What's new

'Demographic flooding': India introduces new Kashmir domicile law

Oe
Yes,that would a good idea.
Look,,,i dont care much for JnK.
But it is an issue which has lingered so long with no end in sight.
And frankly i dont believe bhayya people in both countries have it in them to solve this via war or dialog.
I also believe tht despite changing domicile laws people, other thn northeast of India will be willing to settle thr now,,,,perhaps after a decade or so.

I feel this is the only way forwrd

Settle Assam regiment jawans frm northeastern tribes n see the dividends in a decade
 
.
Under the law, those who have resided for a period of 15 years in Kashmir are eligible to become permanent residents.


Srinagar, Indian-administered Kashmir - The Indian government has announced a new set of laws for Indian-administered Kashmir, including domicile rights for Indian citizens, that experts and residents fear will alter the demographic status of the Muslim-majority Himalayan region.

Under the new law, those who have resided for a period of 15 years in Indian-administered Kashmir or studied for a period of seven years and appeared in Class 10/12 examinations in educational institutions located in the region are now eligible to become permanent residents.

The announcement came nearly eight months after the Indian government stripped the disputed region of its limited autonomy that had protected the region for decades from demographic changes.

'Worry the Kashmiris'

The new law announced by the Ministry of Home Affairs also provided domicile status to the children of central government officials who have served in Indian-administered Kashmir for a total period of 10 years.

The notification by India's Hindu nationalist government comes as the country of 1.3 billion people is under a 21-day lockdown due to coronavirus fears.

The government changed the geographical and political status of the Indian-administered Kashmir region on August 5 after it abrogated Article 370 - a law that restricted rights over jobs, scholarships and land to the permanent residents of Indian-administered Kashmir.

Subsequently, the Muslim-majority region was divided into two federally-administered territories with little power vested in the hands of the local people to decide their future.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi had justified the stripping of the region's special status saying it will bring development.

Retired Air Vice Marshal Kapil Kak, who has challenged the abrogation of Article 370 in the Supreme Court, said it is "a permanent resident by stealth". "It should worry the Kashmiris."

"The effect of this notification would be felt in [the] Jammu [region] because there are not many people who have come into Kashmir in the last 15 years," he told Al Jazeera.

'Demographic flooding'

While the law has triggered fear among Kashmiris about the "permanent settlements by the outsiders", the experts say it will lead to "demographic flooding".

"It is a lot to circumvent the law. I think it illustrates clearly that some will not stop from politicking during coronavirus," Siddiq Wahid, a political analyst based in Indian-administered Kashmir told Al Jazeera, referring to the current coronavirus crisis.

"Obviously it is an attempt to change the demographics, not only change but flood it. It will lead to demographic flooding," Wahid said.

He said the change of law "is much larger than [the issue of jobs]". "I am not even thinking about jobs."

Sheikh Showkat Hussain, professor of legal studies based in the region, said: "It was in the offing."

"The whole purpose of revoking Article 370 was to settle outsiders here and change the demography of the state. Now this provides the modalities and entitles so many categories of Indians whose settlement will be legalised over here."

But the leaders of the governing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) justified the step, saying it will secure jobs only for the domiciles of the region.

"We have been pitching for it. Everyone in Jammu and Kashmir is happy, let people who live here for 15 years get the benefits, no other outsiders will get it," said Ashok Kaul, the general secretary for the BJP in Jammu and Kashmir.

According to the new law, jobs up to the lowest level of non-gazetted rank are reserved for Jammu and Kashmir domiciles.

Omar Abdullah, the former chief minister of the erstwhile state of Jammu and Kashmir and a pro-Indian politician who was recently released after seven months of detention, criticised the government for bringing in the law when the focus should be on fighting the current pandemic.

"Talk about suspect timing. At a time when all our efforts and attention should be focused on the #COVID outbreak the government slips in anew domicile law for J&K. Insult is heaped on injury when law offers none of the protections that had been promised."

'To protect Kashmir's unique identity'

Khurram Parvez, a human rights defender based in the region, said: "By virtue of this order, outsiders are also going to be the claimants of jobs in Jammu and Kashmir, which already has a huge unemployment problem. This is an act against the interests of unemployed youth."

