Pullout of Mamata sets India at danger

[LaBong]

Whatever be the reason, A mere chief minister of India walking out on talks being led the heads of states in a foreign country is an insult to everbody involved.Mrs. Mamata Banerjee isn't 10 to throw tantrums and hissy fits,she is free to do all that in West Bengal and not in Bangladesh.She should apologize for insulting Bangladesh as well as the Indian political system.Even the United States doesn't pull off such arrogance.Shame on her

Still in school?

 

[monitor]

Mamta Banerjee's activities
baddarundin umar
Mahogany
'I through the nose naruna retaliation, glabrous dumaduma Fig, I know her country through brute smoke - then the Communist Party of India's independence is affected by' gananatya instant, it was one of the most popular songs. The situation is so new to the West. Mamta Banerjee the Chief Minister there new 'miracle' staff are trying to turn. He has already announced that ninety percent of the time he was given his pledge to meet you! His grandfather was a commitment to the stadium to the creation of the world bamkuraya! Kalakatake Sign up! And above all the two years of employment within the 10 million people! Among his many other commitments to be met, the three now remaining. It is not, as far as possible before any symptoms or not. A lot of different places around the country during the King incognito harunara Rashid and his people about the situation. Mamta Banerjee are incognito will not be covered as a half-harunara Rashid, dressed in his familiar suit conditions, hospitals, schools, markets, and a sudden case of indiscipline and corruption to these missions nemechilena, just after the seat of power gadite. His efforts now fall with the restless and visionary. Because of these irregularities and corruption and thus it is not possible, such as anna thousands through starvation, but it is not possible through any kind of sudden inspections.

Trinamool Congress leader Mamta Banerjee in West Bengal in the last elections in the previous ÏpÏfHj abjectly defeated the government has been subject to much mischief. Than the government's own superiority and janadarada government to prove that he is working on his elopataribhabe some people happy, but I was not happy to be permanent, temporary featureless. The primary reason bhayabhitira evil, irresponsible and corrupt people, but some careful work and temporarily shut down their akartabya allows the habits and behavior they are already in the loop. That's normal, because one of the most serious problem, and the deep crisis through a long, long talk, and throw one's weight problem should not be possible. The West Bengal government in a way, it's actually not a party to the government. It is, Mamta Banerjee, the government of one person. He does not exist any more than the party. And to anyone outside of the tissue. Like his personal mandate by the Government of West Bengal. Some jobs are primarily in the state, but the situation in West Bengal for development of the long - wide commitment he gave, it was met with any affair. In addition to the work he is doing something odd about it, that would be impractical, hasyakarao well. Such a work is in Kolkata, all the time for each traffic laite rabindrasangita instruments. If so, traffic lights, passing the time, or to listen to Rabindra arm of the sound of music. He is one method of creating a bhebechena kalakatake London! However, this type of work in London on behalf of any government to survive, it will be difficult. Thus, all traffic laite rabindrasangita bajale or any of the music is not music bajale it is to become a word dusane. Mamta Banerjee Thus Tagore's birth anniversary sardhasata sabdadusane into his music by? Each traffic light as a result, residents around their houses are in poor condition. They are always uneasy listening rabindrasangita!

West Bengal, the name change from the first of many conversations, discussion, debate has been. Since its name was the first Bengali to favoring ÏpÏfHj. The name change is not the end of the West tetrisa bachareo their time. West Bengal, the name change, a new reminder of the East Bengali Bangladesh haoyate appeared. Mamta Banerjee has also held a meeting to start a quick name change to show the work completed by the decision. Despite the name of the Maoists are not acceptable, they did not have any objection. Mamta Banerjee in West Bengal wish to change the name unanimously and in accordance with the proposal. But the best thing that happened was surprising and, in West Bengal with the name of 'change', which has been pascimabangai! In other words, it is just that, before the went to pascimabangake West Bangal, now, rather than to speak and write English, pascimabangake in West Bengal-of Pashchimbanga!! The name change from the 'breakthrough' could change what? Before the election, will not return to the 'Mamta Banerjee and the sound was bhotayuddhe dismounted. Some of it is for the government to start work on his change of status that the West's name changed Pashchimbanga dekhaleo like to keep the stand - the possibility that the defendant, and pursuant sipiemabirodhi and affection many have occurred.

