Is it really India?

[EjazR]

Also published in the The Hindu under a different title
The Hindu : Opinion / Lead : India & Pakistan: case for common defence

 

[Bhaarat]

Also published in the The Hindu under a different title
The Hindu : Opinion / Lead : India & Pakistan: case for common defence

India and Pakistan will commonly defend against whom? India needs defence from Pakistan and its proxies!

 

[Goodperson]

Everyone knows that India desires Pakistan to remain boiling. Not collapsing, not stable. A Pakistan in some trouble keeps India happy since we are unable to take action against India and neither are the Jihadis going to take over the military assets of Pakistan.

This is the ideal situation for Indians.

The situation is not good in Pakistan but the problem is mostly created by Pakistani themselves the leaders were short sighted.
Its in a way good that Fundamentalist and Taliban are getting eliminated the war also shows how deep rooted connections they have.

Hope Pakistan will come out of this crisis soon.

 

[DavyJones]

I don't think India will get much by supporting Pak Taliban.
About Baloch militants I'm not sure - maybe India is supporting them. The proof is not clear and the level of support is not very high in all likelihood. Anyways Baloch militants are not a very big threat to Pak.
There is sympathy in India for terrorist attacks in Pak. Most fellow Indians are coming around to the feeling that Pakistan's monster of religious warrior is now not under the control of the Pak government. The same thing happened after India nurtured the LTTE in Sri Lanka and Punjabi terrorists - they came back to bite India. India realised that feeding extremist movements backfires and has since then stopped any such activities. I hope Pak learns that extremists and insurgent armies can go rogue easily.

 

[graphican]

Well, its good that you have got that impression. But from India's POV, India desires to carve out many more Bangladesh like states. Keeping the Pakistan on boil is the first step in that direction, remeber East Paksitan was also on boil, but not many in Pakistan actually believed India could do what did in 1971. RAW is very efficient in this way, it covers it tracks well and prepares the enemy for a final blow by the army. Army gives the last punch and Indian influence does the rest. This is the plan for Pakistan from the begining. Lets see, whether it works.

Although your words are hurting me like Venom but I am pleased to meet you. Please be active member here as there are only few Indians that have balls to stand with truth and you are the rare one.

 

[Bhaarat]

Although your words are hurting me like Venom but I am pleased to meet you. Please be active member here as there are only few Indians that have balls to stand with truth and you are the rare one.

Thanx, buddy.

 

[Spring Onion]

raised . While India’s assistance for Baloch insurgents could conceivably make strategic sense, helping the jihadists simply does not.

Mr hoodbhoy is known anti-Pakistan goon.

Now coming to the above sentence of Mr hood wow he sees the terrorists activities of India in Balochistan Province of Pakistan justified and the Indian terrorism in Pakistan makes sense to this paid anti-Pakistan zionist. Then why it doesnt make any sense to him if tomorrow Pakistan starts supporting and funding Naxals or any other organisation for strategic purposes against India.

 

[Spring Onion]

India and Pakistan will commonly defend against whom? India needs defence from Pakistan and its proxies!

Its otherway round specially when your Army chief is waging a nuclear war against Pakistan.

 

[MilesTogo]

take care............

Well, its good that you have got that impression. But from India's POV, India desires to carve out many more Bangladesh like states. Keeping the Pakistan on boil is the first step in that direction, remeber East Paksitan was also on boil, but not many in Pakistan actually believed India could do what did in 1971. RAW is very efficient in this way, it covers it tracks well and prepares the enemy for a final blow by the army. Army gives the last punch and Indian influence does the rest. This is the plan for Pakistan from the begining. Lets see, whether it works.

 

[Bhaarat]

Its otherway round

From your perspective, yes.

specially when your Army chief is waging a nuclear war against Pakistan.

Janaji, he said that limited war was possible. He never talked about nuclear war. Just saying something is possible, does not mean, we will do it. But I pleased that the comment was taken seriously and did what it was intended to do. I am convinced that Indians have refined the art of dealing with Pakistani state by understanding its reactions and fears. Gen. Kapoor was subtle and smooth yet so effective.

 

[Spring Onion]

From your perspective, yes.

Same about yours

Janaji, he said that limited war was possible. He never talked about nuclear war. Just saying something is possible, does not mean, we will do it. But I pleased that the comment was taken seriously and did what it was intended to do. I am convinced that Indians have refined the art of dealing with Pakistani state by understanding its reactions and fears. Gen. Kapoor was subtle and smooth yet so effective.

for scaring India we even dont need to ask our Gen to threaten India.

Some rag tag outfits do it effectivly

 

[Spring Onion]

Well, its good that you have got that impression. But from India's POV, India desires to carve out many more Bangladesh like states. Keeping the Pakistan on boil is the first step in that direction, remeber East Paksitan was also on boil, but not many in Pakistan actually believed India could do what did in 1971. RAW is very efficient in this way, it covers it tracks well and prepares the enemy for a final blow by the army. Army gives the last punch and Indian influence does the rest. This is the plan for Pakistan from the begining. Lets see, whether it works.

Hope you will also be ready for the same within India.


And oh dont forget that there is a big big difference between the location of then East Pakistan and Balochistan.

We did have many disadvantages due to the location and supply line was not at all stable or maintainable due to location of East Pakistan when India started terrorism there.

Anyway i hope Indians wont cry when Pakistan starts supporting insurgencies in North east India

 

[Bhaarat]

Same about yours

for scaring India we even dont need to ask our Gen to threaten India.

Some rag tag outfits do it effectivly

ha ha...Janaji, that time is gone. Most rag tag groups are being fought by your fauj. RAW has compromised both the rag tags and few officers below the brig. rank. There is large scale of discontent among the soldiers because they think they are being forced to fight with their ideological brothers for the sake of US. India hopes that PA will be hassled by internal problems. Once, that happens we win. We are not scared of Pakistan, anymore. I confess, that once it was true, but not today. Today our focus is long-term.

 

[Bhaarat]

Hope you will also be ready for the same within India.

We are taking effective steps to remove that possibility. Of late, we have been successful.

And oh dont forget that there is a big big difference between the location of then East Pakistan and Balochistan.

I agree. But Janaji, also remember that there is greater value for Balochistan than East Pakistan. Balochistan is very resource rich and many countries want a pie in it.

We did have many disadvantages due to the location and supply line was not at all stable or maintainable due to location of East Pakistan when India started terrorism there.

The key was that Bengalis sided with India. That was the clincher. Mukhti Bahni had many ex-army officers who played a critical role in defeating PA. There were large scale desertion in East Pakistan from Army. All this was RAW's success.

The same model is being applied to Pakistan's other regions. Results in Balochistan are showing.

Anyway i hope Indians wont cry when Pakistan starts supporting insurgencies in North east India

Janaji, Pakistan has already done that. Do you think those who formulate the policies will sit idle while India/RAW is doing all this? ISI has done a lot of meddling in North-East India, Punjab, Kashmir..etc. But, of late, India has been successful in defeating insurgencies in these places.

 

[Moorkh]

Janaji, he said that limited war was possible. He never talked about nuclear war. Just saying something is possible, does not mean, we will do it. But I pleased that the comment was taken seriously and did what it was intended to do. I am convinced that Indians have refined the art of dealing with Pakistani state by understanding its reactions and fears. Gen. Kapoor was subtle and smooth yet so effective.

just to support this point

"if i say its possible for me to castrate myself, doesnt mean i will do it"