What's new

New Charge Sheet Links Tablighi Jamaat & Deoband to Delhi Riots

And then you have the gall to question why we fight the CAA?
CAA is duely passed by the parliament of India - the legislatures who were elected by the people. I have no problem in your protests as long as it is peaceful and doesn't disrupt movement of people.

Anna Hazare held big rallies but there was no violence and it was all held in Ramleela ground not a public road.

BTW you have appealed in the SC. If and when it is deemed constitutional then what?
 
You already have several forms of documentation that prove citizenship in India.

What would the purpose of another government agency reviewing all those documents do?

Let's say an illegal comes in 2009 and takes all illegal documents including voter id and Aadhar. The first two is pretty easy to obtain. Ration hard and it's history is pretty tough. Even if some migrates, he has to has home ration card. Even if he doesn't have, if he claims to be from a particular village, the panchayat leader or village people will identify his or her family. There are quite a few ways to track if required. However it won't be 100% accuracy.
I still do not know why even with an recent cut off date of 2011 you are opposing it. Its for your benefit and mine.
 
CAA is duely passed by the parliament of India - the legislatures who were elected by the people. I have no problem in your protests as long as it is peaceful and doesn't disrupt movement of people.

Anna Hazare held big rallies but there was no violence and it was all held in Ramleela ground not a public road.

BTW you have appealed in the SC. If and when it is deemed constitutional then what?

The only hope lies in whether the SC finds it to be afoul of Article 14. Article 15 likely will not apply.

More importantly, the judiciary has been compromised, so it will likely be deemed constitutional. I do not have any hope for a legal rectification.

As for then what - we can only work to ensure that the NRC is not implemented. Hopefully we have enough like minded people who will support us. I don't believe I can count on your support. But I do have some other Sanghi friends who do not like this NRC idea, they do feel the government has gone too far.
 
If this had been the quality of your posts earlier, a great deal of high blood pressure would have been avoided.



First, I was unwilling to believe that you were suggesting that this bill was brought in to allow the BJP to bring in Hindu illegal migrants. But you are. So on looking at what you are saying with a new look, it seems to me that you are neither supporting nor opposing the real situation but you are interested in reporting reality.

This reality: what is it? It is that the Assamese want all the illegals out. It is that the section of the Assamese themselves that are in power now, through an opportunistic use of the BJP and its manipulative power, want to retain the Hindu illegals, but reject the Muslim illegals.It is that throwing the Muslims out will not be easy; not because what @Arulmozhi Varman says is correct, that someone who has been here for 20 to 30 years cannot be thrown out, that it is impossible, but because there is no implementation of 'throwing out' is possible, or even practical.

Let us move to the next step in the argument.



Unfortunately this is a movable feast. What the electorate thought some years ago, what it thought at the time of the last elections, and what it thought after the perceived betrayal over the issue of the NRC and the results of the commission that decided citizenship eligibility are three different things.



Now the point about your clinical review of the reasons for the introduction of the CAA is understood. It was to protect the Hindus.

Next the point about the NRC. You say that is something on which both the INC and the BJP are agreed. Some confusion here: were you referring to the NRC peculiar to Assam and the Assam problem, or were you referring to the NRC on the national level that is contemplated for the near future?



We have seen these idiots take one rash and disastrous step after another. What gives us the confidence to think that we can safely dismiss the possibility of their declaring, say, between 2 and 3 crores of Muslims as non-citizens of India? And worse - then doing something disastrous with these newly-discovered non-citizens?



They didn't promise to demonetise either.





Have you? Can you give us some examples?



That has already started with a tent camp in Bengaluru. Are you making the harrassment of genuine Bengali workers a positive factor in favour of the policy that the BJP is following?

https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.in...ants-arrested-in-bengaluru-1613727-2019-10-29
 
Let's say an illegal comes in 2009 and takes all illegal documents including voter id and Aadhar. The first two is pretty easy to obtain. Ration hard and it's history is pretty tough. Even if some migrates, he has to has home ration card. Even if he doesn't have, if he claims to be from a particular village, the panchayat leader or village people will identify his or her family. There are quite a few ways to track if required. However it won't be 100% accuracy.
I still do not know why even with an recent cut off date of 2011 you are opposing it. Its for your benefit and mine.

You need to study the Assam NRC to understand how things will work. Just speculating on random things based on your limited knowledge would not suffice.
 

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom