What's new

Opinionated - Pakistan nationality related debate

Please look it up for yourself. The first references are NOT to the Sindh Valley, nor to Kashmir (I have never come across any reference to Kashmir, btw, the region was always referred to in western sources as 'Gandhara'), but to Indika.

This is the kind of historical disinformation that Hindutvavadis habitually spread around. I am sorry to see this bad practice and deliberate distortion being taken up by others.
Sindho was always the original name of our land used by locals.persians couldn't pronounce the 's' in it and used indho greeks used the same word indos in their literature not indika after learning the name from persians. . indika is Latin for " of indos.". Greeks used to call our land indos for its river indus....and it was NEVER used for present day "india".so this is unrelated to you.
 
.
Sindho was always the original name of our land used by locals.persians couldn't pronounce the 's' in it and used indho greeks used the same word indos in their literature not indika after learning the name from persians. . indika is Latin for " of indos.". Greeks used to call our land indos for its river indus....and it was NEVER used for present day "india".so this is unrelated to you.
Please don't labour the point. You are wrong in every respect, but this is not the forum to explain, unless you, on your own volition, persist in this illusion.

Having said that it is wrong, I plan to move on.
 
.
indika is Latin for " of indos.". Greeks used to call our land indos for its river indus....and it was NEVER used for present day "india".so this is unrelated to you.
Joe may have moved on, but I have all the time on my hand. so Labbaik, and I'll explain. Indika referred to all of the subcontinent/peninsula specifically including the Gangetic plains the Greeks knew about. it wasn't limited to some arbitrary four modern provinces.
 
.
Joe may have moved on, but I have all the time on my hand. so Labbaik, and I'll explain. Indika referred to all of the subcontinent/peninsula specifically including the Gangetic plains the Greeks knew about. it wasn't limited to some arbitrary four modern provinces.
But why though? Why exactly do you have so much time and energy to have random arguments on a pakistani forum with random anonymous people

It's literally most Indian users of PDF, they have so much energy and time for arguments, couple Indian members are going on since 3-4;days already, non stop chabar chabar BLA BLA BLA in multiple threads with multiple arguments

I never had more than 4-5 max Post back and forth with anyone cause that sounds like wastage of time and but most importantly boring
 
.
Please don't labour the point. You are wrong in every respect, but this is not the forum to explain, unless you, on your own volition, persist in this illusion.

Having said that it is wrong, I plan to move on.
you better should... you are in the wrong department JOE..
 
. .
Joe may have moved on, but I have all the time on my hand. so Labbaik, and I'll explain. Indika referred to all of the subcontinent/peninsula specifically including the Gangetic plains the Greeks knew about. it wasn't limited to some arbitrary four modern provinces.
That was a very pleasant surprise, thank you very much. May I DM you?

I never had more than 4-5 max Post back and forth with anyone
Not terribly surprising, honestly.
 
Last edited:
.
Joe may have moved on, but I have all the time on my hand. so Labbaik, and I'll explain. Indika referred to all of the subcontinent/peninsula specifically including the Gangetic plains the Greeks knew about. it wasn't limited to some arbitrary four modern provinces.
Indos was only for the region around the indus river...your land never became part of the greek satraps..you were discovered much much later by greeks.who was the frst greek to visit your land?...The first time you got tied to the word "india"' was when the British colonists arrived and conquered Southern Asia, in the 17th Century AD as part of their Indian Imperial Empire of South Asia; they expanded the term and applied the name to the entire region of South Asia and called it “India” by following that regional example and formally applied the Greek name for Sindh under her entire domain of the Raj respectively. ..
 
. .

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom