What's new

Myanmar to Look at Rohingya Rights

eastwatch

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 19, 2008
Messages
7,503
Reaction score
1
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Japan
Myanmar to look at Rohingya rights

Sunday, November 18, 2012
Myanmar to look at Rohingya rights
President Thein Sein writes to UN; OIC decries 'genocide'; Suu Kyi remark shocks many in India
Star report

Myanmar's president has pledged to consider new rights for the stateless Rohingya minority ahead of a landmark visit by President Barack Obama, but stopped short of a full commitment that citizenship and other new freedoms would be granted.

In a letter sent to the United Nations on Friday, President Thein Sein made conciliatory remarks that condemned the "senseless violence" in western Rakhine state between Rakhine Buddhists and Muslim Rohingya.

Almost 200 people have died and more than 1,00,000 have been displaced since June in fighting between the two communities, reports Associated press.

The persecution of Rohingyas also affects Bangladesh. Whenever communal violence breaks out in Myanmar, the minorities intrude into Bangladesh through Teknaf bordering area.

Bangladesh accommodates around 29,000 registered Rohingya refugees, although different estimates suggest the number of the Myanmarese minorities unofficially living in and around Cox's Bazar ranges between 2.5 and 5 lakh.

Yesterday, the world's top Islamic body called for the international community to protect Muslims in Myanmar's unrest-hit Rakhine state from "genocide".

"We expect the United States to convey a strong message to the government of Burma so they protect that minority, what is going on there is genocide," said Djibouti's Foreign Minister Mahmoud Ali Youssouf, who is the acting chairman of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation.

"We are telling things how they are, we believe that the United States and other ... countries ... should act quickly to save that minority which is submitted to an oppressive policy and a genocide," he said at the end of an OIC foreign ministers' meeting in Djibouti.

OIC Secretary General Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu of Turkey also urged a stop to what he called "ethnic cleansing" of the Rohingya, considered among the most persecuted groups in the world by the United Nations.

"We would like the international community to act immediately to stop the ethnic cleansing," he said.

The 57-member OIC decided at an August summit in Mecca to take the issue before the UN General Assembly, writes AFP.

Obama tomorrow will become the first sitting US president to visit Myanmar in a short but hugely symbolic trip that he hopes will spur greater reform in the once isolated country and highlight a rare success for his policy of engaging pariah regimes.

Ahead of the visit, Thein Sein said yesterday that the communal unrest was hampering the country's reforms and causing it "to lose face" on the world stage.

In October, he blocked the OIC from opening an office in the country, following rallies against the organisation's efforts to help Rakhine's Muslims.

In his letter to the UN, Thein Sein made no promises and offered no timeline for resolving the tensions, but it marked an overture to the international community and to Obama.

The White House has urged Myanmar to take urgent action to end the strife and has said Obama will press the matter with Thein Sein, along with demands to free political prisoners as the Southeast Asian country transitions to democracy after a half-century of military rule.

Thein Sein in his letter said his government was prepared to address contentious issues "ranging from resettlement of displaced populations to granting of citizenship," according to a statement from the spokesperson for UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon that contained excerpts from the letter.

He said he also would look at issues including work permits and permits granting freedom of movement for the Rohingya to ensure they are treated in line with "accepted international norms."

The UN statement called Thein Sein's letter a step "in the right direction."

It was not clear from his letter whether Thein Sein was changing his stance on citizenship for the Rohingya. He has previously cited strict citizenship laws stating that only Rohingya whose families settled in the country before independence from Britain in 1948 were considered citizens.

Meanwhile, Civil society activists in New Delhi have protested against what they said Myanmar's opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi's unwillingness to acknowledge Rohingya Muslims' plight in her homeland.

The protesting groups, including the Association for Protection of Civil Rights and the Democratic Students' Union, on Friday issued a statement, in which they disapproved Suu Kyi's continuous silence and ambivalent attitude towards the violence against "a section of her compatriots known as Rohingyas."

Suu Kyi, who is now on a visit to India, told NDTV in an interview on Thursday that both sides were responsible for the ethnic violence in the Rakhine province and she did not want to take sides because she wanted to promote national reconciliation.

"The political position [on the issue] of Suu Kyi, the daughter of respected General Aung San who stood for democracy, peace and minority rights in Burma, is highly condemnable in all respects," the statement says.

"Its a complete hypocrisy that Aung San Suu Kyi doesn't stand by the victims of the ethnic cleansing in Burma [Myanmar], but wants India to stand by her cause," it adds.

The activists on Friday were agitating outside a leading women's college in the capital of India.

Suu Kyi had discredited the plight of Rohingyas by describing the situation in Myanmar as a mere issue of law and order, they said, adding her fight for democracy would remain incomplete until she spoke against the persecution of such minorities in her own country.

The protesters were detained for a brief period at Greater Kailash Police Station before being freed.

The United Nations has called the Rohingya -- who are widely reviled by the Buddhist majority in Myanmar -- among the most persecuted people on Earth.

Myanmar denies the Rohingya citizenship, even though many of their families have lived in Myanmar for generations.

The UN estimates that 800,000 Rohingya live in Myanmar, where they face heavy-handed restrictions: They need permission to marry, have more than two children and travel outside of their villages.
 
Burma needs to learn that it's fascist racist attitude to minorities is not acceptable in normal society. This deeply illeducated and backward country needs lesson in civilised behaviour.
 
Burma needs to learn that it's fascist racist attitude to minorities is not acceptable in normal society. This deeply illeducated and backward country needs lesson in civilised behaviour.

Their Literacy rate is much Higher than yours and is Their Per capita income .

In anycase once the military dictatorship is over things will be better out there . You Should Applaud Myanmar President for moving in that direction ever after opposition of Arakanese people .
 
Their Literacy rate is much Higher than yours and is Their Per capita income .

In anycase once the military dictatorship is over things will be better out there . You Should Applaud Myanmar President for moving in that direction ever after opposition of Arakanese people .

Literacy rate & per capita is not a big deal.The matter is quantity,global presence & competency.
 
Literacy rate & per capita is not a big deal.The matter is quantity,global presence & competency.

Then why are you guys so behind them in these two socioeconomic indicators . Plus you are the first guy i have seen dismissing these two important Socioeconomic Parameter completely .
 
Their Literacy rate is much Higher than yours and is Their Per capita income .

In anycase once the military dictatorship is over things will be better out there . You Should Applaud Myanmar President for moving in that direction ever after opposition of Arakanese people .


I will applaud them once they give the rohingya and other minorities rights. Burma has been allowed to ethnically cleanse every minority in their country not only Muslim rohingya. They did the same to the Hindus, the keran , the Shan people etc.

Comparing them to Bangladesh is silly. Go to Bangladesh no one is being ethnically cleansed there... You can point out what happened to the buddist village near the burmese border. The incident was universally condemned, not a single person hurt and and it was an extremely isolated incident.

In Burma the rohingyas only lost their citizenship in 1982 I believe ( may be out by a few year). All this talk of migration from BD is stupid. Why would anyone migrate to a country where you can not marry or have children or walk out of your village. Use your head dude, Bangladesh is not a land of milk and honey but no one would leave it to go to Burma. Rohingya have existed in what is now Burma for centuries. Purely from an ethnic perspective that area should have been part of British raj and the subsequently India or Pakistan . It just happened to be within the jurisdiction of British Burma hence went with Burma.

The basic point Burmese don't get is there are minorities in every country. International borders does not equate exactly to where people live. They only have these territory because of the British.

It's a very immature and racist society.
 
Literacy rate & per capita is not a big deal.The matter is quantity,global presence & competency.

They are still a natural gas-rich country which once they liberalize their regime as Thein Sein put it, will be much more important than you guys.
 
I will applaud them once they give the rohingya and other minorities rights. Burma has been allowed to ethnically cleanse every minority in their country not only Muslim rohingya. They did the same to the Hindus, the keran , the Shan people etc.

But my friend, you see this from islamic angle. Why do you always see from the religion angle? Religion is an obsession with you guys so much so that you refuse to see who started it first.

Rohingya unrest has been a problem before Burma became a military regime. It failed and hence when junta rose to power, they started taking harsh measures.

Comparing them to Bangladesh is silly. Go to Bangladesh no one is being ethnically cleansed there... You can point out what happened to the buddist village near the burmese border. The incident was universally condemned, not a single person hurt and and it was an extremely isolated incident.

Were the Muslims attacked in other countries for that incident?


Purely from an ethnic perspective that area should have been part of British raj and the subsequently India or Pakistan . It just happened to be within the jurisdiction of British Burma hence went with Burma.

I don't think so that would have been preferable. It has been a part of Myanmar and if you were to dwell in history about territories, then nothing can stop a WW3.

It's a very immature and racist society.

Then do you condemn the same acts performed by almost entire Muslim world against non-Muslims in their countries?

Would you call them as immature as well?

I don't mean to deviate but I am willing to cite links as evidence if you like.

If you can have the courage to accept that without calling it a "western/Hindu/Zionist" propaganda, I am willing to consider it as a legitimate discussion on this.
 
They should stop their massacre immediately and recognize their rights and don't let extreme Buddhist target them again, let them live in peace.
 
They are still a natural gas-rich country which once they liberalize their regime as Thein Sein put it, will be much more important than you guys.

Myanmar has more worth as a regional transit for all big players in the region.
 
They are still a natural gas-rich country which once they liberalize their regime as Thein Sein put it, will be much more important than you guys.

It remains to be seen just how much natural gas there is.

Anyway BD has a much larger economy and it now has the fastest growing economy in the whole of South Asia(bar the tiny countries) and the IMF expects it to stay that way for the next 5 years.

A lot of people forget that BD was handicapped for 25 years development-wise due to the Pakistan period.

From being behind both Pakistan and India in important social indicators like life expectancy and child malnutrition in 1972 it is now ahead, and so this shows the progress than an independent Bangladesh has been able to make.

Expect around 7% a year GDP growth form BD this decade, and with population growth falling from 1.3% to around 1% by the end of this decade, this will result in a huge hike in per-capita incomes.
 
Burma needs to learn that it's fascist racist attitude to minorities is not acceptable in normal society. This deeply illeducated and backward country needs lesson in civilised behaviour.


Not sure how Bangladesh can speak in regards to minority rights when temples were attacked in your country not to mention how Hindus and other minorities been persecuted
 
Not sure how Bangladesh can speak in regards to minority rights when temples were attacked in your country not to mention how Hindus and other minorities been persecuted

This is too funny coming from an Indian:woot:

How many people died in the temple attacks as opposed to the thousands that were slaughtered by Hindu extremists in 2002 in Gujarat?
 
This is too funny coming from an Indian:woot:

How many people died in the temple attacks as opposed to the thousands that were slaughtered by Hindu extremists in 2002 in Gujarat?


Both Hindus and Muslims died in the riots of Gujarat but you can google minority rights in Bangladesh if you have doubt its like the pot calling the kettle black.

http://www.hrcbm.org/
 
Both Hindus and Muslims died in the riots of Gujarat but you can google minority rights in Bangladesh if you have doubt its like the pot calling the kettle black

How many Muslims died as opposed to Hindus?

The ratio was massively tilted towards Muslims.

Anyway, ample proof exists that the Hindu-dominated police looked the other way and even helped the Hindu mob to carry out the killings.

BD is by far the most tolerant South Asian country and that is a fact.
 
Back
Top Bottom