What's new

India alone has the potential to defeat China in a war, argues Subramanian Swamy | ThinkEdu 2022

Status
Not open for further replies.
Actually, he's right.

I am emphatically opposed to everything that this man stands for, but he had this utterly unpleasant habit of being right most of the time.
He will also be on the first flight out of India whenever such a conflict breaks out. As we say here “Tu chal, mein aya” type
 
Except Chinese won't attack us as long as they have USAF and USN close to home
have you noticed how fat shah and others in power have stopped threatening to take GB, AJK, Shaksgam and aksaichin since Galwan smackdown?

to prove your assertion you should convince them - the bharati ministers-- to resume their rhetoric and bluster.

उन में क्षमता है किआ?

 
Last edited:
What makes you think it need be a battle through the high Himalayas?

China will easily obtain air superiority by making use of its estimated 150 100 J-20s to spearhead it's force of nearly 1000 4/5 gen fighters.

Then Indian SAM sites will be taken out one by one and Indian armour picked off at leisure.

Finally China can land mobile airborne forces behind the Indian defending border forces and attack them from the front and rear.

India would get a bitchslap never before seen in history!
Correct. Also that is the current inventory, China has increased the defense budget by 7.2% this year and ramped up production of the J-20, with some sources estimating China could have almost 500 J-20s in a few years. The Ukraine war, like every major war sees the Chinese do a through analysis followed by a major build up to catch up technological where possible.

Russia hasn’t prosecuted this war with full force to try to pacify the civilian population. That won’t be an issue for the Chinese.

A Sino-Indian war would be a real show of their expanding heliborne air assault forces, being build up for the Taiwan contingency. Hundreds of attack helicopters and hundreds of transport helicopters.
 
have you noticed how fat shah and other in power have stopped threatening to take GB, AJK, Shaksgam and aksaichin since Galwan smackdown?

to prove your assertion you should convince them - the bharati ministers-- to resume their rhetoric and bluster.

उन में क्षमता है किआ?

Its not surprising you are gullible enough to fall victim to regular political rhetoric from Indian politicians. That is the purpose of such rhetoric afterall.

People with an actual plan never gloat it, they realize the importance of secrecy

Hint - Indira never gloated or threatened military action against your nation during her tenure from 1967
 
Putin's action sure gave ideas to a lot of ambitious leaders around the world. we definitely need to prepare for a potential Indian invasion
 
Provided the Chinese go full Wei renmin fuwu like below

View attachment 822399

Aftermath.

644rew.gif

83F3B082-2AD1-4C3D-8BFA-4290742C7008.jpeg

EZU-YvhU8AAFlbY.jpg
 
Correct. Also that is the current inventory, China has increased the defense budget by 7.2% this year and ramped up production of the J-20, with some sources estimating China could have almost 500 J-20s in a few years. The Ukraine war, like every major war sees the Chinese do a through analysis followed by a major build up to catch up technological where possible.

Russia hasn’t prosecuted this war with full force to try to pacify the civilian population. That won’t be an issue for the Chinese.

A Sino-Indian war would be a real show of their expanding heliborne air assault forces, being build up for the Taiwan contingency. Hundreds of attack helicopters and hundreds of transport helicopters.



Indians have this wet-dream that they are anyway comparable to China.


The gap between India and China is going up every year and to compare the two nations in any way is an insult to China.


India is a messy and incompetent nation and will always remain so.
 
He must be saying that India can defeat China in defense if China decides to attack India..... I too believe this....

If you look at Russia Ukraine war, Ukraine doesn't even have natural barrier like Himalaya to slow down the Russian advance whereas India is blessed with this Barrier.... Ukraine still giving a strong fight to Russians in spite of having very weak and small military in comparison..... still Kiev not yet fallen....

India not only enjoys Himalaya barrier with most of the sites on top in her control but also have a much larger (though outdated compared to China) military compared to Ukraine.... Imagine how bloody will be the all out border war for China if she decides to do Ukraine on India.... China is very powerful no doubt but attacking and defeating something big like India that too in Himalayan terrain is no joke..... both sides will suffer huge losses and most likely the result will be a stalemate with both sides sitting on small small chunks of each others territory....


With all due respects, China is occupying your land and its a fact. So its every patriotic Indian job to liberate their lands, be brave and try your theory into practice. Please once you finished the Chinese nation conquest try to test your spanking new Rafael's against naughty boys Pakistan too. Your over prepared forces are rearing to go, lets have some fire works and enjoy the party if you lived to see the sun rise again.
 
Aftermath.
A series of carefully selected pictures, and we are supposed to fall for it. Good luck with that.

China is occupying your land and its a fact.
They are not.

It became a dispute because of the respective egos of Mao and Nehru. I do think you should educate yourself about the issues involved, including recent developments, before commenting in so glib a manner.
 
Observe Russia's strategy. They did not go for blitzkrieg. They went in a measured approach since they had anticipated support from fellow Slavic people and hoped to install a puppet regime.

China on the other hand will not have such problems. So in terms of strictly Conventional war, India will lose with China head to head. At the same time, I don't think China can hold on to Indian territory for long time either. That's a lot of hostile people to subdue and control. So eventually they will also have to withdraw.

In terms of Bangladesh, I don't think any Bangladeshi ever claims we can take on India in a conventional war. It will be the same war of attrition through guerilla tactics and any Indian invading force will eventually have to withdraw in long term. India doesn't have the power to invade and control a hostile population of 150+ million.

That said, referring back to the topic, that guy is clearly a joker to think India alone can win against China, where US wouldn't dare it.
Indians civilians are nothing like the Ukranians ,the civilians are cowardly ,pisspoor and looking to flee to other nation on any given chance.
They will likely be scared shitless to put up any resistance and most co-operative when subdued like their soldiers has shown, and once given some financial assistance they will change camps totally.China is much better at micromanaging than Russia .
 
Last edited:
When China breaches India North East, wherever the PLA goes, a new republic will be founded breaking away from British imposed land borders. China is literally able to liberate Indian serfs from the minority high castes.
 
Indians have this wet-dream that they are anyway comparable to China.


The gap between India and China is going up every year and to compare the two nations in any way is an insult to China.


India is a messy and incompetent nation and will always remain so.
Especially as China focuses on competing with the US, which is about to ramp up defense spending.
 
Last edited:
A series of carefully selected pictures, and we are supposed to fall for it. Good luck with that.


They are not.

It became a dispute because of the respective egos of Mao and Nehru. I do think you should educate yourself about the issues involved, including recent developments, before commenting in so glib a manner.
Here you go.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom