Mumbai Attacks

[arihant]

Did i say pakistanis where not involved in the attack.
Are you trying to tell me that the mumbai attackers had no help from indian citizens?Looking into it it seems the indian govt was involved with one of it officers being arrested for providing sims to the terrorist....how did he meet them?....if a middle man was involved why has he not been arrested.

Who says Mumbai Attackers had no help from indian citizen. They did have otherwise nothing could have been achieved.

By reading the article, it reveals that to get plan details of Laskhar, Indian Intelligence use to provide sim cards. Same SIM card was use by Lashkar in the Mumbai Attack.

So it means that, guy provided sim to lashkar people, they gave it to Abu Ismail and everything got revealed. So basically it proved that Lashkar was behind the attacks.

 

[dabong1]

Who says Mumbai Attackers had no help from indian citizen. They did have otherwise nothing could have been achieved.

By reading the article, it reveals that to get plan details of Laskhar, Indian Intelligence use to provide sim cards. Same SIM card was use by Lashkar in the Mumbai Attack.

So it means that, guy provided sim to lashkar people, they gave it to Abu Ismail and everything got revealed. So basically it proved that Lashkar was behind the attacks.

So why didnt they stop the attack?

 

[dabong1]

wrong post edited

 

[arihant]

So why didnt they stop the attack?

You are joking, am I right. Same thing applies to 9/11 and all earlier attacks. It's not easy to carry out anything without local helps. Same happened with 9/11 Plot. Matter is that you openly support that Lashker spread terrorism (you call it freedom fighter) and same carried out attack in Mumbai.

 

[dabong1]

You are joking, am I right.

please stop with the

Same thing applies to 9/11 and all earlier attacks. It's not easy to carry out anything without local helps. Same happened with 9/11 Plot.

what local help did they get?

Matter is that you openly support that Lashker spread terrorism (you call it freedom fighter) and same carried out attack in Mumbai.

I will support the freedom fighters in kashmir until a fair solution is reached.....the only time there not freedom fighters is if they target civilians like the mumbai attackers then there terrorist.
The only way this is going to stop is if there is a deal on kashmir.

 

[EjazR]

Do we or do we not agree that the people involved in the mumbai attacks should have there heads chopped off?

Although a large section would say yes. I hope not straightaway. The only reason being, Kasab is the pawn. He should be used to ID his handlers. If Pakistani govt. has agreed to crack down on the suspects, Kasab can confirm if that is indeed the case as a witness.

But eventually yes, even according to Islamic law, any one causing fitna and fasad should get capital punishment.


And adding to riju's post, the same channel also showed a documentary on Gujarat riots in collaboration with Tehelka. They always do hard hitting journalism

 

[IceCold]

Blah Blah...so you believe whatever the British will say....it originated from your soil and you are squarely to blame.

Will somebody shut this troll up.

 

[SurvivoR]

Who says Mumbai Attackers had no help from indian citizen. They did have otherwise nothing could have been achieved.

By reading the article, it reveals that to get plan details of Laskhar, Indian Intelligence use to provide sim cards. Same SIM card was use by Lashkar in the Mumbai Attack.

So it means that, guy provided sim to lashkar people, they gave it to Abu Ismail and everything got revealed. So basically it proved that Lashkar was behind the attacks.

So basicaly Indian Intellegence had links with Lashkar operatives right!

 

[dabong1]

So basicaly Indian Intellegence had links with Lashkar operatives right!

As far as i can gather from news reports indian intellegence gave the mumbai attackers phone sims and that one of the reasons thats probably why we got hear all the conversations between the attackers.
The point of interest is if Indian Intellegence gave the sims to the attackers then why not stop the attack.....if indian intellegence operative used a middeman why has he not been arrested.

 

[waraich66]

India gives Pakistan new Mumbai attack evidence Buzz Up Share
Twitter Delicious Myspace Digg Stumble Upon Facebook Sun, Aug 2 08:48 AM
India gave Pakistan on Saturday a new dossier of evidence to investigate the Mumbai attacks and prosecute Hafiz Saeed, the suspected mastermind of the three-day carnage that killed 166 people.

A Foreign Ministry statement said the evidence was handed over after Pakistan gave India an update on its investigation into last November's attacks and sought more information last month.

Saeed heads the Jamaat-ud-Dawa (JuD) charity, which the United Nations said in December was a front for the Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT), an outlawed militant group accused of carrying out the assault on India's financial capital.

