Islamic Monuments in India - Whose Legacy?

[Zarvan]

These are the legacy of Muslims who ruled India

 

[Lyrical Mockery]

^ nobody doubts that.

 

[Kalyugi Mirza]

No it's belongs to Islamic values and Islamic culture..You can't bound this to Pakistan only..

 

[SQ8]

No it's belongs to Islamic values and Islamic culture..You can't bound this to Pakistan only..

It belongs to the history of Islam in the sub-continent.. of which Pakistan-India-Bangladesh is part of.

 

[Rusty]

Self Delete

 

[Khan_patriot]

They surely dont belong to Pakistan but they belong to Muslims and the true Muslim and Islamic heritage and no one in this world can take this away from the ''Muslim Ummah'' these monuments not only bear witness to our great heritage but also for people like me serve as a reminder of our soon to be repeated glorious past.........

 

[tony singh]

Taj is a fusion of Hindu, Islamic and persian style thats why no such building exist in Arabia

 

[notsuperstitious]

Its indeed shared legacy, but it belongs not only to the muslims, it belongs to everybody in the sub continent. Its like saying Rashtrapati bhavan belongs to anglo indians

We all paid taxes, not just the anglo indians or the sub continental muslims.

 

[mahar khawar ramzan]

Surely all the things of our Muslim Ancesters belong to us. Pakistan is not just a geographical division of Sub-Continent but it is the representer of muslims of sub-continent. So all things belonging to muslims of sub-continent belong to Pakistan.

 

[NALANDA]

Surely all the things of our Muslim Ancesters belong to us. Pakistan is not just a geographical division of Sub-Continent but it is the representer of muslims of sub-continent. So all things belonging to muslims of sub-continent belong to Pakistan.

Cross check with other PDF members from Pakistan. When it comes to "all the things of our Hindu Ancesters " like Indus Valley civilizations etc, they lay a claim on them as well.



As per me, it is shared culture and belong to the sub-continent.

 

[oFFbEAT]

Its actually Hindu legacy.......as most(if not all) of the architects, labourers were Hindus.

By the way......India(ancient) was full of Hindu architectures..... Most of which were destroyed by Islamic invaders...........

 

[mahar khawar ramzan]

Its actually Hindu legacy.......as most(if not all) of the architects, labourers were Hindus.

By the way......India(ancient) was full of Hindu architectures..... Most of which were destroyed by Islamic invaders...........

can you refer some hindu architects which were the most skilled of sub-continent than muslims or any other.

 

[oFFbEAT]

can you refer some hindu architects which were the most skilled of sub-continent than muslims or any other.

Who built all the Hindu temples??........Muslim architects??

Everything has its root in Hinduism......you can't escape anywhere.........
If you "dig up your roots"......you will be surprised to find that everything you are made to believe from your childhood is a myth......

The History of the most iconic, so called "Islamic" monument in India is shrouded in mistery itself.........

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Origins_and_architecture_of_the_Taj_Mahal
Taj Mahal: Was it a Vedic Temple?

Surely all the things of our Muslim Ancesters belong to us. Pakistan is not just a geographical division of Sub-Continent but it is the representer of muslims of sub-continent. So all things belonging to muslims of sub-continent belong to Pakistan.

According to your logic.....we should claim the legacy of Indus Valley Civilization then!
Pakistanis a.k.a Muslims had no role in it.........

 

[shuntmaster]

If people feel that the Islamic monuments in India belong to Pakistan, then shouldn't the government of Pakistan pay the rent to India for occupying the land in India? I suppose by this the Indian Government can earn some revenue from these monuments.

 

[Charlie1]

I aint proud of the taj mahal....
that fool could have made some world class universities with the fortune that he shoved up his dead wife's tomb...