What's new

Expat population ‘could threaten’ GCC security

Status
Not open for further replies.

Sinnerman108

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jul 20, 2009
Messages
8,994
Reaction score
-3
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
.JEDDAH: More than 12.5 million workers in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries are foreigners, accounting for 31 percent of the 40 million GCC population, the latest official study said.
Three million foreigners are domestic workers in the six GCC member states.
The expatriate labor is not distributed in uniformly in these countries.
While 30 percent of the Saudi Arabian population is expatriate, in Bahrain it is 26 percent. Expatriates account for 80 percent of the population in the United Arab Emirates, while they constitute 27 percent in Qatar, 63 percent in Kuwait and 62 percent in Oman.
However, some other studies claim that the actual number of expatriate workers in the GCC is about 15 million, Al-Hayat daily reported yesterday.
The expatriate work force in the Gulf can be divided into Arabs and Asians. They flock from their poor native countries to the wealthy Gulf in search of employment and better living conditions. The large-scale recruitment of expatriate work force was justified by the need for executing huge development projects in the fast-growing GCC countries. Another factor was the willingness of expatriate workers to undertake hazardous jobs with lower wages that Gulf citizens refuse to do.
They started coming to the Gulf countries mostly in the 1970s, when oil companies largely depended on workers from the subcontinent. The trading, transport, fishing and security sectors also depended heavily on the expatriates. As the economies in the Gulf countries continued their growth in later decades, multinational companies that undertook extensive development of the infrastructural sector recruited labor from the cheapest sources in Asian countries.
It is also worrying that the level of Arab expatriates has been falling compared to Asians in the GCC. According to a report of the Arab Labor Organization, the number of Arab expatriate workers in the GCC plummeted from 72 percent in 1975 to 23 percent in 2008.
For instance, the report found that Egyptians and other Arab workers accounted for only 11 percent, while Indian workers dominated the work force by 52 percent followed by 10 percent Pakistanis. There are also three percent consultants and experts from Western countries.
One of the problems created by the huge presence of expatriates is the threat they pose to a country’s security. The sheer number will also take its toll on the planned utilities in these countries.
Abdullah Al-Gheilani, an Omani expert on demography, said the imbalance in the population was a security issue rather than an economic one. “The recruitment of expatriate labor and experts for developmental works is not the problem, but the real problem is to depend on the foreign work force for decades. Gulf countries excepting Saudi Arabia and Oman are unable to manage even their internal (security) matters by their national work force,” Al-Gheilani said.
He also warned against the erosion of social values and increase in crime rates because of the imbalanced presence of foreigners in a society.
The expert observed that the expatriates in GCC countries refused to integrate with the local culture, unlike the migrant communities in the United States had been doing.
He called on the Gulf countries to grapple with the unhealthy demographic situation seriously and jointly.
One of the solutions recommended by Al-Gheilani to solve the issue is to enable Arab expatriates to integrate into the GCC society, “because Arabs are less dangerous for the GCC society than any other nationality of expatriate workers.”
.

Expat population

Hoping for a fact based debate.
 
An old new issue

----------

December 26, 2010

Dubai Police chief warns of expats' threat to Gulf identity

Gulf citizens may soon be marginalised with continued rise in expat workers' population in GCC, says Dubai Police chief

Dubai's Police Chief supported a claim that if the population of expatriate workers continued to rise in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) at the current pace, Gulf citizens would soon be marginalised.

"The possibility of GCC nationals turning into a minority in their own countries cannot be ruled out if a law is, for instance, promulgated and enforced to naturalise expatriates," Lieutenant-Colonel Dahi Khalfan said.

He was reacting to questions from the audience at a popular monthly call-in programme on Qatar Television Laqum Al Qarar (It is Your Decision).

The audience comprised mostly young people, both men and women, from across the Gulf, Qatari daily The Peninsula reported on Sunday.

The discussion addressed "whether the rising numbers of foreign workers posed a serious threat to the GCC identity and culture, and if so, what steps the governments in the region could take to reduce the danger."

If the GCC governments do not take "bold steps" to check the inflow of foreign workforce, a day could come when locals would be marginalised in their own countries and become like Red Indians in the US, Dahi said.

