Dalit girl's limbs chopped off for resisting rape in UP, India

[LaBong]

A twist would be implied.. if it said minister rapes, dalit girl..
or Dalit girl raped by brahmin with ministers consent.

While I can sense the low blow in the title..
The girl was dalit..and since that exists in the news and in the context..
nothing wrong there....by the rules.

Sorry I don't understand, why the girl's caste is important in the context of the news when she was raped because of a family feud? It's wasn't mentioned in the source so the thread-starter must have been added it for a purpose, it would be good if he clarifies the same.

Girl is Dalit, accepted, but she is also poor, destitute, helpless etc, why the sudden stress on Dalit identifier.

 

[Agnostic_Indian]

I disagree. It's not just the politician's. The people of this land are equally to blame.

One of the Indian member suggested "Dont compare this with Taliban". I say "Why Not?"

The only reason, such incident happens in this central states is because of the religious intolerance, caste based discrimination practice, Racial discrimination, gender bias ...and lastly.... no regards for law of the land.

Tell me now, is this any different from the Taliban's?

Sad, the land of Jayprakash Narayan, is reduced to this level.

Regards.

According to some reports, the ghastly incident was the result of an ongoing feud between the victim ’ s and assailants’ families .
this was family rivalry nothing else.she being dalit has nothing to do with it.
cast system exists in india but it is nowhere near comparable to taliban..they are not terrorists,they don't fight with ak 47 and boobs and suicide attacks,they are just conservatives may it can be compared to racism prevailed in other parts of the world.but things are improved largely.

 

[farhan_9909]

is thier any place in this world wher incident like this nt happens?

i want to go their..

why the fuckk they rape a girl cant they pay to the prostitututes

 

[Spring Onion]

Sorry I don't understand, why the girl's caste is important in the context of the news when she was raped because of a family feud? It's wasn't mentioned in the source so the thread-starter must have been added it for a purpose, it would be good if he clarifies the same.

Girl is Dalit, accepted, but she is also poor, destitute, helpless etc, why the sudden stress on Dalit identifier.

1. The thread Starter has NOT added the word Dalit. Its all over your Indian media. It is suggested you should check the sources its mentioning the cast.


2. why they mentioned the cast ? may be because the feud is between high cast hindus and her low cast family.

 

[LaBong]

1. The thread Starter has NOT added the word Dalit. Its all over your Indian media. It is suggested you should check the sources its mentioning the cast.

Please have a look on the original news headline as quoted as by the TS as source.

Girl's limbs chopped off for resisting gangrape - India News - IBNLive

2. why they mentioned the cast ? may be because the feud is between high cast hindus and her low cast family.

There is no such report that she is raped because of her caste.

 

[Spring Onion]

According to some reports, the ghastly incident was the result of an ongoing feud between the victim ’ s and assailants’ families .
this was family rivalry nothing else.she being dalit has nothing to do with it.
cast system exists in india but it is nowhere near comparable to taliban..they are not terrorists,they don't fight with ak 47 and boobs and suicide attacks,they are just conservatives may it can be compared to racism prevailed in other parts of the world.but things are improved largely.

denying is a not a good thing specially when this social evil of cast system is prevalent in India. you can deny the reason in this case but what about this following incident and mind you its also in the same new year 2011

Dalit woman resists rape, set ablaze in Punjab
Neel Kamal, TNN, Jan 17, 2011, 12.39am IST

Dalit woman resists rape, set ablaze in Punjab
Neel Kamal, TNN, Jan 17, 2011, 12.39am IST


MANSA (Punjab): A dalit woman was set on fire in Punjab's Mansa district after she resisted the attempts of an upper caste farmer to rape her. The woman died on Sunday morning.

The accused, Sandeep Singh, was booked for murder but he is absconding, said police.

Singh and the woman lived in the same village. Her husband is a tailor while she worked as a farm labourer. On Friday evening, when she was alone at home, Singh barged in and attempted to rape her. The woman fought hard to resist him. Singh then poured kerosene on her, set her ablaze and ran away.

On hearing the women's cries, neighbours rushed to her help. Her family members took her to a Bathinda hospital. ''Her condition was grave and she was shifted to Baba Farid Medical College at Faridkot,'' her husband said.

She died of burn injuries on Sunday morning, said Behniwal police post head Rajinder Singh. Police are looking for Singh.
Dalit woman resists rape, set ablaze in Punjab - The Times of India

 

[Xestan]

Was the girl raped because of her caste? Why Dalit has been added to thread title when the actual news headline doesn't mention it?

Do we say Brahmin girl is raped if the victim is Brahim by caste? :/

Pretty pathetic of people to twist headlines to suit their own agenda. Thread reported.