Maoists in West Midnapore and the jungle very janabirodhi role and torture because of the deplorable state of the Maoists. Very bad relations with the Maoists Maoists. Adapted to people, especially in the milk of human kindness paiye jangalamahalera some people have. However, politically the most disabling and absorb the thoughts of the Maoists, he was, he thought he was now facing the crisis. Furthermore, the central government and its intelligence agencies to the presence of armed police on siarapisi become a way to stop it. Mamta Banerjee that the torture by now if it was closing, or the solicitation of requests for kendrake will occasionally not have a job. Thus, shortly there will be situations like the previous one, and only the central sarakarai, and affection between the state government to be tortured like the previous ÏpÏfHj led bamaphranta government. What we stand at the grassroots and state that there is no detailed discussion of some here.

Mamta Banerjee is the latest celebrity, according to pre-scheduled programs with the Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on 6 September sinyera canceled his tour of Bangladesh. His party had decided to make a decision because of the sudden, and suddenly the thought of his appearance, that this visit tistara water distribution that is designed to be given the contract after the purchase of additional water (50:50 per cent) so that the West will be affected. To protect from this damage, so he pascimabangake Bangladesh - India panicuktira opposition. Because of this opposition, he canceled his tour of Bangladesh and West Bengal is one of yourself and try to prove the sole representative and leader. The reason for this opposition between the two countries have not been any panicukti. Not only tistai, with many other rivers in India should be related to water cuktii! It was a step tista panicukti sedika. West of the 'undisputed' leader as well as to increase the popularity of these initiatives was the creation of the barrier. Thus, it seems that he can keep his popularity is not long persist. This is a reply to his impatience, and various bizarre and fantastic happen Programme.
[Source: My Country, 08/09/11] amar desh

 

[Perceptron]

Mamta Banerjee's activities
baddarundin umar
Mahogany
'I through the nose naruna retaliation, glabrous dumaduma Fig, I know her country through brute smoke - then the Communist Party of India's independence is affected by' gananatya instant, it was one of the most popular songs. The situation is so new to the West. Mamta Banerjee the Chief Minister there new 'miracle' staff are trying to turn. He has already announced that ninety percent of the time he was given his pledge to meet you! His grandfather was a commitment to the stadium to the creation of the world bamkuraya! Kalakatake Sign up! And above all the two years of employment within the 10 million people! Among his many other commitments to be met, the three now remaining. It is not, as far as possible before any symptoms or not. A lot of different places around the country during the King incognito harunara Rashid and his people about the situation. Mamta Banerjee are incognito will not be covered as a half-harunara Rashid, dressed in his familiar suit conditions, hospitals, schools, markets, and a sudden case of indiscipline and corruption to these missions nemechilena, just after the seat of power gadite. His efforts now fall with the restless and visionary. Because of these irregularities and corruption and thus it is not possible, such as anna thousands through starvation, but it is not possible through any kind of sudden inspections.

Trinamool Congress leader Mamta Banerjee in West Bengal in the last elections in the previous ÏpÏfHj abjectly defeated the government has been subject to much mischief. Than the government's own superiority and janadarada government to prove that he is working on his elopataribhabe some people happy, but I was not happy to be permanent, temporary featureless. The primary reason bhayabhitira evil, irresponsible and corrupt people, but some careful work and temporarily shut down their akartabya allows the habits and behavior they are already in the loop. That's normal, because one of the most serious problem, and the deep crisis through a long, long talk, and throw one's weight problem should not be possible. The West Bengal government in a way, it's actually not a party to the government. It is, Mamta Banerjee, the government of one person. He does not exist any more than the party. And to anyone outside of the tissue. Like his personal mandate by the Government of West Bengal. Some jobs are primarily in the state, but the situation in West Bengal for development of the long - wide commitment he gave, it was met with any affair. In addition to the work he is doing something odd about it, that would be impractical, hasyakarao well. Such a work is in Kolkata, all the time for each traffic laite rabindrasangita instruments. If so, traffic lights, passing the time, or to listen to Rabindra arm of the sound of music. He is one method of creating a bhebechena kalakatake London! However, this type of work in London on behalf of any government to survive, it will be difficult. Thus, all traffic laite rabindrasangita bajale or any of the music is not music bajale it is to become a word dusane. Mamta Banerjee Thus Tagore's birth anniversary sardhasata sabdadusane into his music by? Each traffic light as a result, residents around their houses are in poor condition. They are always uneasy listening rabindrasangita!