Citing examples, Dahi told people to look at the Malabaris, (a reference to Indians from Kerala) and Iranians who come here and run small neighbourhood stores and eventually become millionaires.

"Why can't we run these stores which, after all, we legally own? But we do not want to do such work," he said.

An Indian driver is hired by a Gulf family and then he manages to bring a relative even if there is no job for him. The relative hunts for a job and lands one. This is an unending chain, Dahi said.

Ministers should bring to the notice of the GCC rulers the rising threat the heavy influx of foreign workers poses to GCC identity and culture, he said.

However, when asked if the problem could be tackled to some extent if more workers were brought in from Arab countries, Dahi said: "I do agree that they (Arab expatriates) are better than non-Arabs."

Dubai Police chief warns of expats' threat to Gulf identity | GulfNews.com
 
52 % indian workers? Good then we could make conquest of the arab monkey nations in no time.And get the cheap oil too.

lets read history together, lets look for the finest prints where it mentions the last time Indians conquered anything in their 3000 years long history. Its the same people who conquered you 1200 years ago... Jayada bara bool na bol aur chal apni job ker chup ho ke
 
lets read history together, lets look for the finest prints where it mentions the last time Indians conquest anything in their 3000 years long history. Its the same people who conquered you 1200 years ago... Jayada bara bool na bol

That was past.In present Arabs are weak and divided.Like how parts of india were then.
 
52 % indian workers? Good then we could make conquest of the arab monkey nations in no time.And get the cheap oil too.

Day dreaming arent we here ..... lol
 
it is no security threat its called democracy......once the residents who have been in these "states" for decades and dgenerations demand their human rights and political representation i.e. citizenship and voting rights ----- we see end of the all the "royalty" in the gulf and a normal human state formation.....they can the set up equal rights for all citizens and doa way with the discrimination in these "states"....
 
A time bomb waiting to be exploded, no doubt.

Nothing is going to explode, all expatriates know that getting citizenship is impossible before they came for work. GCC take stiff measures toward any similar demands, opening your mouth with one word about citizenship is an enough reason for an immediate deportation. Gulf Arabs are already a minority in their countries. So, citizenship is not even a choice.
 
The expert observed that the expatriates in GCC countries refused to integrate with the local culture, unlike the migrant communities in the United States had been doing.

This is a joke right? I mean a big one.

Besides, it would be great if true crime rates can be obtained and then put against the % of population of each country. But I suppose that is too inconvenient, otherwise would be available readily.

@VK_man - cut the cr@p pls, go back to trolling turks on the PKK thread. Unless all you are really doing here is providing one more opportunity to a bunch of morons to splash their hindu hatred.
 
“because Arabs are less dangerous for the GCC society than any other nationality of expatriate workers.”

GCC doesn't follow some major aspects of Islamic teachings like marriage between different ethnicity and races. Our beloved prophet Muhammad(pbuh) encouraged marriage between different races and ethnicity but the sadly arab monarchs have made something prohibited that Islam made permissible. Arabs should come out of these mentality as it is a poison to believe and take pride in nationalism and ethnicity which the arabs monarchs are taking pride in. Racism like these are the reason arabs find some Pakistanis and Bangladeshis bad mouthing arabs and musriks from other countries take advantage of these ignorance from both sides to create more conflict.

Give citizenship to legitimately hardworking muslim just like the west do. What is with this arabs and non-arab non-sense. These is akin to the pre-islamic era of ignorance. A muslim can not spout such non-sense. Any arab believing and talking such nonsense is going against the teachings of the Quran and sunnah and as Allah(swt) says in the Quran: those who create divisions and sects, the Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) has nothing to do with them.

Brotherhood by Salem Al Amry - YouTube

Dont degrade your Muslim brother based on Nationality or level of Job - Abu Mussab Wajdi Akkari - YouTube
 
The expert observed that the expatriates in GCC countries refused to integrate with the local culture, unlike the migrant communities in the United States had been doing.

Sorry , I do not buy this statement ... The article is sensationalist and highly biased !
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom