Look bhai
Both Pakistanis and Bharatis are pagan worshipers of their version of WRONG history.
Anytime someone provides a counter-narrative, the reaction is the same as yours.
Speak for yourself. Indian history is largely free from fiddling. You can see this when most neutral historians and even some Pakistani historians agree with the Indian textbook account.
OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG, OMG,
League never asked by chopping off MMPs.
They wanted special status of MMPs within the federation.
Lol. Yeah a federation where they would have right to secede. Even if they do not secede they will have practically all the army and then hold the most fertile lands of India along with the biggest cities except Bombay and Madras. May be Jinnah also thought like you that Congress people are idiots. He is so blind to his own logic of division and now you too, that you want to segregate Indian states but don't want to touch any state internally. Why? Because that is convenient for you.
And then what answer do you have for this question? Why should the MMPs get special status in a federation?
Heck just read the mission plan clauses that were agreed by Jinnah. Who thwarted Jinnah and Mission plan?
Congress.
Cabinet Mission plan was a stupid idea for the reasons I outlined above. I am surprised that Congress even gave it that much merit. Why the hell should any religion get parity at Central level? You should read into Jinnah's actual demands. They were watered down by the time they came into the British plans. What Jinnah asked was for parity at each state level among other ridiculous proposals. You tell me now. Will Pakistanis today agree for parity for non-muslims in Pakistan?
And Congress was successful in kicking out MMPs by chopping kaaatu Peetu politics
why
Why? Because Quaid's logic of division was applied to MMPs. It is only fair when you are saying divide India on the basis that Hindus and Muslims cannot live together, then how can they live together in a province? So Congress was not practicing kaatu peetu. They were cutting down India's losses and rescued as many people as possible.
Congress was the most powerful entity among the three I mentioned.
So please sit down, sip some cold water, and you will come to grips with the reality.
peace
The reality is that Jinnah got Pakistan more than what any negotiator in his position can squeeze out of the situation. So you sip some cold water without crying over what you thought you lost in the MMPs. You already got more than what you(Muslim League) deserve.
What the heck is the street value. It did not work in MMPs.
No I did not say street value. I said ML had value as spoilsport. It did work in MMPs.
The only time in 50 years League tried to use direction action that showed up ONLY in muslim minority city of Calcutta.
why? It was the handy work of local gangs who used that opportunity to score hits on their opponents.
Please read into history. The Bengal government was in ML's hands. Muslims League, while being in power organized a hartal and direct action day. Show me another government which makes such a stupid move. A hartal by defnition in subcontinent means an opportunity to score hits. The fact is that any violence is an advantage for Muslim League. Because status quo was in Congress' favor. They can simply sit tight. Only the Muslims Leaguers were afraid of the scenario where the British leave India without settling the Hindu-Muslim question, either by partition or the ridiculous parity plans.
While Gandhi the clown mourned so called killings in Calcutta, 10s of 1000s of Biharis were raped and killed.
And people asked Gandhi
why the heck are you sitting in Calcutta while so many people are being hacked to death in Bihar
And guess what did he say
You know?
(lets see if you know your history)
I don't know what Gandhi said. But the same incident is projected by right wingers in India as proof that Gandhi cared more for muslims. So I guess you have your own theory on what happened. Let it out.
Had League any street power, then direction action day would have shown up in MMP areas and cities like Lahore, Karachi Peshawar.
Again I never claimed League had street power. So a strawman argument. Anyways as I mentioned, violence was in ML's advantage. You don't need to be in majority to stoke violence.
But it never did. So League failed miserably and the real winner were the Hindu mobs who went on killing spree in W Bengal and Bihar.
Hope you learn something now.
Thank you.
Hope you learn the other half that you left out without learning. W.Bengal and Bihar were not the only places where violence hit. It was there in Rawalpindi, in other places in Punjab and even where you seem to automatically assume that in all places Muslims were the victims, it was not the case. You can see the Bengal CM claiming that most people killed in the riot were muslims. This was similar to what the Hindu right wingers in India use as a call for war today. So please you learn the parts you missed and come back. We will discuss further.
I would like to hear from you on the merits of Cabinet Mission plan since you seem to think it was a golden plan. So what was so nice about it? What was in it for Congress and what was in it for the League?
