What's new

Indian CAS tol visit BD and take salute during BMA passing out parade

This guy wants to sell his book! He advertises in each and every thread. Dude even I'm an author of a National Bestseller. But I don't brag about it. :coffee:

And Bdw, :lol:

No not every thread and the book is actually very relevant here. I don't need to try to sell the book it sells itself now.

So what book did you write?
 
.
Six pages over Indian COAS visit to Bangladesh where he will attend the BMA passing out parade in which he will be saluted by the new cadets. Many serving army officers are extremely unhappy about this subservient gesture in light of Pilkhana and the continuous killing of our citizens on the border. Many in BD do not think the Indians COAS should be accorded such an honour.

To understand what all this is actually about you would have to read either my book or those by Abu Rushd or Zainal Abedin. The Indians may call it propaganda and conspiracy theories but there is a lot of incontrovertible evidence in these books.

Mate, after googling the subject of this thread, you are the only person to discuss this so deeply :lol:

The official story about the Pilkhana tragedy was that it was internal. Some people say that some influential smugglers discredited that BDR, especially after the Chittagong arms haul.

By the way, if I am not mistaken, the Chittagong arms haul was found after an Indian tip-off. Is there any reason for India to mastermind the tragedy in the context of India's security interests in Bangladesh? It seems unlikely.

Who cares what some new cadets think? We should honor the high ranking officer coming from an important country. It would insulting not to do so, and potentially dangerous. There are many longstanding issues between India and Bangladesh. Lets not compromise that on our part.

Now I have no doubt, the people who masterminded the Pilkhana tragedy are still out there. They could be in Bangladesh and elsewhere in the world. These men need to be hunted down.

As far as the Indo-Bangladesh border goes, we must equip the newly formed BGB better. If BSF troops do illegally enter Bangladeshi territory, they have every right to shoot. Same applies to smugglers.

'Dr Imtiaz Ahmed, Professor of International Relations, University of Dhaka also emphasises on the threat of 'very influential smugglers' operating on the Indian borders. He says, “BGB has to earn the trust of the nation through their efficiency especially in the border zone.” He says the black market on the borders with India is at least 3.5 billion dollars and the BGB has to compete and launch operations against them. “This is not my own figure, even Indian economists will agree,” he says.'

' “Without the knowledge of the Indian Border Security Force (BSF), it is impossible to smuggle in the goods. India has erected a fence for stopping the flow of human beings but not smuggled goods. Many people have been killed on the borders by BSF. But Indian authorities have done little to disrupt smuggling. This shows that they are only interested in stopping the entrance of human beings, but not smuggled goods. So these are some of the challenges that the BGB faces, and through their efficiency in tackling these problems, is BGB going to win the trust of the general populace.” '

' “The BGB has overbearing duties,” he says. “The smugglers are influential in both countries and they are armed.” He says that compared to the BSF and the smugglers, BGB has only rifles, while others have machine guns and other sophisticated equipment. “The smugglers have influence on every level of the administration and the government. Their reach within this country is very wide and they have influential 'friends'. So understandably BGB has a very difficult job when dealing with such challenges.” '

' “Also the BSF has border outposts in 3-4 km of their terrtory, while BGB has their outposts in 6-7km,” says Dr Ahmed. “India is a much stronger power. But while India prides herself for her democracy, the illicit activities on the borders and the killings of civilians on the Bangladesh-India border have gone unreported in their media and Indians are not aware of the activities going on.” He emphasises that against such overwhelming odds, it is going to be a very rough ride for the BGB. “It is not only the responsibility of the BGB, but the nation as a whole that such activities are stopped and the BGB is lent support from the general populace.” '

::: Star Weekend Magazine :::

The solution is simple enough, we need to equip the BGB more. I mean everything, automatic firearms, night vision, helicopters, sensor equipment, vehicles, etc. This should be reflected in the recent defense budget.

They must do their part for security, and no compromise to smugglers. And certainly no space to foreign armed groups.

India would have nothing to 13itch about in the end.
 
. .
1. RNA Chief is an Hony Gen of IA and an alumni of IMA. The entire RNA officer corps are alumni of IMA. Therefore, RNA Chief's officiating at IMA passing out and VK Singh officiating at BMA are not the same thing.

2. BD has raised an army, and provided the mily with a US$ 2 Blln budget this time. BD people want to have the best that it can afford. In all studies of threat perception India emerges as the only potential threat to BD. Myanmar has become a recent problem, and that too localized and temporary.

3. In SA India is unpopular, but nowhere as much as in BD. India, because of her attitude and because of her activities, is lathed in BD. AL govt, by inviting VK Singh, adds another point to its dwindling unpopularity.
 
.
Mate, after googling the subject of this thread, you are the only person to discuss this so deeply :lol

People are too scared to discuss this in BD but I am getting a lot of private responses.

The official story about the Pilkhana tragedy was that it was internal. Some people say that some influential smugglers discredited that BDR, especially after the Chittagong arms haul.

You must have already seen this -

DeshCalling: THE PEELKHANA MUTINY AND MASSACRE

I originally got it via email and some of the points raised in the article still remains unanswered but indicates an Indian hand.

Who cares what some new cadets think? We should honor the high ranking officer coming from an important country. It would insulting not to do so, and potentially dangerous. There are many longstanding issues between India and Bangladesh. Lets not compromise that on our part.

Not only the new cadets but most of the officer class are opposed. You would have to read mine, Abu Rushd's or Zainal Abedin's book on the subject to understand. Read any of those first and then comment on this. It is simply not about saluting the Indian COAS. There is much more at stake then this or I would not have spent so much time on it. There is no point stating the obvious but a great deal of kudos in revealing the unobvious.
 
.
Not only the new cadets but most of the officer class are opposed. You would have to read mine, Abu Rushd's or Zainal Abedin's book on the subject to understand. Read any of those first and then comment on this. It is simply not about saluting the Indian COAS. There is much more at stake then this or I would not have spent so much time on it. There is no point stating the obvious but a great deal of kudos in revealing the unobvious.

Since you are a part of most dreaded DGFI, therefore, it is assmed that you know many internal information. But, is it correct that the Cadets are not willing to salute the Indian CAS? Have they already rebelled? If not, you can initiate one because you are so close to them. What are you waiting for? It may the best opportunity to become a leader.
 
.
This thread is a typical case of making a mountain out of a mole hill! Jeeez! :undecided:
 
.
Our all training exercises are based against India and to a lesser extend towards Burma. Now at the very outset if we see the face of Indian General, I donnot know what would happen !!!! Is the govt is trying to show the new imputs that look India is our best friend. My foot !!!! We donnot want to show this gesture.

its the great bharati method of nipping the buds .. just imagine on the very first day of their carrier poor BD cadets are forced to salute the arch evil bad Indian Gen. it will have moral shattering experience which the poor chap will never be able to overcome . well done India and ofcourse AL and Hasina :coffee:
 
.
one serious OT Question ... what steps have Bangladesh establishment have taken regarding increasing sea level around Bangladesh .....since some reports claim one-thirds of Bangladesh is set to disappear under water by 2025......im raising this question because iv never seen any discussion's on this topic in this forum ...
 
.
one serious OT Question ... what steps have Bangladesh establishment have taken regarding increasing sea level around Bangladesh .....since some reports claim one-thirds of Bangladesh is set to disappear under water by 2025......im raising this question because iv never seen any discussion's on this topic in this forum ...

This is a defense forum, not a forum for global warming.

.....since some reports claim one-thirds of Bangladesh is set to disappear under water by 2025.....

Who told you this?
 
. .
People are too scared to discuss this in BD but I am getting a lot of private responses.



You must have already seen this -

DeshCalling: THE PEELKHANA MUTINY AND MASSACRE

I originally got it via email and some of the points raised in the article still remains unanswered but indicates an Indian hand.



Not only the new cadets but most of the officer class are opposed. You would have to read mine, Abu Rushd's or Zainal Abedin's book on the subject to understand. Read any of those first and then comment on this. It is simply not about saluting the Indian COAS. There is much more at stake then this or I would not have spent so much time on it. There is no point stating the obvious but a great deal of kudos in revealing the unobvious.

Okay, I didn't know Joy could be that ruthless.

But lets face it, the habits of the army toward the BDR. They did often discriminated the BDR soldiers. Don't you think that is what partly contributed to the Pilkhana tragedy?

I don't know, the foreign conspiracy thingy appears to be a kinda far-fetched theory. The Hasina government does not have very good relations with the USA at the moment.

As far as the masterminds of Pilkhana go, we just have to wait and see. I hope they are doing something other than nothing!

That's funny, the link you provided is not working anymore :confused:

......................

?????????????
 
.
The next thread will be Indian COAS ate more fishes that due in canteen.
In BD section, I sometime feel like I am listening to conversation of rickshaw puller or bored wives.
 
.
I have just read the "Amader Shomoy" news about Indian CAS getting Salute from BD Cadets in Bhatiary of Chittagong. The newspaper quoted a govt source as saying that this RARE honour will be given to the Indian CAS in recognition of his contribution in the 1971 war.

Why people shoiuld keep on shouting on such a trifling matter? Last time, it was general Moeen who received six horses from Indian CAS, and then some lowly guys still here cry that India has thus bribed Gen. Moeen to take away the independence of BD.

These guys are so talented that like 'Sai Baba' they can initiate news from nothing. Indian govt should award these silly guys for propagating anything Indian. I just wonder what would happen to our DGFI if shallow-minded guys like these are really the salaried ADVISERS to that dreaded organization. God bless Bangladesh!
 
.
The next thread will be Indian COAS ate more fishes that due in canteen.
In BD section, I sometime feel like I am listening to conversation of rickshaw puller or bored wives.

Hmmm, if that is the case as it seems to you then the Indians
would certainly be the additional wives of that puller, they certainly bitches
alot then first bored one.

Never mind, just continue your verbal gibberish....
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom