What's new

China red-flags India’s entry into NSG, may push for Pakistan

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
BEIJING: China on Monday reacted coldly to strong indications that the United States would back India for a membership of the Nuclear Suppliers Group, with the Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying cautioning that any such move "requires very careful consideration from all member countries".

"We support the group carrying out discussions on admitting new members, and at the same time we encourage India to take next steps to satisfy the relevant standards of the group," Hua said, indicating India should first accept the Non-Proliferation Treaty before aspiring for a place in the NSG.

NSG controls almost all international nuclear trade; its membership enables countries to freely use technology and nuclear material from other nations.

READ ALSO: Joint declaration on South China Sea may irk Bejing

The spokeswoman's statement revealed serious differences between the perceptions of the Chinese government and US President Barack Obama, who has backed India's case during his ongoing visit to New Delhi.

Hua also said the issue is of the 48-member NSG "admitting new members" instead of confining the debate to India. Observers here believe China, which has helped Pakistan build two nuclear power plants, would lobby for a seat for Islamabad in the NSG if the US pushes for India.

China's opposition could hurt India's chances of joining the NSG because many of its members believe that acceptance of NPT — an international treaty that prevents signatories from acquiring nuclear weapons — is an essential prerequisite. The United States and Britain have backed India regardless.

READ ALSO: Can't iron out differences in just 3 days, China says

"We believe that such (an) inclusion should be conducive to the integrity and effectiveness of the regime and decision should be made on consensus. We notice India's commitment to relevant issues," Hua said, suggesting China seems to think India does not meet all the conditions for a seat in the NSG.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi had on Sunday said President Obama has assured him of strong US efforts in support of India's full membership of the four international export control regimes at the earliest, and indication of US backing for NSG membership.

China is emerging as a major exporter of nuclear technology and would want to control NSG's membership. By saying that the "decision should be made on consensus", it has indicated it will play an active role in NSG's decision making on India's case.


China red-flags India’s entry into NSG, may push for Pakistan - The Times of India
 
. .
Our safety is any way better than the so called self proclaimed superpower that proliferated nuclear technology by leaking Nuke kit and technology to other nations including a South Asian nation.
Neither we stolen or bought anyone tech nor we proliferated our hard earned indigenous nuke tech.
I hope if US could gave us a waiver in NSG they can also ensure our memebership in NSG
 
.
Our safety is any way better than the so called self proclaimed superpower that proliferated nuclear technology by leaking Nuke kit and technology to other nations including a South Asian nation.
Neither we stolen or bought anyone tech nor we proliferated our hard earned indigenous nuke tech.
I hope if US could gave us a waiver in NSG they can also ensure our memebership in NSG

Whining about China's help to Pakistan in the nuclear weaponry field is pointless since your Uncle Obama who is backing your country (India) for NSG membership today is the head of state of the same country (United States) which, along with France handed over nuclear weaponry know-how to Israel.

Ignorance of historical facts does not hand you the license to discharge pointless rants.

China will make sure that India does not get access to NSG unless it signs the NPT otherwise the NSG loses whatever credibility it currently has.
 
. . . .
Even with the proliferation track record?


Does NOT matter. What matters is the criteria that every member of the NSG must be a signatory to the NPT. United States, Britain, Australia, etc can keep handing unofficial waivers to India to generate business for their firms by grabbing a piece of the Indian nuclear pie but official NSG membership is a wet-dream much like India's aim to become a permanent UNSC member.
 
. . .
Could be ( I am happy if that is the case)..... But then security (instead of safety in this case) is provided based on threat perception.....

Regardless of how India perceives, Pakistan in effect is in a deal with China for a full fledged nuclear industry. We can easily trade fuel with China for meeting our energy demands.
 
.
Pakistan never engaged in proliferation, AQK did, his network was shut. Lets not talk about proliferation, we all know who provided nukes to Israel.
And got President's pardon immediately for the proliferation. The good doctor on record has indicted pakistani government of complicity....

If this doctor was not held guilty for treason because of his unilateral role in proliferation, then remind me why is the other doctor in prison.
 
.
And got President's pardon immediately for the proliferation. The good doctor on record has indicted pakistani government of complicity....

If this doctor was not held guilty for treason because of his unilateral role in proliferation, then remind me why is the other doctor in prison.

AQK can't be punished, we told US squarely and they haven't made any fuss since.
 
.
Regardless of how India perceives, Pakistan in effect is in a deal with China for a full fledged nuclear industry. We can easily trade fuel with China for meeting our energy demands.

There is nothing new in that, but we are discussing about stopping India's entry to NSG and pushing Pakistan's entry to NSG, I dono if you could see the hypocrisy in it...... the out come of all this, will be a Delayed entry for India to NSG, and a further delayed entry of pakistan to NSG (if it really happens)
 
.
[QUOTE="NaMaloom, post: 6705607, member: 165675"]Does NOT matter. What matters is the criteria that every member of the NSG must be a signatory to the NPT. .[/QUOTE]
Post of the day, I have to say... your take is proliferation doesn't matter.... what matters is member must be signatory to NPT- NON-PROLIFERATION TREATY .... Epic
 
.
Back
Top Bottom