Melbourne most liveable city; Karachi and Dhaka among the least, reveals survey

[Panther 57]

Pakistani actress itself admit repeatedly that 'India is a big film industry, we cant compare to indian film industry,
Wrong question' ! -Few sensible artists in pakistan drama/film industry.Hope she may willing to settle Mumbai who knows !

@Imran Khan @Clutch @Panther 57 @tps77 @graphican @Spring Onion @Farah Sohail

If Pakistan film industry thinks that it is bigger then Indian, they are living in fools paradise. Indian film industry is very well established with multilingual productions, since long. Besides Indian film industry has been taking some very bold plots. I have seen some very interesting topics like in unfreedom, parched and toilet.

 

[Mr.Nair]

Many threads which proclaims Mumbai GDP is ahead of Pakistan??? All over internet, which is an internet hoax actually.

Also speaking of growth rate about the above chart...hope you know the difference between growth rate which shows close to 8% for Indian cities and actual growth achieved so far, the maturity achieved by say Tokyo, LA or London.

Tolyo city GDP at 2.00 trillion USD is almost close to 2.45 trillion USD for India, the whole country with 1.35 billion population. So mature economies tend to have lower growth rates.

For past many years look at japan gdp growth rate its near 1% and there is no improvement in near future.Tokyo is the major city(only 1 city) compared to many cities in India.It like saying london is the biggest city and so UK is the biggest economy in world, when london is the only major city of UK, unlike many cities in US,China,India etc...

If Pakistan film industry thinks that it is bigger then Indian, they are living in fools paradise. Indian film industry is very well established with multilingual productions, since long. Besides Indian film industry has been taking some very bold plots. I have seen some very interesting topics like in unfreedom, parched and toilet.

Now Indian films are crossing 300 million dollar mark

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_highest-grossing_Indian_films

 

[N.Siddiqui]

For past many years look at japan gdp growth rate its near 1% and there is no improvement in near future.

Japan GDP at 4.939 trillion USD (2016) is still twice that of India, and Japan population is 120 million and India's population at 1350 million...talking about nominal real GDP. India per capita GDP ranks 131 in the world. Also most of HDI indices of India is below 140 in the world ranking, slightly better than Congo, Zambia and Somalia.

Nothing to boast about. More money in few hands and vast majority of people finding it hard to meet both ends meet is not a good sign, India ranks second in the worst distribution of income in the world.

Also India is a class, caste and creed based society, where division of resources are acute and worst. Pakistan is much better of in distribution of wealth, not many billionaires and lesser multi dimensional poverty.

 

[Mr.Nair]

Aamir khan fans in China

Japan GDP at 4.939 trillion USD (2016) is still twice that of India, and Japan population is 120 million and India's population at 1350 million...talking about nominal real GDP. India per capita GDP ranks 131 in the world. Also most of HDI indices of India is below 140 in the world ranking, slightly better than Congo, Zambia and Somalia.

Nothing to boast about. More money in few hands and vast majority of people finding it hard to meet both ends meet is not a good sign, India ranks second in the worst distribution of income in the world.

Also India is a class, caste and creed based society, where division of resources are acute and worst. Pakistan is much better of in distribution of wealth, not many billionaires and lesser multi dimensional poverty.

India is almost 1.25 billion people and even the streets in europe can find very poor people and many also can find in US.So that does not mean that they should not proud about,since there are poor in their own streets !
As of large population nothing can change overnight and every parameters in india improving.Now India is the 6th biggest economy from 10th biggest, from just few years back and also 3rd biggest gdp ppp, more than twice than of Japan, standing almost staggering 9.45 trillion dollar.

Pakistan have neither improved much life for very common people nor high class in pakistan(They will go treatment abroad and many does not want to come back).There is lack of education,good hospitals,multi national industry...you name it.So there is no hope for any category of people in pakistan

By the way you didn't mention which way karachi or lahore can be proud to tell in the world?

Just assume India open border and both become one country again, then Indian land now will be flooded with pakistani's, since more opportunity and land resources in every angle...

 

[N.Siddiqui]

There is lack of education,good hospitals,multi national industry...you name it.So there is no hope for any category of people in pakistan

Your rudimentary knowledge about Pakistan and the lack of knowledge about Pakistan society has to be blamed.

A few Pakistanis going to India doesn't mean millions of people who goes to Pakistani hospitals has't got the facilities. Many NRP's from US visits Pakistani hospitals for medical and dental treatment, that doesn't mean US hasn't got the facilities.

Pakistan has good hospitals, good universities(7 universities in QS top 300 ranking in Asia), MNC industry including FMCG is big in Pakistan, like Nestle and Unilever per capita sales of consumer goods in Pakistan is twice that of India...Google search about it. Many big Pakistani consumer goods company as well like Engro, National foods, EBM, many dozen more...self sufficient in all the consumer and food stuff.

 

[Mr.Nair]

Your rudimentary knowledge about Pakistan and the lack of knowledge about Pakistan society has to be blamed.

A few Pakistanis going to India doesn't mean millions of people who goes to Pakistani hospitals has't got the facilities. Many NRP's from US visits Pakistani hospitals for medical and dental treatment, that doesn't mean US hasn't got the facilities.

Pakistan has good hospitals, good universities(7 universities in QS top 300 ranking in Asia), MNC industry including FMCG is big in Pakistan, like Nestle and Unilever per capita sales of consumer goods in Pakistan is twice that of India...Google search about it. Many big Pakistani consumer goods company as well like Engro, National foods, EBM, many dozen more...self sufficient in all the consumer and food stuff.

Nestle or Unilever are not pakistani companies,there sales volume more because there is no competition in the market and pakistani companies are unable to cope with their brand image.In fact there is no TATA,Birla,Adani,infosys,wipro,reliance,mahindra....you name it.Honestly speaking i never heard above pakistani companies,not my mistake but they are not that popular to outside world

 

[N.Siddiqui]

By the way you didn't mention which way karachi or lahore can be proud to tell in the world?

Many foreigners who has visited Pakistan and India both has the following observation...

-In Pakistan poverty is less visible, in India it is more visible with much high multi dimensional poverty.

-People in Pakistan tend to live in vast/big homes with gardens and open areas unlike Mumbai and other cities. Mumbai has all apartment and no houses.

- Roads and motorways in Pakistan are better and this is the reason for high number of SUV's and large land cruisers type of vehicles.

Many other observation by the foreigners...and Indians alike. Check this article by a foreigner...

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-witness-pakistan-motorway-idUSTRE5BF01220091216

Nestle or Unilever are not pakistani companies,there sales volume more because there is no competition

Check this article....

https://tribune.com.pk/story/483287...rowth-of-the-billion-dollar-club-in-pakistan/

TATA,Birla,Adani,infosys,wipro,reliance,mahindra....you name it.Honestly speaking i never heard above pakistani companies,not my mistake but they are not that popular to outside world

Also check this thread about Made in Pakistan products or Industrial growth, started by me...in the developing stage.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/made...following-products-are-all-local-made.510937/

 

[Mr.Nair]

Many foreigners who has visited Pakistan and India both has the following observation...

-In Pakistan poverty is less visible, in India it is more visible with much high multi dimensional poverty.

-People in Pakistan tend to live in vast/big homes with gardens and open areas unlike Mumbai and other cities. Mumbai has all apartment and no houses.

- Roads and motorways in Pakistan are better and this is the reason for high number of SUV's and large land cruisers type of vehicles.

Many other observation by the foreigners...and Indians alike. Check this article by a foreigner...

https://www.reuters.com/article/us-witness-pakistan-motorway-idUSTRE5BF01220091216

That's a myth, if you check many videos in the roads of pakistan and india, can find much better brand of cars,trucks,bikes etc on roads in india since almost all brands are available locally.

India is target to construct almost 27 Kms(Now almost 17Kms) of highways in every single day and what about pakistan?

Every part of Indian land is occupied unlike pakistan where most of people are in punjab,north and sindh and balochistan is more like no mans land and dry.

Look at this list and think where India stand vs pakistan? Yes India is big but even in proportion of agricultural commodities pakistan is no match.How many products India No.1,No.2,No.3.India is almost self sufficient unlike pakistan where many things have to be imported like Tea,Rubber,coffee etc....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_producing_countries_of_agricultural_commodities

Look at the comparison of number of dams india vs pakistan,comment not by me, but by your own expert in your own media

 

[N.Siddiqui]

Look at this list and think where India stand vs pakistan? Yes India is big but even in proportion of agricultural commodities pakistan is no match.How many products India No.1,No.2,No.3.India is almost self sufficient unlike pakistan where many things have to be imported like Tea,Rubber,coffee etc....

Check this link, wheat production in Pakistan was 25 million tons in 2016, in India it was 98 million tons. About 4 times that of Pakistan for a population which is 6.5 times that of Pakistan. Check similar figure for Rice, Milk, other staple food.



https://pabausa.org/1013/pakistans-wheat-production-in-2015-16-estimated-at-25-5-million-tons/

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...98-mt-this-crop-year/articleshow/58359151.cms

 

[Mr.Nair]

According to him india is having 5000 and pakistan 2.I don't know how far your expert telling is true or not considering number of major dams in pakistan

 

[N.Siddiqui]

Check milk production in the world, Pakistan ranks 3rd and a per capita which is twice that of India wrt to population.

 

[Mr.Nair]

Check this link, wheat production in Pakistan was 25 million tons in 2016, in India it was 98 million tons. About 4 times that of Pakistan for a population which is 6.5 times that of Pakistan. Check similar figure for Rice, Milk, other staple food.



https://pabausa.org/1013/pakistans-wheat-production-in-2015-16-estimated-at-25-5-million-tons/

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...98-mt-this-crop-year/articleshow/58359151.cms

Wheat is not a major food consumption in india, as many in south consume 90% Rice.Moreover india export lot of rice product to middle east.You came with few products, what about a ton of other product !

 

[wiseone2]

Check this link, wheat production in Pakistan was 25 million tons in 2016, in India it was 98 million tons. About 4 times that of Pakistan for a population which is 6.5 times that of Pakistan. Check similar figure for Rice, Milk, other staple food.



https://pabausa.org/1013/pakistans-wheat-production-in-2015-16-estimated-at-25-5-million-tons/

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com...98-mt-this-crop-year/articleshow/58359151.cms

Most Indians eat rice
India produces 155 million metric tons. Pakistan's numbers are around 10 million metric tons.

 

[N.Siddiqui]

According to him india is having 5000 and pakistan 2.I

don't believe such foolish reports..it puts you in a similar position.

Cotton production in India and Pakistan, check wrt to land size and population...

 

[Mr.Nair]

You come up with few item which pakistan have presence and then come up with per capita production figures,funny ! When Indian also producing Tea,rubber,lemon,ginger and many spices, what pakistan people are doing according to per-capita !

You also have to think that more than 20% land area in india are covered by forest and stay away for cultivation when there is hardly any forest in pakistan !