Poll | Should there be a 'total ban' on Indian media in Pakistan??

[farhan_9909]

Just like Yankees follows the culture of Native Americans or Australians follow the culture the aboriginals !

any way which philosophy or cultural Pakistanis even loosely follow which are based on Indus valley civilization . again five sentences plz !

The part is that the indigenous people of Indus valley civilization were from the present day Pakistan,we might have changed our religion but it doesn't change the fact as to we are the inventor of Sanskrit,panini was from charsada,KPK,yoga,Rig veda or the monotheist rig veda based religion.We still are monothiest.

Persian are muslim today or greek are christians and they don't follow zoraster or zeus anymore but the history of both is still associated with them,

The part is that no matter how much harder you try,You won't be able to claim an inch of IVC history from us as we hold the patents of IVC history and we have not corrupted the rig veda but be merged with modern hinduism(Merged form of many central and south indian religion with the major contribution of Rig veda stolen from our side)

in other words: Mohajirs, blaochis and pashtuns are lesser pakstanis ! jeeye punjabistan !

Lol,we are talking about the majority part kiddu.

I am a pashtun myself and our history again is different to IVC,I was just debunking the bharti drama about we being similar culturally or anything else

 

[punit]

The part is that the indigenous people of Indus valley civilization were from the present day Pakistan,we might have changed our religion but it doesn't change the fact as to we
so u changed ur religion .. what else is left to change ! there goes 90% of the claim.

Now the cultural part :

are the inventor of Sanskrit,panini was from charsada.
what is the percentage of Sanskrit words in the language of Pakistan!! or which derivative language of Sanskrit is used in modern pakistan.

KPK,yoga,Rig veda or the monotheist rig veda based religion.
Monotheism of Vedas has nothing to do with Islam. Do not compare the vedic philosophy with Abrahamic tribal god philosophy. Sanatan dharma is the continuity of Vaidic philosophy with changes & correction which were need of time.

We still are monothiest.

explained earlier !!

Persian are muslim today or greek are christians and they don't follow zoraster or zeus anymore but the history of both is still associated with them,
because there is no descendant left to claim !! while Modern India is continuity of IVC and Vedic Civ both in philosophy as well as religion.


The part is that no matter how much harder you try,You won't be able to claim an inch of IVC history from us as we hold the patents of IVC history and we have not corrupted the rig veda but be merged with modern hinduism(Merged form of many central and south indian religion with the major contribution of Rig veda stolen from our side)

which part of Rig veda is being followed in Pakistani cultural and religious life?

Pakistani are the most confused among the lot. They are descendant of Cental Asian, Arabian as well Vedic societies ! In short they are of none !!

 

[Afridistan]

A person's allegiance depends on what he believes. The very base Pakistan's ideology is the two nation theory, which clearly states that muslims and hindus are two different nations. Their language, ancestry, history might be common but a muslim is a muslim and a hindu is a hindu, no matter what.
If Pakistan thinks that Indian media is posing a threat to its culture and religion, then it will be folly if appropriate steps for dealing with the situation are not taken.
Its not only the borders of a country that need protection.

 

[nangyale]

Correct. It's not only the borders that need be protected.
The future of Pakistani identity is at stake here. If we want to continue with open access to our air waves to Indian media, we might as well surrender the rest too.
It may not be so obvious today but in a generation time --with the constant onslaught of these channels-- there won't be left much of a Pakistani identity.

 

[raja hindustani]

Correct. It's not only the borders that need be protected.
The future of Pakistani identity is at stake here. If we want to continue with open access to our air waves to Indian media, we might as well surrender the rest too.
It may not be so obvious today but in a generation time --with the constant onslaught of these channels-- there won't be left much of a Pakistani identity.

Would it not be better for both Indian and Paksitani entertainment industry, if we allow Pakistani TV shows and movies and you allow Indian TV shows and movies , and let the people watch what they want to watch?

 

[kaku1]

Correct. It's not only the borders that need be protected.
The future of Pakistani identity is at stake here. If we want to continue with open access to our air waves to Indian media, we might as well surrender the rest too.
It may not be so obvious today but in a generation time --with the constant onslaught of these channels-- there won't be left much of a Pakistani identity.

So, if one watch Hollywood movie or Big Bang Episodes or Games of Thrones, so he/she surrender to westerners. What pathetic argument you making.

 

[kurup]

Thread was started in 2013 ..... Have they completely banned Indian content yet ??

 

[nangyale]

Would it not be better for both Indian and Paksitani entertainment industry, if we allow Pakistani TV shows and movies and you allow Indian TV shows and movies , and let the people watch what they want to watch?

India being a bigger country has a bigger market thus will always have bigger budgets, the only way for Pakistan to have a media of its own it to make an overall ban on India media.

So, if one watch Hollywood movie or Big Bang Episodes or Games of Thrones, so he/she surrender to westerners. What pathetic argument you making.

What one grown up does with his/her computer in the privacy of his house is his business and will be extremely difficult to police anyway.
The argument here is about broadcast media and cable networks.

 

[kaku1]

India being a bigger country has a bigger market thus will always have bigger budgets, the only way for Pakistan to have a media of its own it to make an overall ban on India media.


What one grown up does with his/her computer in the privacy of his house is his business and will be extremely difficult to police anyway.
The argument here is about broadcast media and cable networks.

lol, bro in India, Big Bang Theory is broadcasting on Star World, and most of the Hollywood movie is broadcasting on many English channels?

Whats your point?

 

[raja hindustani]

Whats your point?

I think his point is that India is large enough to accommodate both Indian and foreign TV shows and movies. There are so many people who watch both Indian and Hollywood movies that it is not a problem for Indian movie industry. But Pakistan is comparatively a smaller market and also the entertainment industry has lower budget so they find it difficult to compete.

 

[kaku1]

I think his point is that India is large enough to accommodate both Indian and foreign TV shows and movies. There are so many people who watch both Indian and Hollywood movies that it is not a problem for Indian movie industry. But Pakistan is comparatively a smaller market and also the entertainment industry has lower budget so they find it difficult to compete.

Bro, there is two points, he trying to prove cultural problem through economical sense.

If there is economical problem, then levy a tax on Indian movie, whats the point in banning them.

 

[MilSpec]

What about sports,IPL,already Pakistani cricket matches r played in Dubai,UK or some other country.

I think the government of pakistan should respect the views of it's subjects. If the view on PDF is any close to ground realities, then absolutely pakistani government should bring about an ordinance which prohibits everything Indian, right from entertainment programming, arts, literature, sports, machine tools, education..all of it....India on the other hand needs do the exact opposite, and Indian population in general has no such qualms.

 

[nangyale]

lol, bro in India, Big Bang Theory is broadcasting on Star World, and most of the Hollywood movie is broadcasting on many English channels?

Whats your point?

My point is that both India and Pakistan have two tier markets.
One is for what can be called as the Desi entertainment market, the other is for foreign language content--mostly dominated by Hollywood.
The international media market is the same for both countries, banning Indian media wouldn't have much affect on it's consumers.
On the other hand If Pakistan give free reign to Indian media on Pakistani airwaves, then the desi-contents market will become very hard for Pakistani content to compete in.

 

[Asian.Century]

Pink shaded Pakistan and Afghanistan all Indus Valley Civilization, origins Pakistan:

Origins of Indus Valley Civilization early roots and expansion, truly belonging to Pakistan :

Ganges Civilization or Ganga insidie India, Bangladesh, Uttarakhand, UP, JharKhand, Bihar and West Bengal:

The Ganges River: The Heart of Indian Civilization

 

[kaku1]

My point is that both India and Pakistan have two tier markets.
One is for what can be called as the Desi entertainment market, the other is for foreign language content--mostly dominated by Hollywood.
The international media market is the same for both countries, banning Indian media wouldn't have much affect on it's consumers.
On the other hand If Pakistan give free reign to Indian media on Pakistani airwaves, then the desi-contents market will become very hard for Pakistani content to compete in.

So, its economical. Then, why banning, there are other methods to, levy a tax on Indian content, like on movies, ads, serials etc.

I am no expert on that, but the current world is world of globalization, banning is outrageous, even I say banning youtube was outrageous, the current world is of tv and internet, but banning them seems me like little harsh censorship.