Mahmud Ghaznawi: Loved by Afghans and Pakistanis but hated by Indians

[Shabaz Sharif]

Its always funny when Baniyas ignore South Asian non-muslim empires who always raped and killed to control other region Infact look at what they did to Buddhists of India, and now Hindus have reinvented the history saying that they were thrown-killed out from India because they lost debates with hindus

 

[Roybot]

There are more Pashtun in Pakistan than in Afghanistan and they consider one another the same nation of tribes with the same history. So no problem with Pakistan celebrating him.

And the fact that it was the Punjabis and Sindhis and Rajputs who were at the receiving end doesn't change anything?

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

Well Maurya Empire was from around the area I am from, so no, I don't hate Maurya Empire I do hate invaders who came from foreign lands though, be it Central Asians, Pashtuns or Persians. If not hate, then Indian atleast don't revere them.

Mahmud of Ghazni invaded Hindustan, which according to him was the land east of Indus. Ironically 75% of Pakistani population lives east of Indus

haha

Your area which is whole India? lol South Asian empires always killed, raped each other and you guys are proud of them Just because they happen to be non-muslim thats make everything ok.

 

[t_for_talli]

Some regard him as a hero some not, Majority of pakistanis do. many in india also accept him as their hero, muslims mainly.

I dont see the point ......... he looted wealth of your ancestors, killed many of them ........still he is your hero

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

According to many Hindutvas Afghanistan is a part of historical Bharat though.

Exactly lol If only these people didnt convert to Islam then likes of Mahmud Ghaznawi and others would have known as great Indian heroes just like Maurya and dozen others

 

[Roybot]

haha

Your area which is whole India? lol South Asian empires always killed, raped each other and you guys are proud of them Just because they happen to be non-muslim thats make everything ok.

There was always infighting, but at the end of the day they were similar people, of common heritage and origin.

Pashtuns and Pakistani Punjabis are not similar people though

Mahmud of Ghazni(An Afghan Pashtun) routed Pakistani Punjabi King Jaypala Janjua, and here we have Pakistanis many of whom are probably Janjuas themselves making Mahmud of Ghazni their hero.

 

[karan.1970]

Yes its been a long time !

Of the above - It doesn't matter where he hailed from...what matters is who were his People - The Pashtuns !

And why ? Because the concept of Nation States is a very recent concept !

He & others like him are Pashtun Heroes - They belong to the Pashtun People not a piece of Land !

We've got more than twice the Pashtuns than the rest of the world combined which means we've got as much a stake in claiming them as ours as anyone else !

So then how would you treat some Pakistanis claiming the heritage of IVC ?

 

[mankov]

Its always funny when Baniyas ignore South Asian non-muslim empires who always raped and killed to control other region Infact look at what they did to Buddhists of India, and now Hindus have reinvented the history saying that they were thrown-killed out from India because they lost debates with hindus

This part I agree on that brahman-buddhist civil wars weakened the hindus and opened them to invasions by Islamic forces.But even Islamic forces massacred huge number of buddhists too.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

He was Muslim. Period.

I dont see the point ......... he looted wealth of your ancestors, killed many of them ........still he is your hero

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

There was always infighting, but at the end of the day they were similar people, of common heritage and origin.

Pashtuns and Pakistani Punjabis are not similar people though

Mahmud of Ghazni(An Afghan Pashtun) routed Pakistani Punjabi King Jaypala Janjua, and here we have Pakistanis many of whom are probably Janjuas themselves making Mahmud of Ghazni their hero.

How can Punjabi be of similar heritage to maratha or tamil? Your lies has been exposed, as long as some one is hindu it makes everything ok. If hindu rapes his daughter then it makes perfectly ok according to you, that explain everything

There is more similarity between punjabi & pathan because of living near each other then anyone in India.

 

[&%)@$)(!#]

haha

Your area which is whole India? lol South Asian empires always killed, raped each other and you guys are proud of them Just because they happen to be non-muslim thats make everything ok.

Chamar convert, where did you get brainwashed like this ??My ancestors didn't kill and rape civilian since they didn't adhere anything from far western deserts. We fought wars in battlefields and never raided civilians.Even during wars we had rules, like we fought only from sun rise to sun set , there was no fight in night and like that there were many rules unlike your heroes.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Its always funny when Baniyas ignore South Asian non-muslim empires who always raped and killed to control other region Infact look at what they did to Buddhists of India, and now Hindus have reinvented the history saying that they were thrown-killed out from India because they lost debates with hindus

Source?
"Hindus have reinvented the history saying that they were thrown-killed out from India because they lost debates with hindus" - Both the 'beautiful actions of the Islamic emperors' and the 'actions of Adi Shankaracharya' are recorded. Besides just look at the ridiculous comparison - "Islamic emperors" and the stateless monk Shankaracharya

Sir @shan - you are caught lying

 

[PlanetWarrior]

In 30 years time, the Pakistani military will name their most recent missile the "Indira Gandhi". Then they will boast that since Indira wrecked havoc on their nation and made them run helter skelter, their missile is deadly and dangerous

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Chamar convert, where did you get brainwashed like this ??My ancestors didn't kill and rape civilian since they didn't adhere anything from far western deserts. We fought wars in battlefields and never raided civilians.Even during wars we had rules, like we fought only from sun rise to sun set , there was no fight in night and like that there were many rules unlike your heroes.

Edit this.
Casteist ideas like this broke the back of our country. Come out of it. It is high time now.

 

[Shabaz Sharif]

Chamar convert, where did you get brainwashed like this ??My ancestors didn't kill and rape civilian since they didn't adhere anything from far western deserts. We fought wars in battlefields and never raided civilians.Even during wars we had rules, like we fought only from sun rise to sun set , there was no fight in night and like that there were many rules unlike your heroes.

lol Only sikhs are chammar convert Another wannabe aryan

Keep worshipping those who raped & killed your ancestors.