The right-wing BJP has been opposed to the special status given to Indian-administered Kashmir in 1947 when British India was partitioned into Hindu-majority India and Pakistan as land for Muslims. But Kashmir's status could not be decided at the time as its then-Hindu ruler signed an Instrument of Accession with India, with New Delhi granting it a measure of autonomy - its own constitution, a separate flag and right to make laws.

Prime Minister Modi made the abrogation of Article 370 as one of his poll planks in the 2019 elections that he won by a landslide.

Rakesh Sinha, BJP leader and member of the upper house of Parliament, denied it was an attempt to change the demography of the state.

"There is an attempt to spread rumours about altering the demography of the state," Sinha told Al Jazeera.

"To protect Kashmir's unique identity is our moral and constitutional obligation. Identity of the northeast is protected and so is that of Kashmir so that the uniqueness of their culture remains protected."

Akash Bisht contributed from New Delhi
 
.
Oe

Look,,,i dont care much for JnK.
But it is an issue which has lingered so long with no end in sight.
And frankly i dont believe bhayya people in both countries have it in them to solve this via war or dialog.
I also believe tht despite changing domicile laws people, other thn northeast of India will be willing to settle thr now,,,,perhaps after a decade or so.

I feel this is the only way forwrd

Settle Assam regiment jawans frm northeastern tribes n see the dividends in a decade
It would only lead to more problems,there is a nuclear armed state as a party in whole conflict which changes dynamics of entire issue.
 
. .
What's the fuss? This is the same in most states if not all. You need to be resident for 15 years in Maharashtra and you get a domicile certificate for the state. They are just bringing J&K UT in line with the rest of the States and UTs.

Fuss is PDF doesn't like it otherwise there is no fuss at all about this anywhere.
 
.
It would only lead to more problems,there is a nuclear armed state as a party in whole conflict which changes dynamics of entire issue.
Both countries have been nuclear for more thn 2decades now.
It only makes a full fledged war redundant.
 
. . .
Fuss is PDF doesn't like it otherwise there is no fuss at all about this anywhere.

As is the norm, even the Pakistani Government hasn't issued any official statements rejecting this move. (Not that it matters of they do).
 
.
So says the person who belongs to the race of men who have the smallest....... :azn::

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/6161691.stm
That's pure savage.

As is the norm, even the Pakistani Government hasn't issued any official statements rejecting this move. (Not that it matters of they do).
Offical Pakistan position is clear,whatever you do it doesn't matters,GoI give it a special status and they took it back,GoP never asked for them to grant this special status in first place.

Let Imran grow balls first.
You can contact him personally for that,i have no idea.
 
.
This is to directly change the demographics of Kashmir. India wants to push Hindus into the region to dilute the traditionally strong 97% Muslim population of the Kashmir valley.

They will however do nothing but reignite the freedom struggle.
 
.
This is to directly change the demographics of Kashmir. India wants to push Hindus into the region to dilute the traditionally strong 97% Muslim population of the Kashmir valley.

They will however do nothing but reignite the freedom struggle.

Ok. And how is that any concern of yours? Does it affect your day to day life in Pakistan? No.
It's a Union territory, and existing archaic laws will be updated to bring it in line with other UTs and states. You can make whatever you want of it. As for what you call the freedom struggle, IF that happens, the GoI is perfectly capable of dealing with it. You need not stress yourself thinking about it.

Stay home, stay safe. Cheers.
 
. .
A frnd of mine in civil services said that land laws will be reformed next in these union territories,making it easier for businesses n companies to buy land.

According to him these proposals have been thr for decades but govts of the past just dragged thr feet,,because they didnt feel the time was right.

Personally i think this provides a perfect opportunity to settle naga tribes in leh laddakh region(perhaps in the valley too).

Haryanvi Jats are in line too. Let us see.

We definitely need mainstreaming and integration.

We also need people who can take care of themselves for now.
 
.
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2020...ces-kashmir-domicile-law-200401100651450.html


--------------

^^ hindus from india proper are being relocated to kashmir , ex army are being alloted land ,

a demographic change is being applied in kashmir ..


---------------

time to heat up the hybrid war , launch more freedom fighters and speed up the arms delivery to them..

--------------


i suspect that india would go for PLEBISCITE once it is comfortable with a demographic that favors delhi in a possible vote
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom