Mystery of OBL's Body

[ptldM3]

Truth once in a while would be good. the Americans have changed their story so many time. They changed several time even in the first 48 hours. EG they said he had a gun, he had no gun, he shielded himself with a woman, no he didn't etc

By the 'Americans' do you mean media rumors? The US analyzed his body, conducted DNA tests and confirmed it was him, only then did they dump his body into the sea. No need to keep or give him a proper resting place where he would inspire other terrorists--he sure didn't care for 911 victims why should any one care for him?

And out of curiosity what should they have done? Gave him a proper funeral? Where should they have buried him? Do you believe something crazy like his corpse is in some kind of cryogenic state where it is located at CIA headquarters?

Al-Qaeda has confirmed he is dead, end of story.

 

[SyrianChristianPatriot]

Sleeping with the fish.

 

[Sugarcane]

By the 'Americans' do you mean media rumors? The US analyzed his body, conducted DNA tests and confirmed it was him, only then did they dump his body into the sea. No need to keep or give him a proper resting place where he would inspire other terrorists--he sure didn't care for 911 victims why should any one care for him?

And out of curiosity what should they have done? Gave him a proper funeral? Where should they have buried him? Do you believe something crazy like his corpse is in some kind of cryogenic state where it is located at CIA headquarters?

Al-Qaeda has confirmed he is dead, end of story.

who said he is alive, he was dead well before may 11. I think Mr. Bush the PRESIDENT OF US announced it.

 

[Nitin Goyal]

I think US forces just went in Royal mansion to deliver Osama's wives and childrens

 

[livingdead]

irrelevant to this thread. Americans know what happened and they are liars so no one knows what happened

What do you mean americans are liers, any reason to believe that or is it just your bias.
pakistan govt also lied about Kasab does not mean they lie about everything.

 

[lem34]

What do you mean americans are liers, any reason to believe that or is it just your bias.
pakistan govt also lied about Kasab does not mean they lie about everything.

Americans themselves changed their own story about Osama several times. In regards to Kasab you are off topic and in any event Indian govt has no evidence and nor do you about Pakistan involvement.

 

[Gautam]

who said he is alive, he was dead well before may 11. I think Mr. Bush the PRESIDENT OF US announced it.

so you believe the presidents as per your liking? besides is it the only reason you believe that the OBL was dead before May '11?

why al queda did not confirm it before May '11? what about the doctor? what about OBL family?

just the common sense.

 

[Gautam]

Americans themselves changed their own story about Osama several times.

can you quote the US officials making contradicting statements?

In regards to Kasab you are off topic and in any event Indian govt has no evidence and nor do you about Pakistan involvement.

you know its off topic- still you wanna continue?

 

[Sugarcane]

so you believe the presidents as per your liking? besides is it the only reason you believe that the OBL was dead before May '11? ........

apparently you are also doing so, by discarding mr. white and going along with mr. black

the remaining part of your post has been discussed lot of time on this forum, use search button

 

[lem34]

Americans themselves changed their own story about Osama several times.

can you quote the US officials making contradicting statements?

The killing of Osama bin Laden: how the White House changed its story
Bin Laden not armed and did not use woman as human shield, US admits;
The killing of Osama bin Laden: how the White House changed its story | World news | The Guardian

 

[livingdead]

Americans themselves changed their own story about Osama several times. In regards to Kasab you are off topic and in any event Indian govt has no evidence and nor do you about Pakistan involvement.

I was not talking about pakistan involvement I was talking about basic fact like citizenship of a guy caught in foreign land. Leave it as off-topic then.

The story changed many times because nobody knew the details, it happens many times. US govt wanted to break the news themselves ( instead of nytimes or some foreign country) and told it as soon as possible. Only later clarity emerged.
Are you saying this is the first time, the initial report of a incident seemed to be less accurate than what is found later?
If you watch news, it happens all the time.

Only bit of propaganda seems to be sea burial, which is basically to appease muslims.

 

[lem34]

The story changed many times because nobody knew the details, it happens many times. US govt wanted to break the news themselves ( instead of nytimes or some foreign country) and told it as soon as possible. Only later clarity emerged.
Are you saying this is the first time, the initial report of a incident seemed to be less accurate than what is found later?
If you watch news, it happens all the time.

Only bit of propaganda seems to be sea burial, which is basically to appease muslims.

Well I thin k you will see from the earlier post I put up the White House made contradictory statements at the start. As far as clarity Americans knew this and could have waited until they were certain about facts. No they lied

 

[Battle Axe]

Yankee Spin Doctors in collaboration with Wikileaks!

 

[livingdead]

Well I thin k you will see from the earlier post I put up the White House made contradictory statements at the start. As far as clarity Americans knew this and could have waited until they were certain about facts. No they lied

You are not the first one to attribute superhuman capability to americans, I would say they bungle, make mistakes as much as we do.(perhaps a bit less)
Their own intelligence and communication have been lacking in capability in many cases, saying americans as "all knowing" is going a bit too far.

Saying parts of their briefing is inaccuarate is one thing, completely dismissing the incident on basis of it shows one's own eagerness to cling onto one's own belief.

I still think they did not tell many parts of the story due to operational procedure / foreign relation / relation with muslims, I hope the declassified documents will shed more light.

 

[lem34]

You are not the first one to attribute superhuman capability to americans, I would say they bungle, make mistakes as much as we do.(perhaps a bit less)
Their own intelligence and communication have been lacking in capability in many cases, saying americans as "all knowing" is going a bit too far.

Saying parts of their briefing is inaccuarate is one thing, completely dismissing the incident on basis of it shows one's own eagerness to cling onto one's own belief.

I still think they did not tell many parts of the story due to operational procedure / foreign relation / relation with muslims, I hope the declassified documents will shed more light.

You can continue to defend them but this incidence of being liars is not the only one. There are many other times when they lie. ef WMD in Iraq etc