India a Country of Hindus and of Their Descendants - Dr. Swamy

[scorpionx]

there were no burning before that

Not at all. Ashoka won Kalinga by smart diplomacy.

 

[Mr.S.Singh]

Not at all. Ashoka won Kalinga by smart diplomacy.

Ashoka kidar se beech mein le aaya
we are taking about burning villages and forced conversion

 

[Indrani]

Thats invasion of an empire, that is not local population causing trouble sweetheart !
Whitewashed matlab ?? agle mahine india shift ! angreez nhi hu

Local population never caused a problem before Bin Qasim. As I said the wars were something like Mahabharata war. Start with sunrise and down with sunset. After sunset you could meet the enemy over tea. It would be in open maidan so that normal life and villagers are not troubled. No civilian property or life destruction. That was dharma yuddha within bounds of moral law. When the islamists came, India had no answer because they spread like locusts killing and destroying everything in their way. How many places and how many lives could kshatriya save. They had no concept of such enemy or war. The non-combatant civilians could not raise arms to protect themselves because they were forbidden by varna system to pick up arms.

White washing history is what the liberals did to our history. The cleaned up all the Muslim atrocities to show how the Muslims did us a favor by killing us. How Hindus were evil caste practitioners and so deserved to be killed. How Hindus were cruel and only storing wealth in temples and hence deserved to be looted. That is called as white washing.

Not at all. Ashoka won Kalinga by smart diplomacy.

Ashoka had a war in a battlefield where the killed were Kshatriya. Not civilians.

 

[amygdaloideum]

It started with Muhammad bin Qasim's attacks on Sindh. You need to make better use of internet and read up a bit. Too much of our history has been whitewashed.



It pretty much explains how Hindus view the world and why they do so. Though the guy is not talking from a Hindu perspective. What he says is what Vedanta is all about.

5 mins and it feel like listening to a schizo monologuing

 

[Indrani]

5 mins and it feel like listening to a schizo monologuing

Patience dear patience.

Though it is irritating when the god voice changes from a man to a woman's just because the author was trying to be politically correct.

 

[amygdaloideum]

Patience dear patience.

Though it is irritating when the god voice changes from a man to a woman's just because the author was trying to be politically correct.

dont expect sane minds to watch the whole video after that opening

 

[Mr.S.Singh]

Local population never caused a problem before Bin Qasim. As I said the wars were something like Mahabharata war. Start with sunrise and down with sunset. After sunset you could meet the enemy over tea. It would be in open maidan so that normal life and villagers are not troubled. No civilian property or life destruction. That was dharma yuddha within bounds of moral law. When the islamists came, India had no answer because they spread like locusts killing and destroying everything in their way. How many places and how many lives could kshatriya save. They had no concept of such enemy or war. The non-combatant civilians could not raise arms to protect themselves because they were forbidden by varna system to pick up arms.

White washing history is what the liberals did to our history. The cleaned up all the Muslim atrocities to show how the Muslims did us a favor by killing us. How Hindus were evil caste practitioners and so deserved to be killed. How Hindus were cruel and only storing wealth in temples and hence deserved to be looted. That is called as white washing.


ns.

Its survival of the fittest sadly ! The sikhs follows the same principle as hindus during mahabharata and we defeated the mughals

Qasim had a powerful army hence we lost

 

[Indrani]

Ashoka kidar se beech mein le aaya
we are taking about burning villages and forced conversion

He wanted to show that Hindus were killing raping and mutilating babies long before Muslims came. That Hindus were evil and so Muslims came to reform them.

 

[Chak Bamu]

This attitude was the reason India got divided in the first place and it will happen again.The Muslims wont come to Pakistan but they will tear apart "Mother India" again

Congrats, you just confirmed Hindutvavadi fears. Were you following the discussion here?

 

[Indrani]

dont expect sane minds to watch the whole video after that opening

Well the book is a better read and actually good, but still do plod on. Listen to at least half the tape before you decide to go no further. Well then again your call.

 

[Voltaire]

Yo. That different element of different group mix is what goes for Hinduism. So now you are baptized a Hindu.

Nope.By that account,everyone can be labelled as something else.Muslims can be called jews too I assume?
Or Indians can be called europeans or westerners as we borrow so much from them?Japanese and koreans can be called chinese?

How about this?
Hindus are nazis because nazis use swastika and called themselves aryan and hated muslims?After all jews, muslims, christians are all same?

 

[Mr.S.Singh]

He wanted to show that Hindus were killing raping and mutilating babies long before Muslims came. That Hindus were evil and so Muslims came to reform them.

Empires come and go
They will do anything to be in power
Rarely does come a king that has a vision and attributes you are pointing out

We had a few pre qasim and post like shivaji and maharaja ranjit singh

But rajput were always know to have these attributes

 

[scorpionx]

Local population never caused a problem before Bin Qasim. As I said the wars were something like Mahabharata war. Start with sunrise and down with sunset. After sunset you could meet the enemy over tea. It would be in open maidan so that normal life and villagers are not troubled. No civilian property or life destruction. That was dharma yuddha within bounds of moral law. When the islamists came, India had no answer because they spread like locusts killing and destroying everything in their way. How many places and how many lives could kshatriya save. They had no concept of such enemy or war. The non-combatant civilians could not raise arms to protect themselves because they were forbidden by varna system to pick up arms.

White washing history is what the liberals did to our history. The cleaned up all the Muslim atrocities to show how the Muslims did us a favor by killing us. How Hindus were evil caste practitioners and so deserved to be killed. How Hindus were cruel and only storing wealth in temples and hence deserved to be looted. That is called as white washing.



Ashoka had a war in a battlefield where the killed were Kshatriya. Not civilians.

There is not enough proof that civilians were not killed in Kalinga war. What we just know is a massive number of people lost lives and taken captive. Given the population of that period would be much less, it is natural to assume that a lot many civilians were among those casualties.

 

[amygdaloideum]

any other links with less drama and better theological approach

Well the book is a better read and actually good, but still do plod on. Listen to at least half the tape before you decide to go no further. Well then again your call.

 

[scorpionx]

He wanted to show that Hindus were killing raping and mutilating babies long before Muslims came. That Hindus were evil and so Muslims came to reform them.

Goebbels reborn.