The dossier is a 7-page document which answers questions raised by Islamabad on the earlier evidence provided by New Delhi, Home Minister Palaniappan Chidambaram told reporters.

"Pakistan is asking for answers to questions which are already there. Nevertheless, I have taken the trouble of dictating the (new) response," he said. Chidambaram said India had already given enough evidence to Pakistan to arrest and prosecute Saeed, who was put under house arrest in December but was released in June by a Pakistani court that said there was no evidence against him.

He is one of 38 people, including Pakistani nationals, accused by India of being key planners of the guns-and-grenades attacks by 10 gunmen India says were Pakistanis.

The raid led to renewed tension between the nuclear-armed rivals as India "paused" a sluggish peace process and demanded Islamabad "dismantle the infrastructure of terrorism".

"The evidence provided in three (earlier) dossiers to Pakistan in our view is sufficient to investigate the role of Hafiz Saeed," Chidambaram said.

Saeed founded the LeT militant group in 1990, and for years it battled Indian forces in the disputed Kashmir region, the flashpoint for more than 60 years of rivalry between India and Pakistan. Both claim it in full but rule in part.

India says the assault on Mumbai was carried out by Pakistan-based LeT militants who must have had backing from some official Pakistani agencies.

Pakistan denies official involvement but has acknowledged the coordinated attacks on Mumbai were launched and partly planned from Pakistan's soil, and that the sole surviving attacker was Pakistani.

Pakistan has lodged police complaints against eight suspects, including Mohammad Ajmal Kasab, the only militant caught alive by Indian forces during the attack. Saeed was not among the eight.

(Additional reporting by Krittivas Mukherjee)

 

[IceCold]

I wonder why is India giving evidence in stages or when Pakistan asks of them inorder to make a case against Saeed.
By the way why have you made an angry face with the title thread fundamentalist?

 

[waraich66]

I wonder why is India giving evidence in stages or when Pakistan asks of them inorder to make a case against Saeed.
By the way why have you made an angry face with the title thread fundamentalist?

India is trying to cover its involvement in balouchistan ,this evidence is in response to our dossier handed over to India.

 

[arihant]

India is trying to cover its involvement in balouchistan ,this evidence is in response to our dossier handed over to India.

which dossier you mean

 

[haawk]

I wonder why is India giving evidence in stages or when Pakistan asks of them inorder to make a case against Saeed.
By the way why have you made an angry face with the title thread fundamentalist?

the evidence is not given in stages!!!!!!your officials just cannot read carefully the evidence provided......and they ask some questions regularly like fill in the blanks type!!!!!


Seven-page response with annexures

Handed over to Pakistan’s Deputy High Commissioner

NEW DELHI: India’s response to the latest set of questions sent by Pakistan in connection with their investigations into the 26/11 terror attack in Mumbai has been handed over to the Pakistan High Commission here.

Union Home Minister P. Chidambaram said on Saturday that a seven-page response with annexures was given to the External Affairs Ministry for transmission to the Pakistani government.

Responding to queries by journalists, he said the set of questions given by Pakistan were routine and procedural — in the nature of “fill-in-the-blank” type of queries — and asked for information that had already been given to them.

“If only they [Pakistan] would have read our Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.PC) thoroughly, such questions would not have been asked,” he said.

An official release by the Ministry of External Affairs said the response was given to Pakistan’s Deputy High Commissioner Rifat Masood by Joint Secretary in the External Affairs Ministry T.C.A. Raghavan.

Mr. Masood was called to the Ministry and handed over the response, which was finalised in keeping with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s assurance given to his Pakistani counterpart Yusuf Raza Gilani at Sharm-el-Sheikh in Egypt last month.

On July 11, Pakistan gave India a dossier providing an update on the investigations in Pakistan into the Mumbai terror attacks, containing a request for further evidence.

Mr. Chidambaram said there was “sufficient evidence” to continue the investigation against Hafiz Saeed, Jamaat-ud-Dawa chief.

On Saeed, the Lashkar-e-Taiba founder whom India has described as the prime accused in the attacks, Mr. Chidambaram said New Delhi has provided “enough evidence” in three dossiers to Islamabad to continue the probe and launch prosecution against him.

 

[IceCold]

India is trying to cover its involvement in balouchistan ,this evidence is in response to our dossier handed over to India.

Well India already refused they got any dossier from Pakistan and so have the US and you know the worse part is, there is a complete silence maintained by GOP who otherwise should have had come forward with the evidence infront of the media and the latter stage should have been the UN.