Lala Lajpat rais were not lunatic fringe. People like him were the MAIN supporters (financial and intellectual) of Congress from Muslimi Majority provinces.
See! the problem with Bharati analysts is that they have not forking idea of Muslim majority provinces (MMPs). They never had it and never tried even today.
Bharati analysts instead look at the Hindu Majority provinces or HMPs (mainly from Central subcontinent) to draw their intellectual moorings for analyzing Muslims.
But the problem is that in doing so they are looking at minority Muslims who are ethnically and historically very very very different from Muslims residing in MMPs.
Thus the biggest cruelty to our region's history is to mix MMPs and HMPs in one bag and ignore the reality of 1920s
Back then Hindus in MMPs were 1000 times more vocal for partition compared to Muslims in HMPs.
Read Hindu published tribune from Lahore back then,
Also read Lajpat rai letters.
you will know.
Obviously it will be difficult for you to find all that but keep at it and you will find the truth.
You are the one who is alleging that Lala Lajpat Rai wanted two separate countries. And all the best with using ZH terminology like Bharti analysts. The MMPs were thoroughly studied in history both by Indian and neutral historians. And the overwhelming conclusion is that partition did not find any support from these provinces until much later.
If you are alleging that Lala Lajpat Rai wanted to partition India, you better show evidence. If you don't show any and then cry hoarse that Bharti analysts then there is no point. After all who dug out those Lajpat Rai letters and Tribune? It must be some Indian historian. Lala Lajpat Rai had links with Arya Samaj and Hindu Mahasabha, but where does it ever indicate that he wanted partition?
You are as rabid hater for
nationalists as you accuse them to be. You forgot that it's the Muslims who have problems with everyone, most Hindus have no problem with most Muslims . they are the one who wanted a separate country, you cannot blame others for having suspicions about intentions of Muslims . not everyone thinks like you , lets count how many Muslims have killed Hindus and vice versa since last 1000 yrs. Whenever they are in majority minority rights goes to gutters , don't need to look to a distant place. Do you know where independent India's largest exodus happened , in Kashmir , where your dear Muslims threatened non violent pandits to leave. Cite me another example where Hindus threw the Muslims away from their majority areas.
Talk about such things in ndtv website and jnu campus . here it won't cut.
You want to know what is the percentage of Muslims that voted muslim league and how many went. The difference is the traitors who are left here. Ask
@SarthakGanguly about the exodus in Kashmir , he is a sufferer.
Be careful speaking for all nationalists. We are only talking about a particular fringe of stupid nationalists. Most Indians are nationalist, even those who are internationalist. So you 'nationalists' better keep your patriotism in your pants or wherever it belongs.
I do not hate anyone. But I have very low tolerance for stupidity. Extremists(of all religions) have problems with everyone. And this dumb score keeping of killings in 2015 is a shining example of such stupidity.
And I appreciate the jab you took with the references of ndtv website and jnu campus. Here let me return the favor(though I did not get offended by it
):
1. Sure like you talk about the BS you just pasted above in Sanghi websites?
2. I think it is time for your 50ps per post duty as online Bhakt trolling comments section on ndtv.
3.
I think you are needed somewhere more urgently. To pack hound some poor liberal on his blog.
4. Hey hey, why are you wasting time here with me? You could have tweeted a dozen anti-muslim tweets in the time.
5. A quote from you in year 2075: These bloody muslims!! We still have to kill two more of them to balance the score of last 1000 years.
This is India. There is no trivializing anyone's sufferings. But please understand this country has a lot of suffering. An eye for eye, especially when the eye is that of someone a generation later, makes the whole world blind.
And if you are trying to tell me muslims are genetically tuned to seek Hindu blood, then p!ss off. If you are saying there are many muslims who want to erase other religions, I agree and will point out that there are enough people who want to kick all muslims, even the peaceful ones, wholesale out of India.
