Featured Pakistan Navy prevented Indian Submarine from entering into Pakistani waters on 16th October

[Raj-Hindustani]

Kuch bhi..

 

[El Sidd]

Did it sail out of Somnath?

 

[SuvarnaTeja]

try harder .. create few templates with the same message so that you can copy paste fast

Why are you so worked up? Did you get some cut in the Scorpene deal or what?

 

[Reichmarshal]

the most important thing will data after flights now pakistanis have signature of these subs . it will help in future missions

Not that easy

 

[truthseeker2010]

You should visit India and meet real people. Netizens are a different breed.

I met some in US/UK/UAE.

 

[SuvarnaTeja]

I met some in US/UK/UAE.

So they are not Indians but citizens of Indian origin. That's a big difference there.

 

[TsAr]

Last I heard there was no insurgency in America or Europe.

Pakistan's General are always punching way above their weight.


DHA is for officers not soldiers. And the money the officers pay (deduction from salary) , if every pakistani is allowed on that "price" every pakistani will own a plot in DHA.

As for the efforts of insurgency its more of a "lasting effort".

DHA phase 9 was for soldiers who embraced shahadat.

 

[El Sidd]

GoP should hang her head in shame.

 

[El Sidd]

Did it sail out of Somnath?

This news came out on 12th Rabbi ul Awwal.

 

[JamD]

Assuming rational actors I have been wondering about this whole incident:

I am assuming some part of the submarine's mission is probing our defenses. In that case we shouldn't publicly disclose when and when we didnt detect them. Perhaps we have detected them way more than 3 times and choose to do a release on some detection for other reasons.

That is ISPR is letting IN know of the detection because it sees a deterrence value in our detection setup (whatever that is).


Why did ISPR do a press release on the detection? If our goal was only getting signatures of their submarines, the press release doesn't help. In that case we should have let the IN come and go with relative ease while recording their signatures. No need to possibly scare them away by saying we see you.

I believe we do not want IN subs roaming around in our waters. I suspect they may be here mapping the waters/seafloor, which is what we want to prevent.


So through that possibly flawed exercise in logic I can reverse engineer the situation.
1. IN subs have the mission of probing our defenses and mapping the waters/seafloor.
2. PN has detected IN several times more than what is said in the ISPR press release. This is because it makes sense for the PN to not reveal all their detection ability.
3. Doing the press release on saying we detected you thrice says we can detect you sometimes so please stay away and stop mapping our sea floor. So that the Indians don't know the full extent of our detection capabilities (trying to fail the IN probing mission) and deterring future missions (trying to fail the IN mapping mission).


But then I know very little of naval, let alone submarine, peacetime operations and warfare so I am just trying to think of interesting background to the whole incident

 

[PanzerKiel]

DHA phase 9 was for soldiers who embraced shahadat.

DHA schemes in every city have separate houses for shuhadas and families of soldiers who die of natural causes while in service.

 

[TsAr]

DHA schemes in every city have separate houses for shuhadas and families of soldiers who die of natural causes while in service.

that I know, but this complete phase was dedicated to shuhadas... was just letting the gentleman know...

 

[Windjammer]

Once to a question by some Western media reporter to the late Vajpaye,
''What if Indian army fails to control insurgency in Indian administered Kashmir'' ?
In a knee jerk reaction, Mr Vajpaye replied, ''If Indian army fails, we will send in the Navy'' !!!!
Later, the spin doctors tried to cover up their PM's blunder by claiming that what their PM means is sending Indian Navy to block Karachi port...
Anyways, after repeatedly being detected in the Sea, IN should try a different approach.

 

[Rafi]

By the way can someone comment how its possible given we have few MPAs and the seas are vast. Also this wasn't like Feb/Mar 2019 when the PN was on high alert. @Rafi ? @Rashid Mahmood ?

These are the dark arts, if I told you, I would have to kill you. LoL.

 

[PanzerKiel]

By the way can someone comment how its possible given we have few MPAs and the seas are vast. Also this wasn't like Feb/Mar 2019 when the PN was on high alert. @Rafi ? @Rashid Mahmood ?

That's where HUMINT and ELINT come into play.