faithfulguy
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2009
- Messages
- 13,651
- Reaction score
- -2
- Country
- Location
I think a direct answer would have been more appropriate
That Yes Indian weapons are much superior to Chinese weapons...(imported or not doesnt matter)
I would have liked u now and would like you in future to accept this more openly than the grudging manner in which u accepted it in ur above post.....
now for ur second point:
WHatever India is building- an weapon is with TOT or in collaboration with West/Russian scientific community....
it is unlike China which is working in isolation.....
So whatever weapon India will make in future also will always be superior to Chinese weapon(because of TOT or West/Russian collaboration)
Secondly Indian scientific communities capabilities are renowed world over....they are as good as the west/russian when provided the right kind of resources....and even better sometimes...Infact we will catch up with west/russian standards much much earlier than China....
And i dont see China reaching anywhere near Russia/West Tech for decades...
p.s:
ur suggestion that China will lead away in Tech from India is funny and laughable coz currently India got much better techology capability in defence sector than CHina...it is pure R&D as compared to copying done by China....going in future India will pull away furthur than now greatly from China and leapfrom many times ahead in Technology..
U learn 50 times more and ur Technological abilities increase manifold when u do ur own R&D.... copying results in 2 things:
a) poor quality of weapons as compared to original
b) no benefit to scientific mind of a scientist
the scientists which are habitual at copying become redundant and can ony do that- copying...
In terms of strategic weapons, I believe that everyone agrees that China is more advance than India, is that true or are there any Indians believe that India is superior to China in this regard? What I mean by strategic weapons is ICBM, SLBM and long range bombers like B2 spirit.
The contention between Indians and Chinese appears to be on the tactical weapons. The Indian guys believe that Russian/Western base system are far superior to that of the Chinese systems. Is that true all across the board or its only certain items. Forgive me as I'm not an expert on current weaponry.
I'm not even quite knowledgeable on US weapons but for example, I believe on one can argue that US F22 is superior to anything Indian AF has. Also, US tanks, surface ships, any kind tactical missiles, either is AA, SAM or Anti Ship, precision bombs, anti tank misisle and even small firearms are totally superior to anything in the Indian inventory. If anyone want to dispute with me, please let me know.
The reason I post the paragraph above is not to compare the US vs Indian system, as its no comparason. But to show how the Chinese/Indian tactical weapons can be compared. This is trickier because any Indian weapons that can compete with China are base on imported or ToT. I do not know all the details. So to start out, with the similar category of comparason I have above, would anyone from China/India detail the comparason between the weaponry in China and India and why one is better than the other. Also, I'm not interested in numerical superiority. Another thing, if anyone want to add more category for comparason, feel free to do sy. Please limit only in tactical weapons as no one sells strategic weapons to India so the comparason is not as interesting.