West Bengal, the name change from the first of many conversations, discussion, debate has been. Since its name was the first Bengali to favoring ÏpÏfHj. The name change is not the end of the West tetrisa bachareo their time. West Bengal, the name change, a new reminder of the East Bengali Bangladesh haoyate appeared. Mamta Banerjee has also held a meeting to start a quick name change to show the work completed by the decision. Despite the name of the Maoists are not acceptable, they did not have any objection. Mamta Banerjee in West Bengal wish to change the name unanimously and in accordance with the proposal. But the best thing that happened was surprising and, in West Bengal with the name of 'change', which has been pascimabangai! In other words, it is just that, before the went to pascimabangake West Bangal, now, rather than to speak and write English, pascimabangake in West Bengal-of Pashchimbanga!! The name change from the 'breakthrough' could change what? Before the election, will not return to the 'Mamta Banerjee and the sound was bhotayuddhe dismounted. Some of it is for the government to start work on his change of status that the West's name changed Pashchimbanga dekhaleo like to keep the stand - the possibility that the defendant, and pursuant sipiemabirodhi and affection many have occurred.

Maoists in West Midnapore and the jungle very janabirodhi role and torture because of the deplorable state of the Maoists. Very bad relations with the Maoists Maoists. Adapted to people, especially in the milk of human kindness paiye jangalamahalera some people have. However, politically the most disabling and absorb the thoughts of the Maoists, he was, he thought he was now facing the crisis. Furthermore, the central government and its intelligence agencies to the presence of armed police on siarapisi become a way to stop it. Mamta Banerjee that the torture by now if it was closing, or the solicitation of requests for kendrake will occasionally not have a job. Thus, shortly there will be situations like the previous one, and only the central sarakarai, and affection between the state government to be tortured like the previous ÏpÏfHj led bamaphranta government. What we stand at the grassroots and state that there is no detailed discussion of some here.

Mamta Banerjee is the latest celebrity, according to pre-scheduled programs with the Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on 6 September sinyera canceled his tour of Bangladesh. His party had decided to make a decision because of the sudden, and suddenly the thought of his appearance, that this visit tistara water distribution that is designed to be given the contract after the purchase of additional water (50:50 per cent) so that the West will be affected. To protect from this damage, so he pascimabangake Bangladesh - India panicuktira opposition. Because of this opposition, he canceled his tour of Bangladesh and West Bengal is one of yourself and try to prove the sole representative and leader. The reason for this opposition between the two countries have not been any panicukti. Not only tistai, with many other rivers in India should be related to water cuktii! It was a step tista panicukti sedika. West of the 'undisputed' leader as well as to increase the popularity of these initiatives was the creation of the barrier. Thus, it seems that he can keep his popularity is not long persist. This is a reply to his impatience, and various bizarre and fantastic happen Programme.
[Source: My Country, 08/09/11] amar desh

It would be well worth the effort if you can translate it manually than running it through a Google Translator. Better yet, summarize key points and give an insight into the article.

 

[Maira La]

This thread is pointless and should be closed asap. No offence to anyone, but I don't see how denying Teesta water to BD puts India at danger. The one in danger is BD.

Mamata is an experienced politician and knows very well what she's doing. Drama at the 11th hour is not mis-communication, neither a last ditch effort to save North Bengal. The gentleman Dr. Monmahan did not see this coming at all, being more of an educated economist than a politician. I have read articles from The Hindu, Times of India and Anandabzar; all agree on one point - the aftermath of the drama is great increase in Mamata's popularity in Bengal, and that's dirty politics. Mark my words, Mamata is eventually going to sign a fair deal.

