Madali
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Mar 28, 2015
- Messages
- 2,717
- Reaction score
- 23
- Country
- Location
You are the first Iranian to talk openly about this, first of all thx for that but i have two point that i dont agre with you:
First, you cant tell me the news papers in Iran are free without censorship, thats hard to believe.
And secondly, Iranian political system might be complicated and unique but this doesnt make it democratic at all, in the end its always someone who decides about the candidates be it the Supreme leader or the President, democracy isnt only about the ability to vote but also the be able to candidate for President freely or found parties no matter if the goverment agrees with its goals and much more but lets not go too deep into details.
1) I didn't say newspapers are 100% free to say whatever they said. I myself mentioned that there are certain restrictions (such as insulting the leader, making racist articles, having anti-islam commentary, etc). But I said we are probably free-er in certain things that people don't guess. One example I gave was criticizing the government & politicians (aside from Khameini or Khomeini). This is done a lot. I think in this we are probably (I'm guessing, I haven't done a media by media comparison) free-er than Turkey, in terms of criticizing the President. However, Turkey is probably more free in certain other aspects.
2) Let me use an example. We don't get to elect our doctors or judges or policeman, right? We don't get to personally vote on each law, right? We also don't get to vote on the decisions the leaders make, correct? Does that mean no country is democratic?
Of course not. Our votes don't directly affect every single decision. Our votes affect the big picture. We vote for a system. Iranians vote for 4 major positions,
1) President
2) Assembly of Experts
3) Parliament
4) City Council
Let's look at the fourth to have a better example. We don't get to directly vote for the Mayor of the city. The City Council chooses the Mayor. Is this undemocratic? No, I don't think so, because I and others choose the people that represent the city council who choose the mayor. If I don't like their choice, I will vote for others in the City Council.
It's the same thing in other aspects of the system.