What's new

Influential Cleric Tells Khamenei Iran's 'Current Situation Cannot Continue'

Kastor

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Mar 22, 2017
Messages
905
Reaction score
0
Country
Iran, Islamic Republic Of
Location
United States
Gutsy letter....but he's right.

https://en.radiofarda.com/a/influen...rent-situation-cannot-continue-/30693992.html

One of Iran's most high-ranking and politically prominent clerics has warned the Islamic Republic's Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei that his regime's popularity and legitimacy has been seriously damaged mainly because of injustice as well as economic and cultural problems.

In a letter to Khamenei on Saturday June 27, the 79-year old cleric from Qazvin, Ayatollah Seyyed Mohammad Mousavi Khoeiniha said that "What many people think and say, and their living standards are not consistent with a political system known to the world by its Islamic nature."

Khoeiniha, a former Prosecutor General, and an ex member of the Majles and the Assembly of Experts, is known for masterminding the seizure of the U.S. embassy in Tehran in 1979 and taking over 50 U.S. diplomats hostage for 444 days.

Khoiniha said he is sharing the letter with the nation, hoping that his account of the country's situation would prompt Khamenei to contemplate and do something good for the people.

He said in the letter to Khamenei, which was published by Ensaf News and re-run by many other Iranian websites on Saturday, "Increasing inflation and declining incomes have created backbreaking problems for the people that have led to abnormal behaviors and have given way to many concerns for the people about the future of their children."

"At the same time, many others are also unhappy about the country's political and cultural situation which are marked by undeniable injustice," said Khoeiniha.

Characterizing Khamenei as "the main player" in Iran, Khoeiniha implicitly pointed at Khamenei's responsibility over problems and shortcomings, adding that the current problematic situation are not simply the outcome of decisions made by managers who are transitional.
He stressed that "From the point of view of the people”, the highest authority is the main player in all or most of the country's affairs, adding that the continued that "the current situation cannot continue."

Khoeiniha said elsewhere in his letter that that "the people believe the highest authority in the country's management should have prevented the cultural, economic and social chaos the country is facing today."

Khoeiniha said at the end, "If the current way of running the country's affairs is based on conventional calculations and known views about governance, there are numerous other experts who should be allowed to criticize this method of government and call for reforming it without fearing possible consequences."

Despite the criticism, Khoeiniha wrote that "if decisions made in recent decades are based on a knowledge only certain individuals are bestowed with, then what is happening to the country and its citizens is an inevitable destiny to which I shall succumb and surrender."

The call on Khamenei to allow critics voice their concerns comes while almost everyone who has openly criticized Khamenei, including 14 well known dissidents, ended up in jail in 2019.

On the other hand, Khamenei has shown that criticism does not influence his decisions. Saturday morning, during a teleconference with Judiciary officials in Tehran, he praised former Chief Justice Sadeq Larijani who has been widely criticized for financial corruption charges faced by his former deputy and many have also implicated Larijani in the case.

Regardless of the extremely polite tone of Khoeiniha's letter, it is still not known what kind of reaction awaits him. He is a die-hard left wing cleric and the leader of the left wing Militant Clerics Association and a seasoned politician who used to have a following among Iranian left wing students.

When his newspaper, Salam, which was highly critical of the government, was shut down in 1999, thousands of students took to the streets in protest which led to the biggest clash between the police and students in Iran's history as well as leading to one of the biggest political crises the Islamic Republic has ever faced during the past four decades.
 
I am not familiar with Iran domestic politics, but from a Chinese practice, this letter is a political move.
I don't think it's good for the country.

Maybe Iran political tradition and culture is different, people like to debate publicly over sensitive affairs. Chinese don't.

In Chinese point of view, the MASS don't and won't understand the complexity of foreign affairs, thus can NOT understand the national interest. MASS are short sighted, individual interest driven.
 
I am not familiar with Iran domestic politics, but from a Chinese practice, this letter is a political move.
I don't think it's good for the country.

Maybe Iran political tradition and culture is different, people like to debate publicly over sensitive affairs. Chinese don't.

In Chinese point of view, the MASS don't and won't understand the complexity of foreign affairs, thus can NOT understand the national interest. MASS are short sighted, individual interest driven.

China is a one party system with its on domestic problems. Xi had to do a massive purge within the party to lower corruption and scandals. The Hong Kong issue has rapidly expanded out of their own control. Their sovereignty over Hong Kong is decreasing by the day and become more and more a symbolic sovereignty.

Iran is a republic with many factions contributing to the stability of the Republic.
In the day and age of social media keeping government criticism from spreading is near impossible.

Iranian Republic needs to unify and purge the many different factions into a more homogeneous structure.
 
I am not familiar with Iran domestic politics, but from a Chinese practice, this letter is a political move.
I don't think it's good for the country.

Maybe Iran political tradition and culture is different, people like to debate publicly over sensitive affairs. Chinese don't.

In Chinese point of view, the MASS don't and won't understand the complexity of foreign affairs, thus can NOT understand the national interest. MASS are short sighted, individual interest driven.
In Iran every body has a say. And this so called influential cleric is no more than a reformist politician who thinks that West is the whole World and we will die without West.

Radiofarda is the most anti Iran Source, this @Kastor is showing his true colors.
 
China is a one party system with its on domestic problems. Xi had to do a massive purge within the party to lower corruption and scandals. The Hong Kong issue has rapidly expanded out of their own control. Their sovereignty over Hong Kong is decreasing by the day and become more and more a symbolic sovereignty.

Iran is a republic with many factions contributing to the stability of the Republic.
In the day and age of social media keeping government criticism from spreading is near impossible.

Iranian Republic needs to unify and purge the many different factions into a more homogeneous structure.
Agree with you to some extent.
But your view on China is quite typical American views. Sigh, always with color glass, close to the truth, but just close to.

In Iran every body has a say. And this so called influential cleric is no more than a reformist politician who thinks that West is the whole World and we will die without West.

Radiofarda is the most anti Iran Source, this @Kastor is showing his true colors.
Iran is great country, hope you guys all well.

When China is under attack, poor economy, lag behind on technology. The last thing we lack are traitors. Traitors everywhere, especially overseas.

Just be patient, and keep strong mind. You guys are doing well under harsh international environment.

It's better to be enemy of west than slavery. Slaves have no independent soul.
 
Last edited:
In Iran every body has a say. And this so called influential cleric is no more than a reformist politician who thinks that West is the whole World and we will die without West.

Radiofarda is the most anti Iran Source, this @Kastor is showing his true colors.


Radiofarda is a MEK extremely zionist source.
 

This guy was in Iranian parliament at the time of Kuwait war. He said Iran should support the Muslim country (Saddam) against US. He wanted Iran to join Saddam and fight US for Islam!!!!
Thank god he lost his battle. He has no wisdom.

Maa se nafar too in forum daarim ke mikhaan be nazar iraani byaan vali zabunemuno balad nistan. Jaalebe.
.....
 
Last edited:
In Iran every body has a say. And this so called influential cleric is no more than a reformist politician who thinks that West is the whole World and we will die without West.

Radiofarda is the most anti Iran Source, this @Kastor is showing his true colors.
What a joke.....everyone has their say, and no one goes to jail for that. As far as my true colors...I'm objective, not brainwashed...or on the take. Regardless of the source, the letter was published in few papers in Iran already, so it's not fake news.

PS: I noticed it's always the same 3 to 4 guys who want to shut down any debate....why? Ask yourself who benefits from not having any debate on any issues regarding our country.
 
This guy was in Iranian parliament at the time of Kuwait war. He said Iran should support the Muslim country (Saddam) against US. He wanted Iran to join Saddam and fight US for Islam!!!!
Thank god he lost his battle. He has no wisdom.
.....
i didnt knew that. what a retard, he should be banned from entering politics.
 
Bro, I've never heard of that guy till today. I'm just posting an article that shows a rare voice calling for a shift of strategy....it can be wrong, or it can be right...lets let the people make up their own mind.
 
Bro, I've never heard of that guy till today. I'm just posting an article that shows a rare voice calling for a shift of strategy....it can be wrong, or it can be right...lets let the people make up their own mind.

I am all for freedom of speech. That is what makes a country advance.

Yet, as someone interested in Iran, I expected you to know Farsi.
......
 
Back
Top Bottom