Govt asks economist Atif Mian to step down from Economic Advisory Council

[Zarvan]

Yes, Hiring qualified personals is foolish decision...

Their are hundreds of others qualified persons 20 Crore is population of Pakistan I am more than sure their are several other Pakistani economy professors in Universities like MIT and Harvard and others.

 

[Falcon26]

Bad move by PTI. Very disappointed today!

This is the old mullah Pakistan... Not the new Pakistan

This was expected after last year’s caving by the government. An opportunity to crush these thugs was missed and the state as whole is suffering and will suffer because every time the government caves in, these thugs are emboldened. This was my assertion from last year and sadly I am right.

Imran Khan and the PTI had the public mandate and support to stand up to these thugs but they retreated. Not a critic of Imran Khan, but after today he should never talk about Jinnah’s Pakistan.

If you are demanding that your cabinet minister should resign to appease a fringe group, then you are setting a very dangerous precedence that will take your country down a ruinous path of no return. It’s important to put politics aside and look at the big picture, sometimes.

https://defence.pk/pdf/threads/poli...shes-army-called.530260/page-34#post-10041819

 

[Syed1.]

Their are hundreds of others qualified persons 20 Crore is population of Pakistan I am more than sure their are several other Pakistani economy professors in Universities like MIT and Harvard and others.

Do you even know the credentials of Atif Mian? Is there no other Pakistani on the list on which Atif Mian was featured



For jahil people like you, I'll post the list of IMF's 25 Brightest young economists, read the list and let me know if you see any other Pakistani there.
https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/imf-lists-25-brightest-young-economists-1462827



Paindu jahils are the reason Pakistan it is the way it is. Jahils like you would rather have a Khadim Rizvi type madarchod in the economic council than a guy who actually knows economics.

 

[Verve]

Had he been a Pakistani Sikh advisor, this issue wouldn't have come up. This is not a minority issue.

Issue is Qadyani.

Those painting is a minority issue are manipulating.

 

[Syed1.]

Had he been a Pakistani Sikh advisor, this issue wouldn't have come up. This is not a minority issue.

Issue is Qadyani.

Those painting is a minority issue are manipulating.

So Ahmedis are not a minority? You are suggesting they are part of the majority religion?



Why not round up all the Ahmedis and execute them, then you guys can move onto the Hindus, and Sikhs, and Parsis, might as well go ahead and turn the guns on the Shias as well. Then finally there will be Pak Saaf Pakistan with only pious Sunni Muslims. Sword of the Muslim Ummah.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Their are hundreds of others qualified persons 20 Crore is population of Pakistan I am more than sure their are several other Pakistani economy professors in Universities like MIT and Harvard and others.

There well might be but please tell me why Atif Mian should be removed from the list?

 

[gutto786]

Whats done is done! It was a little hope but PTI has mandate and its their decision. Business as usual. All the best for Pakistan always!
I request people to show some manners, and dont spit hatred against Atif Mian. Throughout the last few days, he didnt say anything.

 

[313ghazi]

So Ahmedis are not a minority? You are suggesting they are part of the majority religion?



Why not round up all the Ahmedis and execute them, then you guys can move onto the Hindus, and Sikhs, and Parsis, might as well go ahead and turn the guns on the Shias as well. Then finally there will be Pak Saaf Pakistan with only pious Sunni Muslims. Sword of the Muslim Ummah.

Don't be silly. After this the guns will be turned in a deobandi vs barelvi vs wahhabi fight.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Khadim Rizvi type madarchod in the economic council than a guy who actually knows economics.

Hahaha ....

 

[Verve]

So Ahmedis are not a minority? You are suggesting they are part of the majority religion?



Why not round up all the Ahmedis and execute them, then you guys can move onto the Hindus, and Sikhs, and Parsis, might as well go ahead and turn the guns on the Shias as well. Then finally there will be Pak Saaf Pakistan with only pious Sunni Muslims. Sword of the Muslim Ummah.

This is a sensitive issue. And the only one that is banged on about on social media and across the world by Qadyanis and their backers.

Public is not ready for their government to include Qadyanis so the government shouldn't. Qadyanis however are not helping the case by bashing Pakistan and the constitution on social media, like this guy Atif's tweet.

You don't see Pakistani Christians and other religious minorities doing the same.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

You don't see Pakistani Christians and other religious minorities doing the same.

Do you believe in collective punishment? Would you like to get fcuked by UK government for the actions of some Muslims in the country like the London bombers? Would you appreciate legalized discrimination against Muslims in UK. Would you like Sadiq Khan Mayor of London being removed from office because he is a Muslim?

Would you?

 

[Musafir117]

I never lose hope in Pakistan and see 90% of PTI supporters condemning the decision of Party make my hopes more strongers. Now you can guess the same ratio in real world too, thanks to majority of Insafian thanks to stand with right things and don’t afraid extermits only less than 10% here and out. Let’s clean that tiny minority who ruling on us on fear and blood.
May Allah Bless you all Ameen.

 

[gutto786]

Qadyanis however are not helping the case by bashing Pakistan and the constitution on social media, like this guy Atif's tweet.

Please stop this propaganda that he said anything against Pakistan.
Every Pakistani has right to comment on pakistan govt and its policies. Like govt. Made a decision to include atif mian and many were commenting against it. That doesnt make you anti pakistan.
Before 74 when constitution accepted ahmadis as muslim, and mullahs were talking against it and demanding to fix constitution, they were being anti Pakistan or what??
Atif Mian has not said anything against Pakistan

 

[Indus Pakistan]

May Allah Bless you all Ameen.

I think to be fair we can't have a revolution in Pakistan. Nearly four decades of cultivating extremism since Bhutto's days in 1970s means ths type of thinking has permeated deep into the fabric of society. But change will come in increments. Maybe in the next government or the one after enough of other priorities will have been sorted to that things like this can be taken head on. For now education, poverty, health, economy are top of the list.

 

[Zarvan]

Actually Hypocricy Wins.Those People Won Whose Aqeedah-e-Khatm-e-Nauwat Was So Weak That It Would Be Ruined In The Presence Of A Qadiani Economic Advisor

Really I am pretty sure you would have given same advice to Hazrat Abu Bakar RA when he decided to wage war against those false PROPHETS and their followers after RASOOL SAW.

I thought Imran khan will not bow down, but he has done it for few extremist. .. This is the mentality of Imran khan which we fear. There is a reason pakistan taliban appointed him as leader.
We are again moving towards extremism, religious bigotry and sectarian issues.
I wish this news is wrong. Decision was made on merit by appointing him as 25 best economist of the world.
FIRST MURDER OF MERIT
I smell pinky peerni behind this

First no Taliban appointed him. Secondly more than 90 % people support Imran on this and it seem liberals are too naive to understand the sensitivity of this issue. No murder of merit but her very wisely stopped the blood bath which was about to follow

All big talk of merit from Imran Khan falls flat today.

No it doesn't if you want to see blood bath because you are too thirsty for for Blood your issue. but Imran is leader of nation he is not going to let thousands people murdered just to please ego of some liberals