Hitler's barbaric policies let to the formation of Israel

[FaujHistorian]

So many threads on praising Hitler.

So many hitler's fanboyz!

Reality?

Hitler's barbaric policies led to the formation of Israel

And anyone praising Hitler will unintentionally make Israel stronger and more determined.


Strange. Isn't it?

 

[Falcon29]

No he didn't. Jewish people were bored in Europe and had plans to colonize Palestine long before.

 

[TheNoob]

Nobody liked jews back then.
You dont want them doing your tax forms do you? lol

Well....
So they had to go to some place but WW2 seemed to be the best time to fool the world into the formation of israel... sooo......

(NO HATE PLEASE)

 

[Deathstroke]

Hitler's barbaric policies let the call for country for jews . Europe gave them land which was never their's to give.

 

[al-Hasani]

So many threads on praising Hitler.

Reality?

Hitler's barbaric policies let to the formation of Israel

And anyone praising Hitler will unintentionally make Israel stronger and more determined.


Strange. Isn't it?

The idea of colonizing Palestine among the Zionists predate Hitler by many decades. In fact before Hitler's birth!

Large scale Jewish migration (Aliyah) started already in 1882.

Aliyah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Already 1 million Jewish migrants had migrated to Palestine when nobody even knew who Hitler was aside from his close circle of family and friends. When he was totally irrelevant.

 

[rockstar08]

from the time of Prophet Muhammad pbuh they are threatening peoples from the massiah whom they are waiting for ...if peoples hate them that is for some reason

 

[Tacticool]

It was not Hitler policies. It was after Khyber when Jew tribe was forced to leave Medina, then it was after when Hazrat Umar (R.A) expelled them from Palestine and after that it was after Saladin expelled them from Jerusalem..

 

[airmarshal]

Totally disagree.

Balfour declaration of 1927 and Sykes-Picot agreement before that paved the way for Israel. Also, the evolution of the movement to create a Jewish homeland started in the last quarter of 19th century.

The Ottomans were the biggest roadblock in this. Their fall was catalyzed by events of WW1.

Incidentally Arabs were used to pull down the empire to pave way for Zionists. Same Arabs being used now to create fake caliphs with a deadly perverted ideology to undo the countries created as result of Middle East redraw after WW1.

 

[FaujHistorian]

It was not Hitler policies. It was after Khyber when Jew tribe was forced to leave Medina, then it was after when Hazrat Umar (R.A) expelled them from Palestine and after that it was after Saladin expelled them from Jerusalem..

Wrong sir

Saladin did NOT kick out jews from Jerusalem.

What you say is misinformation.

The idea of colonizing Palestine among the Zionists predate Hitler by many decades. In fact before Hitler's birth!

Large scale Jewish migration (Aliyah) started already in 1882.

Aliyah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Already 1 million Jewish migrants had migrated to Palestine when nobody even knew who Hitler was aside from his close circle of family and friends. When he was totally irrelevant.

you are trying to fit the history in order to justify present.

Totally disagree.

Balfour declaration of 1927 and Sykes-Picot agreement before that paved the way for Israel. Also, the evolution of the movement to create a Jewish homeland started in the last quarter of 19th century.

The Ottomans were the biggest roadblock in this. Their fall was catalyzed by events of WW1.

Incidentally Arabs were used to pull down the empire to pave way for Zionists. Same Arabs being used now to create fake caliphs with a deadly perverted ideology to undo the countries created as result of Middle East redraw after WW1.

May be may be not.

It is all supposition.

Jews wanted to live in Palestine, may be have Israel.

But not in the current form

This form is the result of Hitler and Hitler like policies.

 

[Penguin]

The idea of colonizing Palestine among the Zionists predate Hitler by many decades. In fact before Hitler's birth!

Large scale Jewish migration (Aliyah) started already in 1882.

Aliyah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Already 1 million Jewish migrants had migrated to Palestine when nobody even knew who Hitler was aside from his close circle of family and friends. When he was totally irrelevant.

Yes, perhaps, but the question is: would that by itself have led to the formation of the State of Isreal in 1948, had there NOT been a Hitler and a WW2? Would that by itself have been sufficient? Or would that have inevidably led to a State of Isreal, if perhaps a later date, and under different circumstances? And hence a different situation and status quo today?

 

[al-Hasani]

@FaujHistorian

What? Read what I wrote. Those are FACTS. I am just proving you wrong. Large-scale Jewish migration to Palestine already occurred BEFORE Hitler was even born and when he was still totally unknown.

Anyway what is the purpose of this thread really?

@Desert Fox

Yes, but the question is: would that by itself have led to the formation of the State of Isreal in 1948, had there NOT been a Hitler and a WW2?

Yes, everything pointed in that direction. After all those Jewish migrants were claiming what is now Palestine and Israel as their land. They did not migrate to Madagascar.

 

[FaujHistorian]

Anyway what is the purpose of this thread really?

.

if you praise or behave like Hitler, you will make Israel stronger.

Countries and governments threatened for their very survival can do enormous fight. Educated Arabs have not experienced the same level of atrocities at the hands of people like Hitler, where they lost their 70-80% population in no time.



Hope you get it this time.

 

[Deathstroke]

May be may be not.

It is all supposition.

Jews wanted to live in Palestine, may be have Israel.

But not in the current form

This form is the result of Hitler and Hitler like policies.

you should google "Der Judenstaat"

 

[Penguin]

Israel / Palestine: Arab / Jewish Population (1914-2005)
Population Statistics - Israeli-Palestinian Conflict - Solutions - Pros and Cons - ProCon.org

Population Statistics - Israeli-Palestinian Conflict - Solutions - Pros and Cons - ProCon.org

I'm not so sure....

 

[al-Hasani]

if you praise or behave like Hitler, you will make Israel stronger.

Countries and governments threatened for their very survival can do enormous fight. Educated Arabs have not experienced the same level of atrocities at the hands of people like Hitler, where they lost their 70-80% population in no time.



Hope you get it this time.

I do not praise Hitler "or behave like him". Where do you see that? Come on.

Of course not. Anyway just so you know then there is a lot of uncertainty surrounding the real number of casualties during the Holocaust.

Don't forget that the victors tend to write the history.

Israel / Palestine: Arab / Jewish Population (1914-2005)
Population Statistics - Israeli-Palestinian Conflict - Solutions - Pros and Cons - ProCon.org

Population Statistics - Israeli-Palestinian Conflict - Solutions - Pros and Cons - ProCon.org

I'm not so sure....

What are you not so sure about? That wide-scale Jewish migrations occurred before Hitler was born and when he was still very unknown?

I honestly suggest that you do some research. Start here below:

Aliyah - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Demographic history of Jerusalem - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Look how the demographics in Jerusalem changed rapidly out of a sudden starting from the 1880's and what caused that.