What's new

Pakistan’s poor handling brings UAE, India closer

Devil Soul

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
22,931
Reaction score
45
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Pakistan’s poor handling brings UAE, India closer
Kasuri suggests full time minister to deal foreign affairs of Pakistan

LAHORE – A recent defence agreement between the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and India has arisen many questions regarding foreign policy of Pakistan as the proximity of the two is result of a ‘poor handling’ of affairs by the Foreign Office if not a complete failure vis-a-viz Arab world.


Looking at the history of Pakistan-UAE relations, it come to light that the Middle Eastern nation is a major investor in Pakistan's key sectors like oil and gas, telecommunications, real estate, aviation, banking and energy. A report by UAE's Ministry of Foreign Trade tells that its public and private sectors invested about $3.74 billion in Pakistan from in the early years of this century and the Dirham – UAE currency – continued pouring in Pakistan’s economy till now.


The main investments were made in different sector by the Emirates National Oil Company (ENOC), the International Petroleum Investment Company (IPIC), the Emirates Telecommunications Corporation (Etisalat), Dana Gas; Al Ghurai; Emaar, DP World, Abraaj Capital, Thani, Danata, Atharihra Agricultural Company; Gulf Pharmaceutical Industries (Julfar), the Emirates Investment Group, the Arab Company for Packaging and Al Nasser Holdings.


– Pakistan’s contributions –


The love is not one sided as Pakistan has significantly cooperated with the UAE in the establishment of its major institutions like armed force, police, health and education. Besides 1.25-1.50 million skilled and semi-skilled Pakistani expatriates are living in the UAE, contributing significantly to the progress of both the countries. According to an estimate, 20 percent of the Pakistani expatriates are working white-collar jobs, whereas 80 per cent are working blue-collar jobs.


It is a fact that the road of relationship to the ‘Trucial States’ passes through Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) that was in difficult situation due to Yemen-based Houthi tribes. The Saudis were facing difficult time because of the attacks by the insurgents from Yemen. They were advancing inside Saudi Arabia. The Saudis expected the Pakistan Army to reach there and defend their soil. It was perhaps the first time when Pakistan authorities refused to send its troops to the kingdom. Pakistan received a ‘message of displeasure’ from the UAE at that time too. It is obvious that the nearness between the two countries – UAE and India – is not without the blessings of Saudi Arabia.


What gets India from its Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s two-day visit to the UAE is narrated by Poonam Mahajan, India’s Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) lawmaker from Mumbai: “For the first time, UAE and India are on the same wavelength with respect to terrorism. The prime minister in his speech has categorically mentioned that both countries will not tolerate the terror wreaked in the name of religion. Those who were responsible for horrendous terror attacks in the country like the 1993 Mumbai blasts and the 26/11 attacks and are still being ‘harboured’ by Pakistan ought to be punished.”


She also narrated that in order to combat terrorism, a joint statement has been made by India and UAE wherein both the countries condemn efforts, including by states, to use religion to justify, support and sponsor terrorism against other countries. “They have called for international cooperation and intelligence sharing in counter-terrorism operations. They have also proposed to work together for the adoption of India's proposed Comprehensive Convention on International Terrorism in the United Nations.”


The biggest achievement for prime Minister Modi is that the UAE announced support for India’s permanent berth in the UN Security Council. Indian investment in UAE and defence pact between the two is an added advantage. Former Foreign Affairs minister Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri is of the view that Pakistan had failed in dealing with the Saudi-Yemen issue in a proper way. “Saudi Arabia is a tried and tested friend of Pakistan and always supported it at all level and all forums,” he said.


He said that Iran was also a good neighbour. In Pakistan, both Saudi Arabia and Iran have following as Sunni people have soft corner for the Saudi kingdom while the Islamic Republic of Iran was dear to Shia people, he pointed out. “When there is an issue between the Saudi kingdom and Iran, it is needed to be dealt with care and wisely as we must know that these two countries are important to us,” he said. He commented that the Yemen issue should be dealt carefully and the two should be taken into confidence on it.


But the Foreign Office dealt the matter in a poor manner, Kasuri said. He was of the view that Pakistan is lacking a full time foreign affairs minister as the office is being held with the worthy prime minister himself who always has other engagements. At present, he said that the Foreign Office has two bosses which is also creating hurdle in smooth sailing of the affairs. The former minister is of the view that Pakistan should have talked to the Saudi kingdom and also go to Iran on the issue that could help keep the two nations near to Pakistan.


Another point of view is that the recent emergence of new alliance of four nations – Pakistan, China, Iran and Russia – has rang alarm bells for the United States and its allies. Israel and India always enjoy good relations and in these days Israel and Saudi Arabia are near to each other and the recent kind of ties between the UAE and India is to send some signals to quarters concerned. It is time for Pakistan to take a more conciliatory stance with the UAE in an attempt to counter India’s new found status.
Pakistan’s poor handling brings UAE, India closer
 
.
Well...this was expected. Pakistan was put in a precarious position during Arab vs Yemen conflict. They were bound to lose from one end..whether it was from Iran side or Arab, only due to their past partisan foreign policy. Choice was for Pakistan to make.
 
Last edited:
.
Well...this was expected. Pakistan was put in a precarious position during Arab vs Yemen conflict. They were bound lose from one end..whether it was from Iran side or Arab, only due to their past partisan foreign policy. Choice was for Pakistan to make.

Actually Pakistan will gain a lot economically if we develop better relationship with Iran, with Gulf countries only benefit is the manpower export where wages are getting smaller and smaller. With CPEC Iran China and central Asian countries are more important to Pakistan than Gulf countries.
 
.
There was no poor handling. Yes our foreign policy is quite poor but in this case we could not have made any decision differently to change the outcome. We will make the same decisions again. Only thing that a good strong foreign policy could have done was to keep the effect of our decisions to minimum.

Secondly, it is not that UAE are partnering up with India to attack our western border. Much of they hype is created by the Indian media and everyone else is following the cue. The relations of UAE and India are improving, good for them, our relations with them suffered a blow with our decision on Yemen crisis, no issues, we never did anything wrong. IN nut shell, comparing India-UAE relation improvement with UAE-Pak relation slight decline is wrong and a tool to create all this hype. These two things are not related in any way. No need to worry about any of this. We and the Arabs have been together for YEARS, not easy to break that bond. They will get over it and so will be, while the Indian will be praising there newly found love in UAE our relations are bound to get back on track soon.

ALL WE NEED TO DO IS FIND THE RIGHT BALANCE, we need good relations with the Arabs and Iran, with the West and Russians. If we have GOOD relations with all these parties then EXCELLENT relations with two or three countries will work perfectly for us. If we try to relay on EXCELLENT relations on those two three countries alone while getting isolated from rest of the world that will be a problem. Need balanced and good relations with all the mentioned parties.
 
.
Actually its not a bad thing to happen or you can call it blessing in disguies, this will help us to move away them as we have already taken majot steps to block their finances t talibans, arabs are furious because of this and they are just showing their true colours, what pakistani nation must realize that there is no such thing as ummah, whbshould we take pain of whoe ummah if they show their back in out time of need, wether its egypt, iraq or any other country our history is full of it. Time to make ourselves more stronger militalirily as well as economically, we must get rid off scums like zardari and sharif due to their personal interests and investments in these countries the sooner the better.

Enough of this ummah bllshit.
 
. . .
Well, Pakistan should not pay attention much to this Israeli-size UAE and tiny population, who care.
 
. . . .
Im so happy to see the wise comments of Pakistani members here. wow.
With such POVs, after 3 decades of lost opportunities will surely make it to Fourth Decade.

There will be a time where Pakistan will have Only one ally ( btw when even now the list is too small ) : China, which too has a $100 Billion Trade with India.

Allah Save Pakistan !
 
. .
Our relationship with KSA and other Gulf States is based on Solid and firm Ground. India can try to take advantage of temporary opportunities but in the long run India will not be successful.

Iran found out how reliable Indian Support can be, the hard way.

The Arabs know that too.

Pakistan has stuck with Arab Nations through thick and thin and they know how reliable Pakistan is.

Pakistan has taken the right stance by not being a Party to wars between Muslim Nations. Thjis is a Principled stance and we should never apologize for our Principles.

Our Arab Brothers will come around sooner or later because they know our hearts are in the right place.
 
.
Thats what the worry is .. not for Pakistan !
Delusions!!

Let me be frank, UAE has changed its strategy in the wake of rising terrorism in the region. India on one hand has been successful in thwarting most of terror attacks post 26/11 while Pakistan on the other hand is in a quagmire when it comes to handling terrorism.
Zarb-e-Arab might have been successful, but it has only been able to stop one wave of terrorists. Your porous borders and ambiguous policies have landed you into this mess.
UAE has a vast expat population (who are mostly Indians), and it has to cater to their needs. Religion now has become secondary here.
Just take a look at the joint statement made by the 2 countries and you will understand in which direction the fingers were being pointed. Go and watch Modi's speech in UAE, he dropped many hints which you seem to have missed.
I will call you naïf if you could not comprehend that the UAE now shares India's concerns over "export of terrorism" by a few states.

The joint statement...

image.jpg
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom