Muslim Indians Should Demand A Seperate Nation:--

[Hiptullha]

TOI is a source?

Pak will be failed state by 2015: CIA - Times of India
Pakistan: A failed State - TOI Blogs
Pakistan — A failed state - TOI Blogs

Are these gospels of truth to you?

Those are blogs, foolish Bharati.
If you don't know what a blog is, the website will tell you.

DISCLAIMER : Views expressed above are the author's own.

i.e. they don't represent the views of the site i.e. no one gives a damn if another Bharati decides to write a piece on why Pakistan is a failed state and why India will own White slaves by 2030.

 

[Sky lord]

why doesn't Pakistan simply ask the Indian Muslims to migrate to Pakistan- after all, wasn't this the raison d' etre for Pakistan in the first place?

What makes you think they would go to Pakistan? Here is the opinion of one Shia muslim in India

As an educated Muslim, I think Pakistan was created on the basis of an inherently flawed Two nation theory, which was utterly disproven in 1971. Religion is never strong enough to mold a monolithic political landscape, if that was the case, the entire Middle East would be a single country. The tragic illusion of a pure Islamic state is like chasing a mirage for Sub Continent Muslims. Hamas is chasing the similar mirage right now. Creation of Pakistan served the ego of bureaucratic elites like Mohammad Ali Jinnah and created hundreds of millions of orphans.We are harvesting the fruit of one of the greatest blunders in human history.

How do Muslims in India view Pakistan? - Quora

 

[Politico]

india 2 be sliced 2 8 pieces by 2020. 1 piece 4 hindu brahmin. 1 piece 4 dalit. 1 piece 4 christian and sikh and rest include kashmir 4 indian muslim. then peace in region. mughal ruler 2 kind 2 hindu when had chance 2 cut india 2 pieces

 

[Sky lord]

india 2 be sliced 2 8 pieces by 2020. 1 piece 4 hindu brahmin. 1 piece 4 dalit. 1 piece 4 christian and sikh and rest include kashmir 4 indian muslim. then peace in region. mughal ruler 2 kind 2 hindu when had chance 2 cut india 2 pieces

What are you? A Modern Bread factory? Slice after slice! You have been slicing for a long time, all you sliced off was your own legs.

 

[Mythal]

What are you? A Modern Bread factory? Slice after slice! You have been slicing for a long time, all you sliced off was your own legs.

they just keep shifting the dates. As the famous saying goes, tomorrow never comes.

 

[Muslim Subcontinent]

Ok so its real when are the Muslim states of AWADH & HYDERABAD are appearing on the map. Hyderabadi's really deserve it.

And believe me Hindus will be allowed to leave or live in peace as they wish in the new states

 

[Rajesh12379]

Typical impotent obsession with India couple with self loathing.

We have nothing to do with Pakistanis. Mind your own business and the terror and extremism engulfing the Islamic world.

Partition was a one time event and we got rid of the undesirable elements. Now we have nothing to do with them at all.

Their obsession with us only shows their "na ghar ka, na ghat ka" condition. Those who converted them despise them as "second class Muslims" (one just has to look at their condition in Arab countries and comments by Iranians etc.) and they forever need to prove themselves.

There will not be any more partition of India. Most Indian Muslims have contempt for Pakistan and they will not give a damn to them. Pakistanis' fake concern for them is too transparent.

A people who are busy killing each other, showing concern for others who have nothing to do with them and have nothing but contempt for them is only funny.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

What makes you think they would go to Pakistan? Here is the opinion of one Shia muslim in India

As an educated Muslim, I think Pakistan was created on the basis of an inherently flawed Two nation theory, which was utterly disproven in 1971. Religion is never strong enough to mold a monolithic political landscape, if that was the case, the entire Middle East would be a single country. The tragic illusion of a pure Islamic state is like chasing a mirage for Sub Continent Muslims. Hamas is chasing the similar mirage right now. Creation of Pakistan served the ego of bureaucratic elites like Mohammad Ali Jinnah and created hundreds of millions of orphans.We are harvesting the fruit of one of the greatest blunders in human history.

How do Muslims in India view Pakistan? - Quora

The above is true to some extent. The creation of Pakistan is justified on the basis that the people of modern day Pakistan are mainly of a different racial and cultural background to indian people. That is why 1971 occurred. The Middle East was 1 nation under the Ottoman Empire for at least 500 years. indian Muslims are racially, culturally, genetically and socially different to Pakistanis. Apart from religion, they are identical to hindus. They are indian completely. indian Muslims have absolutely nothing to do with Pakistanis and vice versa.

 

[Rajesh12379]

There have been millions of identity crisis stuck haters in a particular place, wallowing in impotent hate all their lives and going to jahannum seeing their wish for breaking India unfulfilled.

This thread is an example of the same.

Rather than making themselves useful, the OP obsesses with an impotent hatred. Well, may be it is not all his fault. The Madressa probably prepared such people for only this destinty.

PS: Impotent hatred will not rid anyone of their sins. Only Shariah punishment (chopping of limbs, death by stoning etc, depending on the crime) is the solution. Doing reverse hijarat to doesn't mean the sinners go away scot free.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Typical impotent obsession with India couple with self loathing.

We have nothing to do with Pakistanis. Mind your own business and the terror and extremism engulfing the Islamic world.

Partition was a one time event and we got rid of the undesirable elements. Now we have nothing to do with them at all.

Their obsession with us only shows their "na ghar ka, na ghat ka" condition. Those who converted them despise them as "second class Muslims" (one just has to look at their condition in Arab countries and comments by Iranians etc.) and they forever need to prove themselves.

There will not be any more partition of India. Most Indian Muslims have contempt for Pakistan and they will not give a damn to them. Pakistanis' fake concern for them is too transparent.

A people who are busy killing each other, showing concern for others who have nothing to do with them and have nothing but contempt for them is only funny.

Pakistanis are not indians who converted to Islam. If that were true than modern day Pakistanis would resemble indians. They clearly don't. Pakistanis are physically, racially, genetically, culturally and religiously completely different to indians. The only similarity is that we share a common border. Arabs and others do not have a monopoly on Islam. If anything, Pakistan, Indonesia and Turkey carry the mantle of Islam now. Here in London, Pakistanis, Arabs, Turks and Persians/ Iranians are intermarrying in ever increasing numbers.

Agreed, indian Muslims are completely identical to hindus except for religion. indian Muslims are not really part of the international Muslim mainstream. Yes, indian Muslims resent Pakistanis.

You are also right that Pakistanis and indians have got absolutely nothing to do with eachother.

 

[Muslim Subcontinent]

Ok lets just say wo kya he na kay Musalmaan cant sit with peace in boundaries because we know that injustice anywhere in the world is threat to justice everywhere in the world. And dont you say ke Muslims in India dont like the experiment of Pakistan (State for Muslims) .Even if the Muslims in India dont want to become Pakistan they do can Re-carve the Prehistorically existent states of AWADH & HYDERABAD on whatever terms they want .

BACH NA SAKAY GA HINDUSTAAN
BATT KE RAHAY GA HINDUSTAAN

Iqbal hi ko pirh se parh le na to phir tarap jaag jaye Musalmaano me

 

[Rajesh12379]

Pakistanis are not indians who converted to Islam. If that were true than modern day Pakistanis would resemble indians. They clearly don't. Pakistanis are physically, racially, genetically, culturally and religiously completely different to indians. The only similarity is that we share a common border. Arabs and others do not have a monopoly on Islam. If anything, Pakistan, Indonesia and Turkey carry the mantle of Islam now. Here in London, Pakistanis, Arabs, Turks and Persians/ Iranians are intermarrying in ever increasing numbers.

Agreed, indian Muslims are completely identical to hindus except for religion. indian Muslims are not really part of the international Muslim mainstream. Yes, indian Muslims resent Pakistanis.

You are also right that Pakistanis and indians have got absolutely nothing to do with eachother.

You need to read the two nation theory, the basis of partition.

Frankly, one shouldn't need to create the post facto justification every single day.

Also, the highlighted part is only true for a small minority population of Pakistan. Again, "resembling" doesn't mean we have anything to do with each other.

A bit interesting this "international Muslim mainstream" thing. What is it supposed to be? Who are its members and how ?

 

[[Bregs]]

Muslims were given option to migrate on both eastern and western side of India, now those who did not migrate have missed the golden chance. rest there is no scope left now do even discuss this absurd idea in India even in fantasy

 

[Skillrex]

WoW.. 21 pages of pure BULLSHIT..

Retarded pakis dont have anything to do other than day dreaming and killing children in the name of faith and religion.. and talking about breaking indian into dozens of seperate countries?? look into your own countriy mess first.. than talk about others.

if you pakis really think ISI will fuel internal movements.. indian intelligence will be sleeping ?? you fuel 1 movement.. we will give support to 10 movements. got my point !!

I have so many muslims colleagues/ friends in my life.. and not one of them ever told me we want separate nation just because beef has been banned. hell we even watched India vs pakistan world cup together and boozed till midnight..

and lastly quality of this forum is going down to gutter everyday.. !! good job..

 

[Rajesh12379]

Muslims were given option to migrate on both eastern and western side of India, now those who did not migrate have missed the golden chance. rest there is no scope left now do even discuss this absurd idea in India even in fantasy

This fantasy is only alive in people in some neighboring countries.

People who are to afraid to face the bleak reality.