Kerala School Drops Vande Mataram from I-Day Programme as Radical Group Objects

[Indischer]

If their sentiments are getting hurt at singing the Vande Maataram, they're residing in the wrong country. These ingrates need to be shipped out to the land of their choice, at their own expense, of course.

 

[Cyberian]

This is just ongoing witch hunt against Muslims in India under the premiership of democratically elected Hindu Extremist Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

 

[acetophenol]

This is just ongoing witch hunt against Muslims in India under the premiership of democratically elected Hindu Extremist Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

No,its not. Its just the rant of a group of immature,stupid group of idiots,who must be kicked out of the country.

 

[SrNair]

No,its not. Its just the rant of a group of immature,stupid group of idiots,who must be kicked out of the country.

Bro what about this SDPI people support in Kollam trivandrum area?

Only limited in coastal fishermens area or large scale inland support.

 

[Sardar Singh]

Their next demands are going to be like this :-

1.Introduce sharia system for Muslim students in schools.
2.Stop morning players which is against their faith.
3.Introduce ISIS in their curriculum.
4.Make it compulsory to wear Bedsheets Burqa.

And the list goes on and on .......

 

[nair]

This is what is meant by pseudo-secularism.

Rajiv Gandhi capitulated to the Muslim fundoos to please the Muslim vote bank. Now in India, every religious person with their 'sentiments hurt' can squash books, movies because once you allow a religion leeway you cannot then in principle deny other religions.

If you don't like to sing the song, or it is offensive, don't sing it.

Normal muslim's dont oppose it, There are people with extreme views..... and SDPI is their political wing..... we also have our own Jamaat e Islami, I dont like to generalise them.... But there are morons cant deny that either....

 

[abjktu]

Not good .

No,there were protest from CPM/SFI,i heard....
The same schools uses Muslim prayers during the assembly and hindu-Christian students must sing it..

 

[Multani]

If their sentiments are getting hurt at singing the Vande Maataram, they're residing in the wrong country. These ingrates need to be shipped out to the land of their choice, at their own expense, of course.

Kindly post the translation of "vande mataram"

If it contains sentences that allow for idol worship, then it is a big sin for Muslims to sing it. That is the reason why they might be objecting.

 

[abjktu]

Bro what about this SDPI people support in Kollam trivandrum area?

Only limited in coastal fishermens area or large scale inland support.

They have lot of support, even among normal Muslims...
Karunagapally,kollam town,kottiyam,kallambalam,attingal town,paravoor,varkala,chirayankeezhu,coastal tracts of vizhinjam,puvaar to colachel(kanyakumari dist)...

 

[Multani]

Normal muslim's dont oppose it, There are people with extreme views..... and SDPI is their political wing..... we also have our own Jamaat e Islami, I dont like to generalise them.... But there are morons cant deny that either....

If vande mataram has idol worship in it. then a Muslim cannot sing it, because singing it will be tantamount to committing idol worship considered the biggest sin in Islam

Their next demands are going to be like this :-

1.Introduce sharia system for Muslim students in schools.
2.Stop morning players which is against their faith.
3.Introduce ISIS in their curriculum.
4.Make it compulsory to wear Bedsheets Burqa.

And the list goes on and on .......

Most Kerala Muslims are Sufis. They are against ISIS extremism.

Your phrase "applying sharia system in school" makes no sense. You don't know about Islam.

Burqa is not compulsory in Islam.

 

[SrNair]

Kindly post the translation of "vande mataram"

If it contains sentences that allow for idol worship, then it is a big sin for Muslims to sing it. That is the reason why they might be objecting.

There is no such idol worship lines in that song.
Vandemataram is our national song .Those who cant sing with patriotism should get out from this country.

 

[Multani]

There is no such idol worship lines in that song.
Vandemataram is our national song .Those who cant sing with patriotism should get out from this country.

Tell me, why are the Kerala Muslims [ who make up a quarter of Kerala's population according to the indian government ] objecting to singing it?

 

[abjktu]

Tell me, why are the Kerala Muslims [ who make up a quarter of Kerala's population according to the indian government ] objecting to singing it?

Kerala Muslims are comparatively peaceful community..But the problem is with those returned from gulf with wahhabi mentality...they are desperately trying to inject wahhabism to other peaceful Muslims in Kerala...unfortunately many are falling into their traps...

 

[SrNair]

They have lot of support, even among normal Muslims...
Karunagapally,kollam town,kottiyam,kallambalam,attingal town,paravoor,varkala,chirayankeezhu,coastal tracts of vizhinjam,puvaar to colachel(kanyakumari dist)...

Very good most of illetrate and semi literate is readily supporting them.They are digging their own graves.

Tell me, why are the Kerala Muslims [ who make up a quarter of Kerala's population according to the indian government ] objecting to singing it?

Same issue imported radicalism .They are insulting other secular muslims in Kerala and try to weaken them.

 

[abjktu]

Very good most of illetrate and semi literate is readily supporting them.They are digging their own graves.

yes,All Malayalam news medias seems to ignoring these social issues.. may be fearing backlash..but its not good for long run....