrated Modular Avionics (IMA), called MDPU (Modular Data Processing Unit). This architecture hosts all the core functions of the aircraft as Flight management system, Data Fusion, Fire Control, Man-Machine Interface, etc.[18][N 1]

The total value of the radar, electronic communications and self-protection equipment is about 30% of the cost of the entire plane.[19]

The Rafale's ground attack capability is limited by the lack of an advanced targeting pod,[20] but this will be rectified with the addition of Thales Optronique's Reco NG/Areos reconnaissance and Damocles targeting pods on the F-3 standard.[21]
 
Aerodynamics
The Rafale features a delta wing combined with active integrated (Close-coupled) canard to maximize maneuverability (withstanding +9 g or -3 g) while maintaining stability in flight, a maximum of 11 g can be reached in case of emergency. The canard also reduces landing speed to 115 knots. According to internal sources (Les essais en vol du Rafale) low speed limit is 100 kt but 80 kt is sometimes demonstrated during airshows by pilots willing to underline low speed qualities of the aircraft." "A minimum of 15 kt have been reached during simulated combat vs a Mirage 2000 by an aggressive pilot."[verification needed] The aircraft can operate from 400 meter runways.[15]

[edit]Combat systems


Weapon complement of the Rafale.
The Rafale carries an integrated electronic survival system named SPECTRA which features a software-based virtual stealth technology. The most important sensor is the Thales RBE2 passive electronically scanned multi-mode radar. Thales claims to have achieved unprecedented levels of situational awareness through the earlier detection and tracking of multiple air targets for close combat and long-range interception, as well as real time generation of three-dimensional maps for terrain-following and the real time generation of high resolution ground maps for navigation and targeting.[16]

In circumstances when signature management is required, the Rafale can use several passive sensor systems. The front-sector electro-optical system or Optronique Secteur Frontal (OSF), developed by Thales, is completely integrated within the aircraft and can operate both in the visible and infrared wavelengths.

The SPECTRA electronic warfare system, jointly developed by Thales and EADS France, provides the aircraft with the highest survivability assets against airborne and ground threats.[17] The real-time data link allows communication not only with other aircraft, but also with fixed and mobile command and control centres. For those missions requiring it, the Rafale will also eventually use the Damoclès electro-optical/laser designation pod that brings full day and night LGB capability, though the Armée de l'Air's current plans call for Rafale to use stand off weapons, and for the LGB role to be handled by Dassault Mirage 2000s.

The Rafale core systems employ an Integrated Modular Avionics (IMA), called MDPU (Modular Data Processing Unit). This architecture hosts all the core functions of the aircraft as Flight management system, Data Fusion, Fire Control, Man-Machine Interface, etc.[18][N 1]

The total value of the radar, electronic communications and self-protection equipment is about 30% of the cost of the entire plane.[19]

The Rafale's ground attack capability is limited by the lack of an advanced targeting pod,[20] but this will be rectified with the addition of Thales Optronique's Reco NG/Areos reconnaissance and Damocles targeting pods on the F-3 standard.[21]


---------- Post added at 11:24 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:24 AM ----------

Although not a true stealth aircraft, the Rafale has reduced radar signature according to Dassault, while most of the stealth design features are classified, extensive use of composite materials and serrated patterns on the trailing edges of the wings and canards help to reduce the radar cross section.[24]

---------- Post added at 11:25 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:24 AM ----------

The new Thales RBE2 AA Active Electronically Scanned Array (AESA) radar is planned to replace the existing passively scanned array of the RBE2. Thales will begin deliveries of the new radar in August 2010 for use on the fourth tranche of Rafale aircraft. A total of 60 tranche four aircraft have been ordered to date. The first AESA-equipped squadron of aircraft is expected to become operational in 2012. Thales also claims that the AESA radar will improve the operational capabilities of the aircraft in terms of range, interception, tracking ability and countermeasures.[22]
 
our missiles are not unreliable.agni-1 and agni-2 are inducted in INDIAN ARMY.prithvi is 100% operational.my choice is EF TYPHOON.

EFT is a very bad choice for SFC since its A2G capabilities are far inferior to other options out there. The best bet would be the SU34- one heck of a bomb truck.
 
I disagree with your statement...Nuclear command should always be in the hands of separate entity...Let Airforce concentrate on defending our skies and dominating others..

Infact in my opinion SSBNs should also be taken out of NAVY's command and placed under Strategic command.

I agree with you, a separate nuclear command would means more better and organized structure. In this case nobody would waste their time to think which plane should use for nuke strike and whom should choose for this as you already has a command for this so let that command do this.

It's good idea to take SSBN under Strategic command but I think they must be in joint command with navy and strategic command for more enhanced operational abilities.
 
What Indian need to do is buy 42 plane each

42 Rafale
42 EF
42 F-18
in that case they dont need to make anyone angry except russians and Sweden, which is I think ok for them....lol
 
What Indian need to do is buy 42 plane each

42 Rafale
42 EF
42 F-18
in that case they dont need to make anyone angry except russians and Sweden, which is I think ok for them....lol
LOL! No man, we're having a zoo already in IAF. The aim is to homogenize our fleet of fighters to 3 types (Indian, Russian/JV, European) to reduce maintenance costs.

SFC is totally different and their requirements are far different from IAFs. WE don't care who is angry and who's not as whatever satisfies our need wins. Plain and simple. If their threat is to give you weapons (which they do anyway), they can go ahead and do so and lose their future possibilities with us. :lol:

I think we should go for F-35IN...

And let US decide whom we drop bombs on in case of war? NO thanks.
 
Back
Top Bottom