What's new

If Jinnah could see Pakistan today, what would he say?

Homo Sapiens

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
9,641
Reaction score
-1
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
https://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/55211/if-jinnah-could-see-pakistan-today-what-would-he-say/
If Jinnah could see Pakistan today, what would he say?
By Shakir Lakhani Published: August 20, 2017


14 Comments Print Email
55211-_pak_jinnah_afpxjpg-1503055605-881-640x480.jpg

The magnitude of corruption would have shocked him. PHOTO: AFP

If Muhammad Ali Jinnah came back from the grave and saw the sorry state of the country he had created, what would he say?

He would be shocked to see that the Pakistan of 1947 had been broken into two, with East Pakistan (where his beloved Muslim League was founded) no longer a part of Pakistan.

He would see a country on the brink of an economic collapse, with the dollar (which was equal to the rupee in value in 1947) now worth Rs107.

He would see fruits and other edibles from New Zealand and other countries selling at prices beyond the reach of the common man in a land which once had the potential of being the granary of Asia.

He would see an innocent nine-year-old child killed by vehicles in a large rally led by a discredited politician. Moreover, he would see the poor victim being labelled a “martyr” for democracy by the heartless beasts who were responsible for his death.

He would be amazed to hear calls for putting the Constitution under abeyance, he who was the greatest constitutional lawyer of his times.

The magnitude of corruption would have shocked him, as he had said time and again that it was necessary to eliminate corruption for the new country to progress.

He would be shocked to see the hooliganism of the rowdy and undisciplined lawyers who attack judges.

He would be appalled to see the poverty of millions of Pakistanis who do not earn enough to feed their families and who desperately try to survive on less than a hundred rupees a day.

It would break his heart to see the state of our schools, where most teachers are absent except on the days when they turn up to collect their salaries.

And he would be filled with horror at the state of our hospitals, with the poor waiting in long lines to be attended to by ill-trained doctors, while our corrupt leaders rush abroad to get treated for the slightest of ailments.

He would see the huge palaces and mansions of the rich and the corrupt, but with beggars streaming our streets and roads, and he would be filled with despair.

He would see that those who opposed the creation of Pakistan (and who called him “Kafir-e-Azam”) are now the guardians of its ideology (as defined by them). As a result, intolerance is so high that even he would not be considered by such people to be a Muslim.

He would see Christians and other minorities being routinely charged with blasphemy (and being burnt alive). He would see Muslims being killed because their beliefs are different from those of their killers, who believe that only they are true Muslims.

He would remember what he had told the citizens of the country he had created:

“You are free; you are free to go to your temples. You are free to go to your mosques or to any other places of worship in this State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion, caste or creed—that has nothing to do with the business of the state.”

He would see girls as young as 11-years-old being married off to men old enough to be their grandfathers. The jirga system, the punishment of women for the sins of their male relatives, helpless women being stripped naked, gang-raped and made to walk in public would have shocked him to no end.

He would see rampant loot and plunder of the country, with shameless members of provincial ruling parties passing legislations to prevent the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) from investigating their corruption.

And he would see the city of his birth (Karachi) sinking under heaps of garbage and its residents being slowly poisoned by air and water pollution.

And Jinnah would have wept because present-day Pakistan is so utterly and so horribly different from the country he had wanted it to be.
 
.
Jinnah would have been pleased that pakistan is finally a democracy...after years of military rule.
 
. . .
I am a Pakistani not a karachi wala.

What is that even supposed to mean? A deeply prejudiced corrupt-to-the-core DG Rangers who's more interested in running his private businesses in Karachi than maintain law and order in the city, has the nerve to sprout this nonsense and you guys being blind military work shippers would praise him and repeat it, to infinity?

Most probably, he would ask the rest of you, to become Pakistanis first, rather than point your fingers at people who have sacrificed more for this country, than you ever could.
 
. .
The writer makes it as if these things weren't happening before pakistan and its something new.

The man was a lawyer and very pragmatic. He knew more about the social thinking and issues of the entire subcontinent than any of us.

You want me to tell you what he would say. I'll tell you.


As Pakistanis and Bangladeshis and Indians would be standing and waiting for him to say a word.

Pakistanis in fear and anxiety and Bangladeshis and Indians in excitement, he would look straight with an air of dominance.

Here is what would happen.

He would sigh. Wear his traditional topi and sherwani and would go to his office and work to make pakistan better just like in 1947. This is what he would do.

Bcz issues plaguing areas for hundreds if not thousands of years don't simply vanish due to the rise of a political entity or a union.

Bcz countries don't suddenly become developed and great especially ones with such complicated history.

All of it require work. Effort. Diligence and rather than wasting his time moaning he would work for the betterment of his creation just like we all should do rather than moan on what if stories.

Change yourself and watch how the change consumes everything.

You want the secret to a superpower. Two words. " work" " hard"

@Zibago @The Sandman @WAJsal
 
.
no matter what Jinah think about current Pakistan.
i am thankfull to Allah for Pakistan.
we are far better than mulims living in indina under fear for getting kill by mob and under the ruling of hindus who want them ghar wapsi and want rape dead Muslim women.
 
.
I honestly believe Jinnah would be proud that Pakistan is surviving and flourishing in the face of worst civil war, an enemy that is six-seven times bigger, a corrupt leadership which is more of a feudal lord and an anti-muslim sentiment prevaling world over. Thats a remarkable achivement!
 
. . .
The writer makes it as if these things weren't happening before pakistan and its something new.

The man was a lawyer and very pragmatic. He knew more about the social thinking and issues of the entire subcontinent than any of us.

You want me to tell you what he would say. I'll tell you.


As Pakistanis and Bangladeshis and Indians would be standing and waiting for him to say a word.

Pakistanis in fear and anxiety and Bangladeshis and Indians in excitement, he would look straight with an air of dominance.

Here is what would happen.

He would sigh. Wear his traditional topi and sherwani and would go to his office and work to make pakistan better just like in 1947. This is what he would do.

Bcz issues plaguing areas for hundreds if not thousands of years don't simply vanish due to the rise of a political entity or a union.

Bcz countries don't suddenly become developed and great especially ones with such complicated history.

All of it require work. Effort. Diligence and rather than wasting his time moaning he would work for the betterment of his creation just like we all should do rather than moan on what if stories.

Change yourself and watch how the change consumes everything.

You want the secret to a superpower. Two words. " work" " hard"

@Zibago @The Sandman @WAJsal
You're right we need to "work" "hard" but author have a point and this article is indeed thought provoking Pakistan was going in the right direction (economy wise at least) in the 60's i wonder what happened after that? what have we done with Pakistan today? we give votes to the most corrupt politicians just because bhutto is still alive? (although there isn't any bhutto in PPP anymore) or give votes to NS? because he made a road or two in front of my house? you tell me majority of our pop is aware? do they even realize that they're literally voting for corruption? what about our minorities? discrimination/violence against them? why they're not equal citizens like Quaid-e-Azam said they would be? the author have made some valid points bro. Most importantly i think even you know that Pakistan was hijacked the moment Quaid died.
@Azlan Haider

and i don't even want to talk what happened from 1977-88.
 
.
considering the odds he would be impressed we have survived

we have been superior to the rest of south asia in most indicators over the last 70 years, took on an enemy 7 times larger, a significant world military and nuclear power, with an improving economy and strategic plans for the future

what would he thought of Bangladesh? a weak dog on Indian leash at risk of being drowned and flooded

what would gandi thought of india? countless insurgencies, poverty, rape epidemic, lurching to the hindutva right where its minorities now feel unease
 
.
He would be dissatisfied that the Islamic country he wanted to establish does not run according to Shariah (Muslim Gods law) even after 70 years.
 
. .

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom