What's new

Is Pakistan drifting away from China?

Yankee-stani

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Messages
8,100
Reaction score
1
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
The positive vibes generated by Prime Minister Imran Khan’s maiden visit to the United States from July 21 to 23 are still being discussed both in Washington and Islamabad. While Imran hailed Trump’s ‘vision’ for the region in a recent high-powered meeting to review the outcome of his trip to Washington, President Donlad Trump also spoke about his ‘excellent’ interaction with the Pakistani prime minister.

The Trump-Imran apparent bonhomie has given many a reason to believe that both Pakistan and the US can still stitch together a cooperative relationship despite many divergences and mistrust. The issue that brought the two estranged allies once again on one platform is of course the Afghan endgame. The Trump administration, desperate to save some pride after 18 years of failed efforts to bring some semblance of stability in Afghanistan, is looking up to Pakistan for a bailout.

But Imran’s visit was not just about Afghanistan. The two countries are also discussing other areas of cooperation such as trade and business ties. Trump himself spoke about increasing trade to manifolds with Pakistan. There is no official word nor will anyone publicly say it but there are speculations that the Trump administration is ready to offer a ‘lucrative deal’ to Pakistan in return for rethink on China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).

Republican Senator Lindsey Graham, who complemented Saudi efforts in securing the White House invitation for Imran, is lobbying for free trade deal to Pakistan if it helps the US in bringing peace in Afghanistan. Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE), which already extended financial assistance to Pakistan, will pump in further investments in the country. But for that to happen, Pakistan may have to adjust its current foreign policy priorities particularly towards China.

The US opposition to China’s ‘Belt and Road’ initiative (BRI) is well known. Alice Wells, senior State Department official, told a group of journalists in Islamabad in April that the “US welcomes the infrastructure investment by China and by all countries so far it advances the prosperity of the countries involved.” The larger objective behind America’s opposition to BRI is to stop the rise of China as global power.

Of late there has been a debate in Pakistan that whether CPEC is mutually beneficial for the country. Those who take a critical view of CPEC claim that contracts signed with the Chinese companies were not favorable to Pakistan. On top of that the PM’s US visit has set off speculations that Pakistan may rebalance its ties with China. There was no official confirmation of this possible policy shift but it can’t be ruled out given how Pakistan often makes somersaults on the foreign policy front. There were many instances where Pakistan simply went for a short-term gain but lost sight of the bigger picture. We must learn from our history. Our policy of choosing sides in foreign relations has always come back to haunt us. The major flaw in our foreign policy has always been putting all eggs in one basket. When China announced billions of dollars of investment under CPEC few years back, we were boasting our ‘strategic partnership’ to tell the West, particularly the US, that we no more needed your support.


Now that the US has extended a “hand of friendship” to Pakistan, our romance with Washington is suddenly reignited. There is no point in getting blown away by Trump’s “charm offensive”. The government or the ones in charge of Pakistan’s foreign policy should avoid committing the past mistakes.

Reengagement with the US is certainly a positive development but that doesn’t mean Pakistan has to antagonise China. Pakistan can optimally use its geostrategic location to its advantage by maintaining friendly ties with both China and the US while without becoming a party to their power politics. It is certainly a difficult task but not an impossible one.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 5th, 2019.
 
.
How does re establishing or improving relations with US mean "drifting away from China". Pakistan must take decisions in its best interest and the best interest mean we should have good relations with US, China and Russia. I believe we need to create interests for maximum participants.
 
.
The positive vibes generated by Prime Minister Imran Khan’s maiden visit to the United States from July 21 to 23 are still being discussed both in Washington and Islamabad. While Imran hailed Trump’s ‘vision’ for the region in a recent high-powered meeting to review the outcome of his trip to Washington, President Donlad Trump also spoke about his ‘excellent’ interaction with the Pakistani prime minister.

The Trump-Imran apparent bonhomie has given many a reason to believe that both Pakistan and the US can still stitch together a cooperative relationship despite many divergences and mistrust. The issue that brought the two estranged allies once again on one platform is of course the Afghan endgame. The Trump administration, desperate to save some pride after 18 years of failed efforts to bring some semblance of stability in Afghanistan, is looking up to Pakistan for a bailout.

But Imran’s visit was not just about Afghanistan. The two countries are also discussing other areas of cooperation such as trade and business ties. Trump himself spoke about increasing trade to manifolds with Pakistan. There is no official word nor will anyone publicly say it but there are speculations that the Trump administration is ready to offer a ‘lucrative deal’ to Pakistan in return for rethink on China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC).

Republican Senator Lindsey Graham, who complemented Saudi efforts in securing the White House invitation for Imran, is lobbying for free trade deal to Pakistan if it helps the US in bringing peace in Afghanistan. Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates (UAE), which already extended financial assistance to Pakistan, will pump in further investments in the country. But for that to happen, Pakistan may have to adjust its current foreign policy priorities particularly towards China.

The US opposition to China’s ‘Belt and Road’ initiative (BRI) is well known. Alice Wells, senior State Department official, told a group of journalists in Islamabad in April that the “US welcomes the infrastructure investment by China and by all countries so far it advances the prosperity of the countries involved.” The larger objective behind America’s opposition to BRI is to stop the rise of China as global power.

