India is just like Pakistan, say reality show contestants (from Pakistan)

[Jackdaws]

Leave the world or Islam or anything. Do these alphabets were used in Indian society before muslims advent in India?

Answer it please.

Yes - once again. Since the language was used, obviously the alphabet was used too.

 

[PakiiZeeshan]

is MQM the party of Muhajirs??

Yes. MQM is party of Muahjirs...and they love you

 

[DGMO]

So you are probably a Muhajir, because it's only muhajirs who have a loyalty to india.

Loyalty to India? Is that how desperate you're getting?

Struggling to accept what I'm saying, and then using an imaginative ethnic link to find an answer to your own question? Really is scraping the bottom of the barrel.

So sad.

 

[Desert Fox]

no thx not all of us have this inferiority complex well i don't want to be from arab,persian or turk either.I consider myself from pakistan only

hate to bring it to ya but

Area: 307,374 sq mi (796,096 sq km). Population: (2009 est.) 174,579,000. Capital: Islamabad. The population is a complex mix of indigenous peoples who have been affected by successive waves of migrations of Aryans, Persians, Greeks, Pashtuns, Mughals, and Arabs. Languages: Urdu (national), English, Punjabi, Pashto, Sindhi, Balochi. Religions: Islam (official; predominantly Sunni)

Pakistan -- Britannica Online Encyclopedia

 

[MilesTogo]

 

[SpArK]

Out of the hundreds of generation a family has gone through , only the present generation and maybe the previous generation to some extend has only lived in the new land.

 

[Desert Fox]

Yes - once again. Since the language was used, obviously the alphabet was used too.

so your saying that Arabic Alphabet originated from india?

@Pakistani members
Didn't i tell you guys that indians will start claiming English and Arabic as their own

 

[JanjaWeed]

Yes. MQM is party of Muahjirs...and they love you

hey..thanks for the info mate. on the lighter note.. do you hate them?? 'cause they love us??

 

[Kinetic]

again, no one is talking about religion here, many Pakistani members have already emphasized this already!

Many members claim that 'we have different religions'.

Tell me what similarities we have in regards to culture, as far as i have observed i have nothing in common with the common indian and neither do most of Pakistanis i know (besides Punjabis)

You first brought the word 'culture' into the discussion, so its your duty to say what dissimilarities we have. Many of adjacent countries have similarities between them in terms of culture but that doesn't make them one. I am very much aware of Sindhi and Punjabi cultures, I found no difference.

like i said before Pakistan isn't only comprised of Punjabis so get that out of your head!

I proved you wrong so you get angered!!! India is not compromised with Punjabi and Gujarati as well. There are different kind of people live in every country. But you failed to understand what I said.

https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/fields/2075.html

this site says that Pashtuns are 15% of Pakistanis while Baluch are only 3% but you claimed that Pashtuns were 30-35%!!!! BTW my source is wiki.

all of the non Punjabi minority groups put together make up 55.32% of Pakistan's population!

Punjabi and Sindhi together make nearly 77% of Pakistan's population.

good for you, i'm not the one here trying to prove that we are the same as indians!

than for what are you talking? The culture and people same doesn't mean countries are same so as India with BD, SL, Maldives, Sri lanka, Nepal and Tibet.

 

[PakiiZeeshan]

Loyalty to India? Is that how desperate you're getting?

Struggling to accept what I'm saying, and then using an imaginative ethnic link to find an answer to your own question? Really is scraping the bottom of the barrel.

So sad.

I accept that muhajirs in Karachi are like Indians.

 

[Areesh]

Hi, you have stated clearly that you are also a muhajir, that means technically before 60+ years back the ancestors were also pretty much part of the much hated bharat. correct me if i am wrong.

http://www.defence.pk/forums/1141783-post129.html

Obviously my ancestors migrated from Bharat but that was 6 decades ago. The day we crossed the border, the day we left India we were no more Indians. We had a new identity which we consider as different from Indians. The Pakistani identity which we choose ourselves. Nobody kicked us out of India it was our decision to leave India and to give up our identity with India. Now we have an identity which is called as Pakistani and that identity we all Pakistanis believe is different from Bharat.

Hope you got my point.

 

[Areesh]

Yes. MQM is party of Muahjirs...and they love you

Come on yaar, my ancestors migrated from Bharat. Did you see any loyalty to Bharat in my posts. Mohajir thing has died here in Karachi even the party like MQM has given up using Mohajir political card now.

Come on don't make mockery out of yourself.

 

[PakiiZeeshan]

Many members claim that 'we have different religions'.












You first brought the word 'culture' into the discussion, so its your duty to say what dissimilarities we have. Many of adjacent countries have similarities between them in terms of culture but that doesn't make them one. I am very much aware of Sindhi and Punjabi cultures, I found no difference.



I proved you wrong so you get angered!!! India is not compromised with Punjabi and Gujarati as well. There are different kind of people live in every country. But you failed to understand what I said.



this site says that Pashtuns are 15% of Pakistanis while Baluch are only 3% but you claimed that Pashtuns were 30-35%!!!! BTW my source is wiki.





Punjabi and Sindhi together make nearly 77% of Pakistan's population.




than for what are you talking? The culture and people same doesn't mean countries are same so as India with BD, SL, Maldives, Sri lanka, Nepal and Tibet.

I don't understand why you are trying soo hard to prove us to be the same as you?

Punjabis are like 3% of the indian population and sindhis are proabably not even 1% of your population

even if we're ethnically the same as you, most young Pakistani don't consider themselves to be the same as Indians, because we only know Pakistan.

And who cares about History? Why is history going to help us today? history is history.

why are forcing your opinion onto us? dude, seriously, it's not like i'm going to consider my self the same as non-Punjabis of India. i'm never going to see the non-Punjabis of India as my own people.

so why are you wasting your time arguing?

 

[MilesTogo]

 

[MilesTogo]