Y-DNA haplogroups don't even give half the story, and seriously, you just said it AGAIN. Russians have more in common with Arabs than with Germans or Swedes or English? Are you insane? Do you know how funny this makes you sound?
Besides, I just provided a plethora of studies for you. No one in the scientific community disagrees. The genetic relatedness between Italians and Greeks for example makes it impossible to tell them apart with current genetic sequencing techniques.
So, are the Italians also West Asians? No, they're not, and nor are Greeks.
And what does that even mean, "popular kind". What a dumb excuse. What you mean is, the data doesn't fit the way you want it to, so you're going to pretend like it's just "wrong".