Think for a moment with calm head. Urdu speakers are kings of Karachi, they are not miss treated. They rule Pakistan. President is urdu speaker, Sindh governor is urdu speaker. PM is pashtun and ruling party is ethnic pashtun party that oppose national project Kalabagh dam just because its in punjab. Tomorrow he will select some pashtun COAS.
In this scenario its understandable why baloch and sindhi would feel insecure. Because if pandora box is opened then balochistan and sindh will be overrun by illegals from both sides.
Before granting bengalis and afghanis citizenship first remove fence from both sides of the border. Declare every muslim in the world natural citizen of Pakistan by default, and Pakistanis can go drown themselves in arabian sea. If federating units agree with this then go ahead and grant them citizenship.
No. 1 Imran khan is not a phustun.
He is a punjabi from mianwali and their family settled in lahore. He may be phustuns generations before as his tribe Niazi shows that, but third or 4th generation. He cannot even speak Phusto.
Secondly I hope to see a phustun army cheif, but sadly the present lot of generals I don't think there are more then 2 phustuns or even less then 2.
Imran Khan can only select among top 3 or 4, he would select on merit not on ethnicity.
I am damn sure of that.
And army is army
A person who reach at that point, has proved his merit. So we don't have to worry regarding that.
You are right. President, governor and ministeries are given to urdu speaking people. But all those big post cannot do a single thing for karachi..
Someone needs to own karachi.
And Sindh government certainly don't want that. They do treat urdu speaking as a second class, or Atleast they do hate them, because Sindhis think that they have somewhat settled into their provincial capital or now their population is bigger then interior Sindh. This is not the reason to hate. Both Sindhis and non Sindhis are humans.
Now federal government gives budget to Sindh government. But that budget was not distributed well among sindhi and non sindhi areas. Look at the condition of hyderabad and karachi.
This is really really sad.
Federal government cannot give a sperate pacakage to Karachi due to their thin economic condition. President cannot give them clean drinking water or governor cannot give them seawage system.
No provincial government treat their capital this way. What is people party trying to achieve. Do they want to throw them out or hope they would go somewhere else?
The best chance is to not distinguish and treat everyone as equal sindhi.
People's party should now stop using sindhi card, it is very old now.
Imran has lived in developed world. He always quote them.
Yes what he is saying is morally right.
But he cannot do this.
He has said in the parliament that they should give him suggestions, what should be done about the refuges. Plus different stake holders such as army and agencies and provinces would never allow it.
It was an idea that was picked up by the media.
Besides there has been bangalis living in karachi forever. They are Pakistanis now. They choose Pakistan after the separation of Bangladesh. They cannot be deported back or anything. They have genuine demand and they must be given nationality immediately.
They are not large community.
But Afghans must go Back..
No one can let Imran do this. It is just the idea and it has created very positive atmosphere around the world about Pakistan..
My views about Afghans are very clear.
They cannot be trusted. They are the god forsaken nation ever.