This is our Bangali way of doing politics. Hasina and Khaleda beats Mamata to it, though!

 

[monitor]

Mamata has prove that personal relationship has no real value in intentional politics . What our joker were talking improve relation with but with no fruitful result what will we do with this relation .

 

[Md Akmal]

Its looks like writer have written this crap from his cell in the mental asylum.

@ " Apna ghar samalu phele, apne suna nahi Delhi ke high court me bomb blust hua hai aur 14 admi mara gai "

 

[LaBong]

This thread is pointless and should be closed asap. No offence to anyone, but I don't see how denying Teesta water to BD puts India at danger. The one in danger is BD.

Mamata is an experienced politician and knows very well what she's doing. Drama at the 11th hour is not mis-communication, neither a last ditch effort to save North Bengal. The gentleman Dr. Monmahan did not see this coming at all, being more of an educated economist than a politician. I have read articles from The Hindu, Times of India and Anandabzar; all agree on one point - the aftermath of the drama is great increase in Mamata's popularity in Bengal, and that's dirty politics. Mark my words, Mamata is eventually going to sign a fair deal.

This is our Bangali way of doing politics. Hasina and Khaleda beats Mamata to it, though!

While it's true Mamata is known for demagogic politics, but she does have a point in this case. 35 K to 50 K cusec from Teesta will leave North Bengal dry, heck even in Ganges water share treaty BD has the provision for 45 k cusec during dry season, Teesta is like a canal compared to Ganges.

I don't think Mamata will have a problem if the deal is fair and considers everyone's interest.

 

[TopCat]

While it's true Mamata is known for demagogic politics, but she does have a point in this case. 35 K to 50 K cusec from Teesta will leave North Bengal dry, heck even in Ganges water share treaty BD has the provision for 45 k cusec during dry season, Teesta is like a canal compared to Ganges.

I don't think Mamata will have a problem if the deal is fair and considers everyone's interest.

Where did you get the 35K number?

India wants 16K wherewas BD wanted 8K in lean season. But total water in Teesta in lean season goes down to 8K cusec. So the deal was to split it 52%/48% proportion from where 20% will be reserved for Bay of Bengal. Literally BD is getting 28% at the distribution point. You think its not fair but Mamata's forumla of giving 25% to BD is fair where BD can only use 5% of the total water?

 

[LaBong]

Where did you get the 35K number?

India wants 16K wherewas BD wanted 8K in lean season. But total water in Teesta in lean season goes down to 8K cusec. So the deal was to split it 52%/48% proportion from where 20% will be reserved for Bay of Bengal. Literally BD is getting 28% at the distribution point. You think its not fair but Mamata's forumla of giving 25% to BD is fair where BD can only use 5% of the total water?

"Had the agreement been inked in its present form there would have been acute shortage of irrigation water in the lean months from December-April," Rudra, a former lecturer in Geography in Calcutta University, told the media.


Referring to the proposed treaty providing for sharing 33,000-50,000 cusecs water with Bangladesh, Rudra said from June-September the river has more water. In July the flow is the highest at 70,000 cusecs.

"From June-September the river has surplus water. But then during this season there is plenty of rain and irrigation is not required. It is in the lean season that irrigation is needed. In the lean season the river has between 3,500-4,000 cusecs only."

Teesta water sharing pact hasty: Expert

Only fault I see in Mamata is the inexperience and lack of intelligence of TMC groupies compared to those of CPM.

 

[TopCat]

Mr. Rudra was misinformed.
I gave the exact deal.


From Now on all the water sharing will be on the basis of 50/50 proportion without going through technical fuss. 6 more rivers on the table and 4 of your chief ministers including your PM gave consent to it. Mamata should understand other's concern as well. The 4 chief ministers gone empty handed and they are really disappointed.

 

[LaBong]

Mr. Rudra was misinformed.
I gave the exact deal.


From Now on all the water sharing will be on the basis of 50/50 proportion without going through technical fuss. 6 more rivers on the table and 4 of your chief ministers including your PM gave consent to it. Mamata should understand other's concern as well. The 4 chief ministers gone empty handed and they are really disappointed.

Have you read the draft? I don't believe a professor of Calcutta University would comment without reading the draft. There has been a last minute change without informing the state as per Mamata, I don't recall MMS or Menon to counter her allegation.

 

[Gonjo]

Second thing BD will never attack India to take control of assam or NE as it is against the constitution of Bangladesh even if it has the military power...If NE India ever get liberated it will be done by the people of NE India themselves..

Yap, in the modern time like Soviet, Lybia. Those NE states will be collapsed from within itself, no need waste any bullet.

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Mr. Rudra was misinformed.
I gave the exact deal.


From Now on all the water sharing will be on the basis of 50/50 proportion without going through technical fuss. 6 more rivers on the table and 4 of your chief ministers including your PM gave consent to it. Mamata should understand other's concern as well. The 4 chief ministers gone empty handed and they are really disappointed.

What gifts were the four Chief Ministers expecting that they went empty handed?

While one cannot condone the attitude of Ms Bannerjee because this is not a local election issue and instead it is an international issue, nonetheless, the GoI at Delhi cannot just go around as if they are some Mughul Emperor going around and giving largess to anyone and everyone.

 

[RockyX]

Yap, in the modern time like Soviet, Lybia. Those NE states will be collapsed from within itself, no need waste any bullet.

Since, Day-Dreaming is the national hobby of Bangladesh, So you don't need answer for that but Many parts of Bangladesh will be under water by next century without any bullet. Think of that.

 

[Tiki Tam Tam]

Put your crap to yourselves... Just see what has happened to USA in a defence less plain desert country like Iraq and India is just a tiny piece compared to USA military...

Second thing BD will never attack India to take control of assam or NE as it is against the constitution of Bangladesh even if it has the military power...If NE India ever get liberated it will be done by the people of NE India themselves.. as they are treated very badly... by the indian babau and muslims and banglalis combined there are supposed to be majority ... muslim 33% official figure ... in reality 40% or more and bengalis 40-45% by official figure if not crossed 50% by now. These bengalis and muslims are regularly abused and discriminated by terming them as illegal migrants... it will not take much time for them to take up arms.. to liberate the land from the Indian babau.. it is not only bengalis and muslims of assam but many local populations also does not want to remain under control of India... major terror groups or freedom fighers whatever you say are mostly made up by local peoples.

N in modern day war does not won by planes, tanks and bomb instead by mead and controlling hearts and minds of the people... Do you really think when liberation movement in Assam or NE india will start india will be able to kill the entire protesters.. n whole world will remain silent... specially pakistan, china and bangladesh.. to start with.. just after few days people will ask for cease fire.. and declare that region as autonomous which will be the beginning of the end and eventually be liberated ... by referendum or anything such that...In any event of war bd, pakistan n china will try to opt a national referendum to see what the prole of that region wants... which hardly US or EU will be able to ignore and as a so called biggest democracy India will also not be able to deny.

This is as fare and simple as that.

If you understood warfare, you would understand the issue.

As far as Iraq is concerned, the US has got the country in its kitty in case you are not aware of the same.

The US has left the Sunnis and Shais warring amongst themselves and have hunkered down in their Base watching the fun and games and still calling the shot.

What more do you think the US could do? Declare Iraq as the 51st state of the US?

Constitutions are a piece of paper. What makes you feel that BD will abide by what you state by BD will never attack India to take control of assam or NE as it is against the constitution of Bangladesh even if it has the military power... ?

Could you give the extract of the BD constitution that states that taking control of X (whatever be the means) is a taboo to BD?

As far as the BD Constitution is concerned, must we say more. Is the circus that has taken place recently over it thanks to the two major party is not an indicator that it is not sacrosanct?

But then you are but you. You can say anything that suits the situation even if it merely a figment of your own fevered imagination!