Oh well, the title was with the video I posted, open your eyes.

And the word Dalit is mentioned in the news itself. Now report your eye sight.

 

[LaBong]

denying is a not a good thing specially when this social evil of cast system is prevalent in India. you can deny the reason in this case but what about this following incident and mind you its also in the same new year 2011

Once again, please show us where is it said that the girl was raped because of her caste?

People don't seem to understand it is equally horrendous and condemnable if committed on any girl irrespective of caste or status. This inhumane treatment is meted out to Brahmin girls too all over India.

 

[LaBong]

Oh well, the title was with the video I posted, open your eyes.

And the word Dalit is mentioned in the news itself. Now report your eye sight.

I know it's tough for you to flex your brain cells, but pray, tell me, since when Youtube videos are accepted as thread titles?

 

[Spring Onion]

Please have a look on the original news headline as quoted as by the TS as source. There is no such report that she is raped because of her caste Girl's limbs chopped off for resisting gangrape - India News - IBNLive.

This is what India today said A

Arvind Kumar, Reeta's cousin, said the accused had political connections. "They are very close to panchayat level politicians of the ruling BSP and the police," he said.

one wonders which cast these influential could belong to ? certainly not to low cast.

Dalit girl's limbs cut off for resisting rape in Uttar Pradesh - India - DNA

This is what Indian media is saying and using the word Dalit too

Body parts of a 16-year-old dalit girl was allegedly chopped off by three youths when she resisted rape attempt in Bindaki area, police said today.

Three youths forcibly dragged the girl, when she had gone out for some work, into a field and attempted to rape her late last night, superintendent of police Ram Bharose said, adding that one of them had been arrested.

He said when the girl resisted the rape attempt and raised alarm, the trio chopped off her nose, ear and part of hand.

The girl was later rushed to the district hospital from where she was referred to Kanpur in a serious condition.

The SP said an FIR had been lodged against the trio.

 

[Xestan]

I know it's tough for you to flex your brain cells, but pray, tell me, since when Youtube videos are accepted as thread titles?

Since today, when I started this thread, Got problem?

The video is uploaded on your own Bharati News Channel on Youtube.

I have NOT violated any Forum rules and you should now stop diverting the discussion.

 

[Spring Onion]

Once again, please show us where is it said that the girl was raped because of her caste?

People don't seem to understand it is equally horrendous and condemnable if committed on any girl irrespective of caste or status. This inhumane treatment is meted out to Brahmin girls too all over India.

Forget the cast for a moment and accept the reality that you Indians here are trying to shy away with a grusome crime like chopping off of nose, and limbs with an Axe. My God how these Indians who committed this crime are different than Taliban ?

as far as the word Dalit you should ask your media why they have used the word? because they know very well what happened and who did it. The upper cast Hindus did it with a lower cast .


anyway as far as video is concerned it was on ToI with same title and made its way to Youtube with same title now you accept it or not.

But do have some heart and also advocate the same criticism for such incidents in India and done by Hindus which you air against those in other parts of the world

 

[LaBong]

Girl's limbs chopped off for resisting gangrape - India News - IBNLive

This is what India today said A


one wonders which cast these influential could belong to ? certainly not to low cast.

The ruling party is Bahujan Samajbadi Party, a party of Dalits, by Dalits, for Dalits. And headed by a Dalit.

The social heredity of rapist and raped is irrelevant unless that is the reason of the rape. The rapist could just have seen her as just another sack of meat.

 

[Spring Onion]

The ruling party is Bahujan Samajbadi Party, a party of Dalits, by Dalits, for Dalits. And headed by a Dalit.

The social heredity of rapist and raped is irrelevant unless that is the reason of the rape. The rapist could just have seen her as just another sack of meat.

you are still shying away from condemning the barbarism by your Indians with your Indian girl by chopping her nose and limbs.

the onus is on your media for mentioning her cast NOT on us so instead of wrongly reporting us it would be good to report your own media

 

[LaBong]

Forget the cast for a moment and accept the reality that you Indians here are trying to shy away with a grusome crime like chopping off of nose, and limbs with an Axe. My God how these Indians who committed this crime are different than Taliban ?

as far as the word Dalit you should ask your media why they have used the word? because they know very well what happened and who did it. The upper cast Hindus did it with a lower cast .


anyway as far as video is concerned it was on ToI with same title and made its way to Youtube with same title now you accept it or not.

But do have some heart and also advocate the same criticism for such incidents in India and done by Hindus which you air against those in other parts of the world

It's hard for you to go beyond the religion, caste etc. It has nothing to do with religion, but humanity.

Anyway I think I have put my point across.