Himachal ban on Hindu animal sacrifices sparks debate among legal experts

[Bang Galore]

I am not much of a 'religious' kind, hence, not much worried about the religious part of the ban, but if we try to be logical on this issue, then certain questions come up:

1. Are those animals that are being sacrificed in the temples are endangered or protected species, thus illegal to kill?
- The answer is NO.

2. Are those animals are also being killed in India for human consumption?
- The answer is YES.

3. Is animal sacrifice prohibited in Hinduism?
- The answer is NO.

4. Are the temple owners/administrators free to decide how they want to do the puja path, and what to offer to gods, as per their tradition & beliefs?
- The answer is YES.

5. Are the protestors free to go to any other temple where animal sacrifice is not the tradition?
- The answer is YES.

6. Was the court acted in a biased manner when it banned animal sacrifice for one particular religious group?
- The answer is YES.

Then how the court came to the conclusion that animal sacrifice or offering meat to gods is illegal when the same meat is being consumed by many Indians all over the country, legally?

If killing animal is brutality, then killing them for human consumption is also brutality, should we ban all non-veg food next? Can we stretch that argument for living plants also?

---- To all Indians who are supporting this judgement.
@Bang Galore @utraash @SarthakGanguly @Dem!god

Didn't support the HC judgment per se. More a general principle. All animal sacrifices needs to be banned. Slaughter should only happen in abattoirs preferably. People shouldn't be allowed to run around chopping of heads or cutting throats of animals just because they want to or because their ancestors ages ago, did so.

 

[Dandpatta]

Isn't there a commercial angle to slaughter too? I mean, come on, how many bovines are slaughtered and the hides go to commercial tanneries ? It's all about $$$$ mennnn... Religion goes to hell when the crisp notes exchange hands.

 

[DingDong]

its true brother

here is hindu festival Gadhimai images search
look at it
festival Gadhimai - Google Search

Disgusting. Can anybody locate this particular place?

 

[utraash]

Fist impose Ban on Killings done on Eid, then show your morality.

I am against that too........
But phele apne ko sudharo fir dusro ko.....

 

[bitter_truth]

First fck off the EID Festival then talk about yagyas

bro first we have to set example to do this.. If we ourselves do not stop animal slaughtering how will we protest against muslims?
Anyways we have ensured this time there is no cow slaughtered in this eid in my area.

 

[asad71]

Photos from कुमार रवि यदुवंशी's post in... - कुमार रवि यदुवंशी | Facebook



Photos from कुमार रवि यदुवंशी's post in WE SUPPORT NARENDRA MODI
Back to Album

कुमार रवि यदुवंशी‎WE SUPPORT NARENDRA MODI

इस सूअर को लगता था मुझे कोई नहीं पकड पायेगा! करीब एक साल से बच रहा था तय्युब उर्फ़ मामू नाम का ये गौ हत्यारा!
दोस्तों आप लोगों के सहयोग से राहतगढ़ कसाई मंड़ी से सागर बिकने जाने बाला गौ मांस लगभग बंद हो गया है! लेकिन ये तय्युव मियां मान ही नहीं रहे थे इन्हें लगता था की बड़े भारी गुंडे हैं ये! क्यों की कई थानों मैं मामले हैं इनके खिलाफ! एक के ऊपर तो बस चढ़ाकर मार भी चुके हैं! कई बार पुलिस को सूचना दी लेक... See More
— with Kailash Jat, Roshan Choudhary, Badrilal Jat, Kailash Choudhary Leswa and Mahendar Tada.
Like"}" data-reactid=".0.1">Like · Share · October 5

 

[Dem!god]

Photos from कुमार रवि यदुवंशी's post in... - कुमार रवि यदुवंशी | Facebook



Photos from कुमार रवि यदुवंशी's post in WE SUPPORT NARENDRA MODI
Back to Album
View attachment 118052
कुमार रवि यदुवंशी‎WE SUPPORT NARENDRA MODI

इस सूअर को लगता था मुझे कोई नहीं पकड पायेगा! करीब एक साल से बच रहा था तय्युब उर्फ़ मामू नाम का ये गौ हत्यारा!
दोस्तों आप लोगों के सहयोग से राहतगढ़ कसाई मंड़ी से सागर बिकने जाने बाला गौ मांस लगभग बंद हो गया है! लेकिन ये तय्युव मियां मान ही नहीं रहे थे इन्हें लगता था की बड़े भारी गुंडे हैं ये! क्यों की कई थानों मैं मामले हैं इनके खिलाफ! एक के ऊपर तो बस चढ़ाकर मार भी चुके हैं! कई बार पुलिस को सूचना दी लेक... See More
— with Kailash Jat, Roshan Choudhary, Badrilal Jat, Kailash Choudhary Leswa and Mahendar Tada.
Like"}" data-reactid=".0.1">Like · Share · October 5

how is thos related to the topic mr. professional....

 

[asad71]

how is thos related to the topic mr. professional....

First learn Hindi.Then open the link, Mr Unprofessional.

 

[kurup]

Animal sacrifice of all kind should be banned in India .

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

Vegetarian sacrifice should be banned in India as well

Plants are considered living animals proven by science

I suggest solar power cells for Humans so we get off the Plant and animal source for survival

 

[bitter_truth]

Vegetarian sacrifice should be banned in India as well

Plants are considered living animals proven by science

I suggest solar power cells for Humans so we get off the Plant and animal source for survival

did here anyone said that meat should be banned in pakistan?
Dusro ke maamlo me taang adane ki aadat chod de..

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Vegetarian sacrifice should be banned in India as well

Plants are considered living animals proven by science

I suggest solar power cells for Humans so we get off the Plant and animal source for survival

NOT. YOUR. CONCERN.

Uh, you always stand by everyone's point of view, too diplomatic.

No. I am worse. Chanakya.
Bagal mein churi muh mein Ram naam

lesson learned Now stay away from..... "us"

Nope. The most I got from 'you' were some jokes, taunts etc. From a specific community we got a different kind of flak.

 

[SledgeHammer]

Disgusting. Can anybody locate this particular place?

That's Gadhimai festival in Nepal.

 

[HariPrasad]

look like s.asians start getting rights fever lolz

What is your view Imaran Saheb?

 

[TheRafael00000]

Not meat... drink the urine.