do we have an actual statistics on street crime in Karachi -- albeit I bet a lot of it goes unreported so official stats and unofficial would have huge discrepency
As usual the figures are under-reported so as to show "efficiency" from the most basic level. Moreover, in the case of Punjab "petty crimes" are not registered in the roznamacha (this dates back to early '90s). The police websites carry the crime statistics district wise, however they are down right now.
I have however read detailed police station and zone wise crime statistics and analysis and mapping of crime zones in the cases of all urban areas. I'll post them if I find them in my pile of documents and the digital junk I have.
its normal in any big (crowded) city that sees lots of rural-to-urban migration to have some issues with crime. But I feel its compounded ten-fold in Karachi, where it is abnormally high
It's way too much in Karachi and there are many factors primary amongst them are the existence of slums which lead to increased crime (Lyari, Pathankot and Orangi) and the fact that there's no management there. Political involvement is raised as a big factor, however the police officers down play this and emphasize that most big robberies and kidnapping-for-ransom do not even involve local gangs but gangs operating out of Thatta, Mirpur Khas and Baloch coastal areas. Karachi is their main source of income.
Organized crime and high crime rates in mega-cities are no-brainers. It takes time for cities to overcome them. New York being a prime example of a city that has had to struggle hard to overcome crime. Moreover, Karachi is under-manned when it comes to police. Private Security Guards in Karachi outnumber the entire strength of Sindh Police.
I would have preferred seeing a mega recreational center or high tech library being built instead --and in a more down-trodden area. But any development work or project has my blessing if it brings betterment to the country
Library, buhahahaha. Oxymoronic in out highly anti-intellectual society.
Anyways, why do you wonder there are no waste management plants for the entire of Lahore and Karachi dumps all of its sewerage untreated in the sea (one plant is operational but it constitutes only about 15% of the entire dump)?
Infrastructural projects do not create political capital since the media does not cover them and neither are they as visible. The idea of "development" has been limited to what the assertive class i.e. the upper middle and elite class define and for them it constitutes wider roads, bigger real estate projects (land obtained under eminent domain under the guise of "public interest" when there isn't any public interest in setting up gated communities) and creating more and more country and golf clubs for the elites. As long as the media does not start roaring over the lack of infrastructural investment (and appreciates the ones that are done), there is no real hope.
This is not the first time I would have ranted on this elitist development though. PDF has witnessed many of my rants