Of late there has been a debate in Pakistan that whether CPEC is mutually beneficial for the country. Those who take a critical view of CPEC claim that contracts signed with the Chinese companies were not favorable to Pakistan. On top of that the PM’s US visit has set off speculations that Pakistan may rebalance its ties with China. There was no official confirmation of this possible policy shift but it can’t be ruled out given how Pakistan often makes somersaults on the foreign policy front. There were many instances where Pakistan simply went for a short-term gain but lost sight of the bigger picture. We must learn from our history. Our policy of choosing sides in foreign relations has always come back to haunt us. The major flaw in our foreign policy has always been putting all eggs in one basket. When China announced billions of dollars of investment under CPEC few years back, we were boasting our ‘strategic partnership’ to tell the West, particularly the US, that we no more needed your support.


Now that the US has extended a “hand of friendship” to Pakistan, our romance with Washington is suddenly reignited. There is no point in getting blown away by Trump’s “charm offensive”. The government or the ones in charge of Pakistan’s foreign policy should avoid committing the past mistakes.

Reengagement with the US is certainly a positive development but that doesn’t mean Pakistan has to antagonise China. Pakistan can optimally use its geostrategic location to its advantage by maintaining friendly ties with both China and the US while without becoming a party to their power politics. It is certainly a difficult task but not an impossible one.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 5th, 2019.





Not at all. The relationship between China and Pakistan is that between 2 iron brothers. Our relationship with America is just cordial and to help improve our economy. That's all, nothing more. Our relationship with America is transactional. It can never be compared to our relationship with China.
 
. .
The US opposition to China’s ‘Belt and Road’ initiative (BRI) is well known. Alice Wells, senior State Department official, told a group of journalists in Islamabad in April that the “US welcomes the infrastructure investment by China and by all countries so far it advances the prosperity of the countries involved.” The larger objective behind America’s opposition to BRI is to stop the rise of China as global power.
The US can't build infrastructure for itself, how can it build it for anyone else?
 
.
Let's wait and see Chinese reaction on recent Indian move on Kashmir and rest of muslim world
 
. .
The Pakistan/US relationship is transactional and will be over the moment this transaction is over. But Pakistan's relationship with Chian is strategic and based on geography, growth and the vision of the future. No matter how big transaction you do with the USA, relationship with China is there and going to stay deep-rooted as ever.

Don't read to much from the media people... they are anyway paid to vomit filth.
 
.
The Pakistan/US relationship is transactional and will be over the moment this transaction is over. But Pakistan's relationship with Chian is strategic and based on geography, growth and the vision of the future. No matter how big transaction you do with the USA, relationship with China is there and going to stay deep-rooted as ever.

Don't read to much from the media people... they are anyway paid to vomit filth.
Even if Pakistan had a strategic partnership with USA, it would still benefit China. We should remember that in 60's Pakistan opened up a door for China and US to interact and establish relation which had been severed since Korean and Vietnam wars so much so that one point US considered using nukes against China. But thanks to Pakistan's good relations with both countries the cold between the two countries thawed and China came out of the isolation and became a permanent member of UNSC as well.

And today, good relation between Pak-US will help China even more since CPEC will help both countries trade even more. And yes China is our long term partners & friend and this friendship will only get stronger with time. And such sold presstitute of the media cannot harm our relation which truly higher than mountains.
 
.
Genocide of Xinjiang region Muslims by the chines govt is the main reason for all that.
 
.
For next 500 years none of Pakistani should think difting away from china.
China and Pakistan is the only 2 countries which is enjoying best friendship.
 
.
For next 500 years none of Pakistani should think difting away from china.
China and Pakistan is the only 2 countries which is enjoying best friendship.

The answer to the title is no. (in the long term)

However, whether its the US or China, its not good for Pakistan to become overly reliant on one or the other.

The true path to independence is lessening the reliance on either China or the US and perhaps collaborating more with other countries such as Turkey.......and....uh.....yea the options are limited.

Ultimately, being a smaller state and dependent on other larger states for key technologies and other factors, Pakistan can't go it alone or collaborate with other Muslims majority countries (i.e. Turkey) because they face the same problems.

But of course the efforts should be made. InshAllah.

However, for now its a case of extracting as much as possible from either US or China while not becoming overly reliant on either of them.

And of course the converse is true as well as the US I'm sure was uncomfortable with the Pakistani lean to China and this speculative weapons sale is a carrot to give the US more leverage with Pakistan going forward.
 
.
Let's wait and see Chinese reaction on recent Indian move on Kashmir and rest of muslim world

Chinese will say the usual about Kashmir and then go back to doing business with India. The same with the Muslim world.
 
. .
How does re establishing or improving relations with US mean "drifting away from China". Pakistan must take decisions in its best interest and the best interest mean we should have good relations with US, China and Russia. I believe we need to create interests for maximum participants.
True Pakistan used to have good relations with China and the US in the past. No reason for it to pick sides right now
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom